Discussly

Politics Debate Topics for Students — page 24

2,667 debate topics, students. Debatable motions with arguments for and against. Open the arguments below, pick one at random, or present them full-screen.

StudentsDebatePage 24 of 54
  1. 1151.

    Quebec should be recognized as a sovereign state

    For

    • Canada consists of two separate nations There are a number of definitions of "nation," but its basic essence refers to people who are in effective control of a territory in which they form a majority, and have unifying characteristics, such as language, culture, and tradition.…
    • The economic situation in Quebec is favourable. In terms of income per capita Quebec is less indebted than other countries. Quebec's economic performance is surprising and they're doing pretty well. Right now Quebec is just a province without control over all their means.…

    Against

    • You plagiarized the round 2 from here: http://decurions25.rssing.com... And your round 3 from here: http://canadiandimension.com... Quebec is a trashy place and I am the only one who made my own arguments.
    • Boring http://www.youtube.com...
  2. 1152.

    Liberty should take priority over state security

    For

    • I will keep the opening argument brief. The topic says it all. I believe liberty is more important than the security of the state.

    Against

    • Donlatt, why did you even start this topic? You ruined a great debate. Wow, I wish I had 100 characters right now.
    • I win. Are we at 100 characters yet??????????????? Are we at 100 characters yet??????????????? Are we at 100 characters yet???????????????
  3. 1153.

    America cannot be great again without nationalizing housing

    For

    • At the time of writing of the this debate argument, America is 20 Trillion in debt to foreigners. That means you and everyone in your family, including your children, owes $60,000 dollars to the rest of the world. This debt occurs when America imports more than it exports. Many…
    • I apologize. I'm new here and was in a dilemma. I wanted to say all of that. I guess I'll have to start being less wordy. I'll try to get to know the rules better. Instead of quoting, which would take up so much space, I'll try to sum up statements. I just didn't want to hear,…

    Against

    • So this debate breaks down really simply. In order for a policy action to actually be something that's can be implimented, there has to be some sort of reason to believe that the plan is going to work as it's intended. Otherwise, why would we want to impliment it in the first…
    • Whoa, whoa, whoa, let's back up a second.Breaking the character limit on the debate by using an outside source is extremely abusive and unfair.First, character limits exist in the debates for a reason, so that we can keep voters from reading novels for every round. Arbitrarily…
  4. 1154.

    Countries should adopt open borders for living and travel

    For

    • I find many of your arguments to be things that are inevitable in today's world or in general. 1. "Terrorists can go in and terrorize our citizens." Terrorists already come in. And is it okay that the U.S. government intervenes with other countries' business? Such as Middle…
    • I believe the borders of all countries should be open and free for all humans. If one lives in the U.S. and wants to live in Cuba or travel to Germany, they should need no passport or visa. We as humans should be able to go where we please on this Earth. This debate can be…

    Against

    • Please vote
    • On 9/11, the dead included eight children: five on American Airlines Flight 77 ranging in age from 3 to 11, three on United Airlines Flight 175 ages 2, 3, and 4. The youngest victim was a 2-1/2-year-old child on Flight 175. Overall, more than 55,000 people have been killed in…
  5. 1155.

    Extremist political movements succeed only in the short term

    For

    • You can change my mind on the topic as I am new to this. (Authoritarianism will not count for this argument) I will establish 2 arguments; 1. Extremist regimes generally establish basic needs (education, Wealth-fare, Housing, Jobs) early on in the starting of the government or…

    Against

    • Ok.
    • Oh!
  6. 1156.

    The electoral college should be abolished

    For

    • Polls show that Americans would prefer a popular vote over an electoral college.
    • The electoral college is undemocratic because it is not based on the popular vote:

    Against

    • The electoral college forces candidates to campaign to the entire country
    • The electoral college favors a strong two-party system:
  7. 1157.

    The US Electoral College should be replaced

    For

    • My opponent has forfeited and has not refuted any of my claims. I extend all arguments.
    • My opponent has forfeited and has not refuted any of my claims. I extend all arguments.

    Against

    • I accept your challenge.
    • Argument Electoral colleges are "a body of electors; especially: one that elects the president and vice president of the United States."Source:[1]: http://www.merriam-webster.com...PresidencyBy the help of the electoral colleges a specific individual will be able to gain…
  8. 1158.

    The United States should adopt single-payer healthcare

    For

    • My opponent plagiarized, http://www.watchblog.com... Conduct point pro, also I think that her points are irrelevant due to this, but I will rebut them anyway. Rationing The US already rations care. Except the way the US rations care is more deceptive, it is based on income. If…
    • C1: Cost savings from single payerIt is a common myth that single payer would increase costs to the government and raise current deficits. But many federal studies have shown that the overall cost saving would be extremely large, 100-200 billion dollars in savings. If you are…

    Against

    • *No Plagiarism intended. All sources are put at end of debate in last round. My opponent addressed some reasons for why universal health care is reasonable and I got this work because I personally know the author. (Robert Fojo) Who gave me permission to use his work. Conduct to…
    • Problem 1: It inevitably must ration care.My opponent claims that cost will not be driven up by single payer health care but a single-payer system is a "free-for-all system," where costs are driven up. Patients are likely to over-use health services because they don't have to…
  9. 1159.

    Socialism would create a more just society

    For

    • Social will bring about a more just society.
    • "It pays according to effort but through wealth distribution, the same money that the harder workers earned, is given to those making their way by. Winston Churchill once noted, "The inherent virtue of socialism is the equal sharing of miseries." This being said, a socialist…

    Against

    • Those countries you mentioned above all have a variation of a socialistic society, but to what expense does that come? In return, those countries pay higher taxes that take even more wealth from the people and the revenue collected is used in turn for government programs such…
    • You are thinking of communism." Communism is indeed a more extreme version of socialism. Socialism doesn't discourage work directly. It pays according to effort but through wealth distribution, the same money that the harder workers earned, is given to those making their way…
  10. 1160.

    Governance of the United States should be split between the two major parties

    For

    • How Congress Works
    • Checks and balances

    Against

    • Growing partisanship
    • Effect on democratic participation
  11. 1161.

    Fascism can be more effective than democracy

    For

    • Hello all I'm starting another debate I believe Facism can be more effective than Democracy Facism: an authoritarian and nationalistic system of government and social organization Democracy: a system of government by the whole population or all the eligible members of a state,…
    • My opponent has FF'd all the debate rounds Vote for Reformist!

    Against

    • Facism is bad for the country and is terrible for the people Also i see that you are a liberal but facism is a right wing idealogy So i dont understand your standing?
  12. 1162.

    Saudi Arabia should become a democracy

    For

    • I thank you for your advice but i do not fall. I will continue with my arguments with why i do not utterly fail this debate but in fact win. This debate will decide on my two point: 1. As what we are fighting on this debate today is about that we should bring democracy in Saudi…
    • Well my opponent says that i have violated some rule. First off, There is no rule in debate saying that in FORM. That is not what this debate is about. It is about attacking and making a case. And second of all my opponent said i do plagiarism but first off have you been to a…

    Against

    • 1. "And second of all my opponent said i do plagiarism but first off have you been to a really debate tournament. I guess thats a know with the knowledge he gave me. That is what you are suppose to do in debate. Find evidence and print it out. So you attacking my whole argument…
    • 1. "Attacking my opponents case:My opponent's only argument is saying people like the way they are....."The format laid out by the instigator and agreed to by the contender (implied by him accepting this debate) was that R1 is acceptance, R2 is arguments, and R3&4 are for…
  13. 1163.

    A just government should provide healthcare to its citizens

    For

    • I will be arguing the affirmative side of a just government should provide health care to its citizens. Martin Luther king jr. once said; "that Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in health care is the most shocking and inhumane." If the people, our people the ones we…
    • Okay ill forfeit!!!! its not that important!!!! Im sorry that this is my first debate that my high school teacher is forcing us to do i can really care less!!!

    Against

    • I am actually on the fence about this issue. Perhaps this debate will allow me to learn enough to take a defined stance. For the purposes of this debate, I will argue against the resolution. My starting points shall be: Every human being ought to be good stewards of their own…
    • Opponent has forfeited.
  14. 1164.

    George W. Bush was a good president

    For

    • George Bush was one of america greatest leaders in American History he did many things 1. He passes massive tax relief for the american people because they needed and that setted off huge job growth for many years he greatly stimulated the economy 2. He freed Iraq took out a…

    Against

    • Win
    • Well then!
  15. 1165.

    A president with a 33% approval rating should resign

    For

    • I must say I am slightly dissapointed. I will give the benefit of the doubt to my opponent and not assume that he has conceded out of lack of rebuttal. Though I must say that it looks awfully strange that he has been here on debate.org and participating in other debates, yet…
    • Hello, I would like to clarify that I intend for this debate NOT to be specific to George W. Bush. This is a debate about presidents in general, whether they are democrats or republicans… When you are president, in this democracy, your solemn duty is to protect the interests of…

    Against

    • You are "shocked" by what I say only because you have some misconceptions about this country, and about democracy in general. While we are taught in school that democracy necessarily equals freedom, and that democratic nations are free nations that is not always the case. My…
    • First and foremost, I must apologize for my tardiness. I always hate it when someone forfeits a round, but hate it more when they forfeit all rounds. I will try to make a much greater effort to post in all rounds for now on. I think that you and I might have very similar…
  16. 1166.

    Protest during the national anthem should be acceptable

    For

    • I'm not going to make this long because you seem to lack interest, and you copy and paste your first response for your second. First off let me say again that it is only acceptable if you accept it as such. So in reality, this is up to you. Second; sitting, kneeling, and…
    • Alas, it is only disrespectful because you believe it is disrespectful. I accept the debate. I will allow the Con to make the first point in the next round.

    Against

    • These quotes come from football players, but can be transferred: "It was our goal to be unified as a team and to be respectful of everyone"s opinions, and the remembrance of 9/11," the team said in a statement. "It"s our job as professional athletes to make a positive impact on…
    • It is proven that doing one of those three things is being disrespectful to the flag, which means you are being disrespectful to America!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  17. 1167.

    The United States has a moral obligation to mitigate international conflicts

    For

    • Indeed, if my opponent paid any attention to these sources, he would have easily found they were the sources from an article on "The 20th Century Russian Civil War" However, only some of the sources listed on the article were supporting my side. These sources are books, most…
    • ^ Jump up to: a b Williams, Beryl, The Russian Revolution 1917"1921, Blackwell Publishing Ltd. (1987), ISBN 978-0-631-15083-1, ISBN 0-631-15083-8 Jump up ^ Overy, R.J., The Dictators: Hitler's Germany and Stalin's Russia, W.W. Norton & Company (2004), ISBN 0-393-02030-4, ISBN…

    Against

    • Despite my explicitly voiced concerns, the instigator chose to continue in making false historical claims, and as I said before ... I find this to be shameful. In my closing remark I will not repeat myself nor my unaddressed issues a fourth time as there is no possibility for…
    • A point of order: In his last rebuttal the opponent cites a wide array of sources, supposedly to support his case. But what the instigator has done is simply copied a list of references of a Wikipedia article. In other words, he has cited sources he does not know in support of…
  18. 1168.

    The American invasion of Afghanistan was justifiable

    For

    • Thank you once again for your reply. I regret that I will not be able to debate with you fully because of your personal businesses. In rebuttal to your point that wars are bad...that is a generalization that is sometimes wrong. Was the war against Nazi Germany bad? Was it wrong…
    • Thank you for your reply First of all, in your rebuttal to my first point you replied that and I quote, "even if Afghanistan did harbor the criminals who committed the attacks, that does not justify attacking the whole country" However, if your neighbor kills a loved one and…

    Against

    • I disagree with a lot of what you said but unfortunately am really busy right now and don't have time to pick your argument apart. So I will simply respond to your statement that the war in Afghanistan is justified because you have refuted my rebuttals. However, my rebuttals…
    • Even if your point were true, we would not be justified in invading Afghanistan. War kills innocent people, not the people who we are truly against. However, even if you can justify war, especially offensive war, attacking Afghanistan is not justified. Your first point was that…
  19. 1169.

    Governments should substantially curtail domestic surveillance

    For

    • Please only accept if you are familiar with this topic and know what the government has done in order to use surveillance to collect information from citizens of this country. First round is acceptance round. Please state your argument and define all the terms in the topic…

    Against

    • Being that the burden of proof is on the opponent and he has failed to present a case, I cannot present any arguments in opposition and thus should win automatically assuming the opponent doesn't argue in any of the following rounds.
    • Being that the burden of proof is on the opponent and he has failed to present a case, I cannot present any arguments in opposition and thus should win automatically assuming the opponent doesn't argue in any of the following rounds.
  20. 1170.

    American democracy best promotes humanity's most important values

    For

    • I am sure that no matter the outcome, this will be a very worthwhile experience for both of us. With that being said I would like to administrate some very basic guidelines for this round. I request that this debate be conducted in a formal, professional and constructive…
    • I apologize to my opponent for my lack of participation in the previous round. I regret to announce that I have had and will be having some unexpected schedule conflicts in the next few days. Perhaps we could carry on this debate at a later time?

    Against

    • Feel free to challenge me any time :)
    • Thats unfortunate. Hopefully my opponent will be back next round!
  21. 1171.

    Governments should prioritize climate policy over short-term economic growth

    For

    • In his initial comments, CON has made several claims, which I will list here for clarity's sake: 1) The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change issues propaganda in an attempt to "strike fear into gullible people," with the purpose of "creating green guilt. " 2) The phrase…
    • I thank CON for offering his comments this final round. I will do my best to address everything that is relevant, since I have been accused of not doing so. Agenda 21 CON has accused me of not addressing Agenda 21. Agenda 21 is a document prepared by the United Nations which…

    Against

    • Sorry, but your response is nothing more then repeating what I said which is no response at all in essence. The fact is that the IPCC has released junk data as gospel truth repeatedly, and therefore we have to look at who is funding them and what their motivation is. The…
    • The propaganda issued by the IPCC in respect to 97% of scientists believing in AGW is nothing but a very successful attempt to strike fear into gullible people so they will fall in line willingly with Agenda 21. This is the science of creating green guilt, nothing more. Global…
  22. 1172.

    Public display of the Confederate flag should be banned

    For

    • First of all exactly It is not a threat to national security however it is the flag of a force that was. Secondly you make an excellent point, however if we are going to look at it from two sides let me tell you what it represents here, apparently in northern Pennsylvania…
    • I do not completely want them removed as I said in my opening statement which apparently my opponent did not read ,I believe that to some extent they should be removed, for instance as a historical and respectable approach to the civil war they should play a major role, however…

    Against

    • You would think there are no troubles where I live, but Lancaster county is different from other parts of Pennsylvania. There are a whole group of racist students and confederate flag wearing rednecks. Yes, many of them do think black people are inferior. There was even a day a…
    • "In my views the confederate flag represents a threat to national security" No tense was specified. "We must remember that the confederate flag does not represent the fun wild south it represents a rebellion of men fighting to uphold slavery and it should not be allowed in a…
  23. 1173.

    Japan should remove Article 9 of its constitution

    For

    • In this round I'll be summarizing my main arguments in point form. -Article 9 is an infringement of Japan's sovereignty. -Article 9 was established by a foreign power, and hence is another infringement on Japan's sovereignty. -Japan has seen various belligerent organizations…
    • (I would like to note to con that round 2 was for opening arguments, as Con was not yet supposed to do his rebuttals. I will proceed with my rebuttals in this round) " This simply doesn't make sense. This damages Japan's sovereignty? Well, if Japan was to reorganise a military,…

    Against

    • I didn't know round two was for opening arguments, and I apologise to Pro as you are not going by standardised formatting. Yes, they, as an independent country, are unable to mobilise their army. However, it is vital to global peace that countries that once killed 9 million…
    • 1, sovereignty. This simply doesn't make sense. This damages Japan's sovereignty? Well, if Japan was to reorganise a military, it would not only be country's sovereignty at risk. I think Japan, legal stuff aside, does not deserve right of military and IS NOT AFFECTED if a…
  24. 1174.

    Communism has morally admirable goals

    For

    • In a capitalist society I as the proletariat am required to work long hours in terrible conditions for the privilege of not being a hobo. Also, the proletariat is not a Roman people, but the oppressed. I would NEVER take anyone's money I would BURN it. Capitalism degrades the…
    • The Moral Demand of Communism is the liberastartion of the proletariat or the poir; my argument stated thus. And I assume you are claiming that I steal. Capitalist society steals people. You force others to work in appalling conditions just to get by. This is immoral. Economic…

    Against

    • Capitalism offers people a better quality of living than they otherwise would be able to afford, but enable to get something out of the system, you need to put something into the system. Enable to not be a hobo, you need a house, and houses require resources to build and…
    • You honestly don't know what you're talking about, no one is forced to work in capitalism, the exchanges are volluntary. The poor aren't enslaved, and the proletarians were an ancient Roman group. Capitalism doesn't steal people,it doesn't steal anything, that's communism.…
  25. 1175.

    Nuclear weapons have benefited the world overall

    For

    • Hello, I would like to debate the topic of whether Nuclear weapons have helped the world, or harmed it. I will be taking the "Pro" side, and supporting the fact that nuclear weapons have helped our society.
    • In your argument you stated that if terrorists got their hands on and atomic level weapon, the world would possibly end, is an obvious fallacy known as "argument from consequences." If in the extreme and unlikely case that they bombed a nation, that nation most likely would not…

    Against

    • "In your argument you --- not mindless"I would like to clarify that by stating 'Let us consider the scenario -- put all human life in danger', I only meant that every human will be at risk as terrorists (or ISIS) could possibly destroy any city they wanted, such that no one…
    • As there is an ambiguity regarding the interpretation of the topic of debate, I will interpret it as 'nuclear weapons have helped the world become a better place'. This so called 'peace' is nothing but a calm before the storm. Let us consider the scenario when such weapons get…
  26. 1176.

    A communist society is impossible to achieve

    For

    • The first thing wrong with Marxism is the idea of a moneyless society. This can't be implemented because trading goods and services is done much better with money than without if it was all gone trade and production would come to a grinding halt the economy of the world would…
    • I'll be arguing that the Marxist vision of a "true communist society" is unrealistic and impossible.

    Against

    • The resolution, "The Marxist vision of a communist society is unrealistic and impossible." is negated.
    • Thank you for being open minded- Karl Marx was a remarkable philosopher, and his works are still well studied today by many scholars. Needless to say, academic Marxism (where interpretations of Marx's works are rigorously standardized) is rather different from your average…
  27. 1177.

    State building efforts have improved stability in Somalia

    For

    • Why Somalia still in war?

    Against

    • Pro has failed to fulfill BoP obligations. Therefore, I win by default.
    • Thus far, Pro has failed to affirm the resolution, as the question, "Why Somalia still in war?" fails to prove the resolution: "The effect of State building in Somalia on political stability". Hence, I further await Pro's BoP fulfillment.
  28. 1178.

    Socialism inevitably requires a ruling elite

    For

    • 1. Socialism requires authoritarian rule of economic society Con did not disagree that government must perform functions I listed in (a) – (e), nor did he disagree that government has the unique ability to use force to compel people to obey it's decisions. In a free economy,…
    • 1. Socialism requires authoritarian rule of economic society Consider government in two parts: laws and regulations related to the economy and everything else. It's possible to have free markets and the rest of the government under authoritarian rule; Taiwan under Chiang…

    Against

    • 1. Governmental Elites and DemocracyI claim that a ruling elite that exists in a democracy is no ruling elite at all, yes. That is because democracy is more than just 51% of people agreeing with something, it covers things like freedom of expression, political freedoms, et…
    • 1. Can A Governmental Elite Exist In A Democracy?I would like to pose a question. If one has a ruling elite, then is that compatible with democracy? A ruling elite, after all, cannot really be challenged. They are static, unchanging, elevated above the common person. An elite…
  29. 1179.

    European weapon laws should be more flexible

    For

    • Great, I look foward to hearing your views and understanding your point of view.
    • Europe has faced one of the toughest immigrant waves in the last 80 years, not only have we taken in too many immigrants for our governments to handle, these immigrants have in fact been in many cases terrorists that have struck our European union hard. My opinion is not trying…

    Against

    • Pro starts by claiming that in many cases, people that have immigrated to Europe have turned out to be terrorists. I would ask Pro to define the word "many" here given that more terrorist attacks in Europe in recent times have been committed by people that were born in those…
    • I accept.
  30. 1180.

    Communism cannot work in practice

    For

    • I know your "sorry" but how did you end up using the same argument? Wouldn't that mean you would have had to copied and pasted it. If my theory is true your argument, wasn't even your argument. Even then though, for Communism to work, you would need an entire nation of…
    • Is it just me everyone, or did the contender use the exact same argument twice! If you would try to look it up,and find out, there has never been a national based entirely off of Communist society and government. China was the closest everyone but it still had its hierarchy…

    Against

    • First I will say any type of government can fail, and any person in any nation always wants power. The only way the USA became a nation was by brainwashing the citizens to believe that monarchies are stupid because all they do is tax us. Also any government can be corrupt. So…
    • "Communism (at least how I see it) fights corruption, apathetic behavior, and encourages work ethic to increase. I know that Communism has failed in the past several times, but I still believe it to be the best government for a Society. Now people, Vote now! I want to hear your…
  31. 1181.

    Democracy is the best system of government

    For

    • Wengerocracy prevents the president to do illegal things but in democracy president just doesnt do illegal things because he is chosen by his citizens. You cant just say wengerocracy wins its just your idea its not a certain situation

    Against

    • Pay attention or taxes! Knowing if there is law is better than picking someone who says there is law. When you go into that election booth and see two candidates remember the idea to watch the one who wins. Democracy is great idea but wengerocracy is the greatest idea in…
    • knowing if there is law is better than picking someone who says there is law
  32. 1182.

    Communism can never work

    For

    • I feel that I came into the debate with a flase view of communism and sabaren has made it correcrt. I also agree with his point of view now I fully understand communism and resign from this debate.
    • Communism is a good idea but it can never work because if everyone gets paid the same amount then there is no incentive for people to work hard. Also if the state owns everything then people can never feel safe as they could lose everything. Also with communism leaders who…

    Against

    • extend
    • Thank you for the polite response. And don't worry that you didn't fully understand communism most don't really know. I hope you learned something from this debate. Have a good one.
  33. 1183.

    Interventionism is preferable to isolationism in foreign policy

    For

    • FrameworkI will admit that I am not a guy who will always be wanting to enforce a strict round structure in every debate, as I believe my opponent's and I should have a bit of freedom to structure our cases as we please. However, Con has made some framework errors that seem to…
    • Those were some interesting points by Con. His Round 2 sources are in the fifteenth comment on this debate.The Role of World PolicemanAs part of his case, Con compared the Roman Empire to the world power of today: the U.S. This is an unfair comparison on many accounts, and it…

    Against

    • FrameworkI Will agree that the way Me and Varrack did this debate made it not as we intended, However,1. I think we can all agree that we wanted a debate where Pro had a BOP and i would try to debunk his points to fulfil his BOP but however this debate ended up being both sides…
    • Rebuttal I Will be making my last two reasons why the USA should remain isolationist. Usa Interventionism has caused even more Instability than it has solved. It was been shown throughout history that as World Powers meddle in other countries affairs this has resulted in a more…
  34. 1184.

    The FCC should add warning labels to news programs

    For

    • 1) Bias in evaluating news programs"So far, Pro has not touched my major objection and really the major crux of the debate, namely defining the system"I have explained several times now how this issue is accounted for since the evaluation by the FCC or an independent body, as…
    • 1) Bias in the media"Most Americans if polled would acknowledge that while these programs have a particular angle, overall they provide a fair (unbiased, objective) portrayal"Is there any evidence that suggests that could even remotely true? The most recent polling data taken…

    Against

    • You should vote for the other side if you believe truth, objectivity, and unbiased means reciting facts, and nothing else. Pro offers a twenty-four hour equivalent of a CSPAN camera, completely unfiltered, non-partisan, and totally disinterested. Or we can take this a step…
    • Good round—let's proceed. So far, Pro has not touched my major objection and really the major crux of the debate, namely defining the system. Without examples of "truly unbiased," "neutral," and "objective," terminology I admit people find favorable but favorable in the same…
  35. 1185.

    American political leaders serve themselves rather than the public

    For

    • Incorrect.
    • If the big dogs aren't blowing the money, then why are there artificial private islands being made, that are even mobile mind you, and houses worth over millions of dollars. Tell me that's necessary. While the people down here are working every day to put food on the plate.…

    Against

    • If the big dogs aren't blowing the money, then why are there artificial private islands being made, that are even mobile mind you, and houses worth over millions of dollars. Those two are completely unrelated to each other. Just because dogs aren't blowing money (for they'll…
    • I believe they are because no one can deny the direction this country is heading, Well, that depends where you think this country is heading. I can deny that this country is heading towards a zombie apocalypse but I could say that I don't deny that this country is heading for…
  36. 1186.

    The House of Lords should be reformed

    For

    • Reform would strengthen the House of Lords
    • The House of Lords is out of touch with the electorate.

    Against

    • Democracy should not be the end-point aspiration of government.
    • The House of Lords allows a number of experts to influence government policy.
  37. 1187.

    The United States should have open borders

    For

    • Do you have any evidence that says closing borders reduces disease spread? No of course not. Your second point admits your concession. Thank your for that.
    • Diseases spread regardless, so this argument is not unique to a stronger/open border, therefore can be disregarded. My opponent fails to refute my question from Round 2 on terrorism, therefore extend that argument across the flow. I win offense on this. We might as well have…

    Against

    • 1. Disease May spread anyway but lowering immigration and increasing border security will decrease foreing diseases that come from continents like Africa and Asia, and Europe that is the equivalent to saying "Murders happen anyway so why stop them". 2. I disregarded your…
    • 1.The Spread Of Disease many illegals come from some of the poorest communities with little access to health care they may carry diseases such as scabies, TB, MRSA or staph, Which intern would cause a safety risk for Americans and about non-citizens i could careless as they do…
  38. 1188.

    Unilateral nuclear disarmament is the best way to create a safer world

    For

    • There will be less nuclear weapons
    • Unilateral disarmament will encourage others to disarm.

    Against

    • Would anyone disarm?
  39. 1189.

    Puerto Rico should become a US state

    For

    • This was a good debate. Here is my summary.- Race should not affect politics, and the governments of Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands are already simmilar.- Virgin Islanders should get recognition on a national level, even if that recognition is little. - The US would benefit…
    • Yeah, sorry about the forfeit. I misjudged the how much time I had. Anyways. .. Further, the Virgin Islands racial majority of blacks[2] would instantly become a small racial minority, trumped by the 99% Hispanic majority in Puerto Rico. [Race should have nothing to do with…

    Against

    • Before I start, I would like to note my opponent has not responded to any of my rebuttals to him, and has instead ignored them. These ignored points include the requirement for minority-majority districts, and the fact that both islands don't pay income tax. He has also not…
    • I appreciate my opponent responding for this round.My opponent's first argument is that race should have nothing to do with politics. Ideally, yes, but southern states are obligated to create minority-majority districts (ie. districts designed entirely because of race) in both…
  40. 1190.

    Nuclear arms reduction treaties make the world safer

    For

    • New START important to Russian cooperation on missile defense.
    • Russia will build-up nuclear arms without New START.

    Against

    • New START would constrain new weapons and defense systems.
    • US should not sign New START to bribe Russia on Iran.
  41. 1191.

    Bad politicians should face deportation after leaving office

    For

    • "deporting bad politicians from the U. S. would lead to some unfortunate results for them. " THATS THE POINT "Since America is a global power and it's policies affect the entire world, many, many people would love to get their hands on an unpopular president. " THATS THE POINT…
    • How does the US have a huge margin of error? When Barack Obama gave his speech on "You didnt build that" he messed up on one pronoun and Republicans have centered their entire election campaign around it! If you mess up in America it resonates and grows to ridiculous…

    Against

    • "Look, the whole point of this idea is to make politicians own up to their screwups and experience firsthand how they have alienated the world and even many Americans from trusting the US government because of their actions and screwups."I'm sorry but I'm still not getting…
    • "How does the US have a huge margin of error?"I meant that the U.S. was more powerful and in a better position, and could afford to make mistakes.Israel: Population: 8 million.GDP: $235.222 billion.Area: 20,770 km2Military spending: $13 billion.Surrounded by hostile countries…
  42. 1192.

    The United States should not intervene in Syria

    For

    • The United states should not supply, aide or intervene in the Syrian conflict in any way. For the purposes of this debate, I am referring to Government intervention, not private humanitarian aide to the refugees, etc.
    • As a single footstep will not make a path on the earth, so a single thought will not make a pathway in the mind. To make a deep physical path, we walk again and again. To make a deep mental path, we must think over and over the kind of thoughts we wish to dominate our lives.…

    Against

    • Glad to be debating on this subject. I'll be taking the stance that the United States should intervene in Syria.
    • I'm very sorry. I couldn't create a rebuttal to your post nor solid arguments supporting an intervention in Syria.
  43. 1193.

    Government should not punish a person for harmless actions

    For

    • The points are solid points, yet most will disagree.
    • My premise is that harmless actions should not be against the law and should not lead to a trial. Looking at an extreme example of Driving Under the Influence (DUI), which most people agree is a serious crime. Mothers Against Drunk Driving implies that in 2012, 10,322 people…

    Against

    • I agree with you now so you should win :P
    • Actually, you make a good point so let's say you win :P
  44. 1194.

    The US government is funding ISIS

    For

    • My answer for where the guns are coming from was actually (believe it or not) on the next line. Where I state : the CIA and George Bush are supplying the guns for ISIS. It's simple math. By triangulating the location of a few marked weapons, we can determine that they are…
    • So, your first argument is you explaining your rulesand trying to tell honest voters what to do, basically calling them stupid, which they arent, so quit trying to bribe them to win. The guns COULD be coming from anywhere else but they AREN'T!!! What do you think the CIA does…

    Against

    • I'm just going to do a line-by-line style rebuttal:"So, your first argument is you explaining your rulesand trying to tell honest voters what to do, basically calling them stupid, which they arent,"Actually, I'm attempting to help the voters out. See, generally voters shouldn't…
    • Well, thanks for this debate. While I do enjoy getting screamed at as much as the next guy, let's try to tone it down a little bit.I just have a couple things to say.1) In order for my opponent to win, he must substantiate his claims. His substatiation consist of claiming that…
  45. 1195.

    The United States should sign the Ottawa Convention banning landmines

    For

    • Landmines provide a false sense of security
    • Banning Landmines is a step towards reducing the horror of war

    Against

    • Landmines are necessary to protect South Korea
    • Landmines are easy to use illegally anyway
  46. 1196.

    Women should be barred from serving in infantry units

    For

    • To begin, I am not against women serving in armedforces. I am just against the idea of women serving on the front-lines ofinfantry. Women technically already serve in combat, but theydon't serve in infantry, and they don't bear arms like men, unless forself-defense. The purpose…
    • I will be taking Pro, and argue that women should not serve in combat. My opponent will be taking Con, and argue that women should be allowed to serve in combat.I would also like to thank Con if he accepts this debate. Round 1: AcceptanceRound 2: Opening ArgumentsRound 3:…

    Against

    • I accept the premises and format given by Pro, and will be arguing that women should be allowed to serve in combat roles in armed forces. I look forward to a productive debate.
    • Conclusion: I believe I have fairly and effectively rebutted the majority, if not the entirety, of Pro's reasons for the claim that Women should not serve in Combat-infantry roles in the military. Personal Hygiene: not an issue; possibility of embarrassment and/or 'sexual…
  47. 1197.

    Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role in democracy

    For

    • Domestic intelligence services are the only organization that is capable of performing counterintelligence
    • Domestic intelligence operates just like the police do.

    Against

    • Domestic intelligence agencies cannot be controlled
    • Intelligence agencies inflate threats.
  48. 1198.

    The Nordic model proves social democracy can work

    For

    • There seems to be a glitch i keep trying to post an argument and it won't let me, No system is pure socialist no system is pure capitalsist, I try to post links and this site gets all funny about it, The nordic model isnt socialism per say but if you went back in time most…
    • Social Democracy is not quite Socialism, As many aspects of market capitalism remain in place, Yet it tries to alleviate the harsh aspects of laisez faire capitalism, And is the ideal from of government and economy, The fact it works so well in Scandanavia proves it is possible…

    Against

    • You just said the same thing. I have already rebutted this.
    • Hopefully my rebuts are more then sufficient in proving my case. "The fact it works so well in Scandanavia proves it is possible elsewhere in the world"If you mean being highly taxed then yes it works well. Why would you want to give the government so much power? No one should…
  49. 1199.

    China is overreaching in its global influence

    For

    • I'd like to remind my opponent that many people out of 1/6th is suffering due to poverty etc. China is currently the largest emitter in greenhouse gases, it just overtook USA last month thus it is not something which is expected but something which already happened. It's the…
    • Eventhough China is a developing country, we see that it is overreaching the reason as to why we say so is that because China is hiding behind the mere banner of developing countries and not bearing the same obligations as developed nations. For example statistics reveal that…

    Against

    • l
    • 1: Greenhouse gas emissions. The fact remains uncontested that China's greenhouse gas emissions are consistent with a developing country of its size. There is no overreaching in emissions. That high levels of people remain in poverty, while undesirable, is irrelevant. 2:…
  50. 1200.

    Consumer groups should be allowed to hold public office

    For

    • Well yes I am rather modest about the scope of this proposal. In fact I wonder where you are going with objections that it is more complicated or expensive than the present system, such as that the proposal would require election reform. That is the least it would require. If…
    • I was going to work on this a little more but there is quite enough here to keep you busy for the few minutes it takes you to reply. I will let you imagine the rest. Clearly you are not a chess player. OK let's suppose we have two choices: reconstruct Congress as it is, an…

    Against

    • "Even more amusing is your objection that it would involve more people in government and make it more complicated. That is the whole point." I debated whether or not to type more than just that quote. Government is far too complicated as it is. Anything that will make it more…
    • After spending some time studying corporate law, I am still unable to find any way to protect a corporation from outside influences. The PAC's you listed were not all corporations. Seven are run by unions, the AMPAC is a PAC set up by a corporation, and after fifteen minutes of…

How to use these debate topics

  • Vote, discuss, revote. Poll the room on the motion, give 5 minutes of discussion, then vote again and look at who changed their mind.
  • Four corners. Label corners strongly agree → strongly disagree; people move, then each corner makes its best case.
  • Switch sides. Halfway through, everyone argues the side they disagree with. It sharpens listening.

Run them live

Want every person to answer on their own phone, with a timer and a live leaderboard? Use these questions in an EngageSlide Vote · Discuss · Revote — free to start.

Tick questions on any page — your set is kept while you browse (or take the first 10 here) — and they become ready-to-play slides. What is EngageSlide?

More question collections

Questions adapted from args.me corpus (CC BY 4.0), edited for clarity. This collection may be reused under the same terms — see sources & licenses.