Discussly

Economy Debate Topics — page 23

1,397 debate topics, all ages. Debatable motions with arguments for and against. Open the arguments below, pick one at random, or present them full-screen.

All agesDebatePage 23 of 28
  1. 1101.

    Poverty is best measured by income

    For

    • 'Working does help depression you forget to feel sorry for your self, and get on whit your life would you call that opportunity or just using that for not getting up in the morning.' It does help depression, however when you're so deep in depression, you actually need help, the…
    • This is more of an opinion gathered from just being aware. But since you're asking me, I won't use sites. It seems like people, after a while... kind of give up, they no longer try and seize the world and make it theirs. Instead they try and get through the next day, usually…

    Against

    • Yes giving up is an easy way out, no backbone no moral no input just plain laziness, they become a burden on the people that like to live a normal life. Working does help depression you forget to feel sorry for your self, and get on whit your life would you call that…
    • How do you end up in Poverty where there are lots of ways to make your situation better, but people can not see they have to change there way they live
  2. 1102.

    Bitcoin is fundamentally sound

    For

    • I am defending the contention that Bitcoin is fundamentally sound as money. I have defended two statements in order to prove such contention. I have stated: 1) Bitcoin meets the definition of money 2) Bitcoin is superior to its competition (ie other monies). My opponent has…
    • I respectfully disagree with my opponent but let me first thank him for stepping up to the challenge, having a polite tone, and raising some good points, despite the fact that said points do not sufficiently invalidate my stance which is that Bitcoin is a fundamentally sound…

    Against

    • I swear I was only trying to anger my opponent into denouncing the Austrian Journal I also sited. I had no idea it would destroy his reading comprehension as well. I never once referred to bitcoins as being a Ponzi Scheme. That would be slander against Ponzi's good name. I…
    • I would hardly call giving the standard definition of sound money, and a paraphrased anecdote, from libertarians, a strawman argument. You've insisted that your definition is following the historical definition of sound money. What sound money is, or is supposed to be, is…
  3. 1103.

    Governments should mandate a minimum wage

    For

    • Laws requiring employers to pay employees minimum wage is necessary in this society. If you don't have a college education or you are even just working at a grocery store as a part-time job, you must rely on your employer to pay you minimum wage. If there were no minimum wage…

    Against

    • My opponent never addressed my arguments. All my contentions stand unopposed.
    • I guess that means he agrees with me!
  4. 1104.

    Brain surgeons are paid too much

    For

    • Brain surgeons get paid $10,000 per hour. What the hell is that! No amount of skill is worth that much money. Note - Brain surgeons haven't got a clue as to how the brain actually works.
    • Quote - If the field of brain surgery is all but a game of bluff, wouldn't there be countless reports of screw ups. Why would people spend all those years in medical school learning a craft which according to you is not supported by science and potentially kill a person and…

    Against

    • You claim that the "system" makes neurosurgeons above the law, yet you have not provided a case that proves your baseless assertion. If one just googles neurosurgeon lawsuits, he/she can easily find results. Take for example this case below where a person sues a neurosurgeon…
    • Your plumber analogy is absurd. To more accurate analogy is a plumber who has to fix pipes while the water is running because patients are alive. He/she can't make any spills while doing the repairs analogous to potential blood loss in the brain. On top of that, there can be…
  5. 1105.

    On balance, capitalism is a better system for humankind than communism

    For

    • Introduction: It seems as if CON has forfeited the round and closed his account. However, there are many arguments that I wish to address in cased he returns. I will be extended all my arguments as well. Rebuttal: 1. Many travesties are the fault of capitalism Con blames many…
    • Introduction CON has sworn and ad hominem attacks that should cost him the conduct point. Examples include "No, you've talked a whole load of sh1t.". CON also believes that I broke the rules since I provided videos as sources. However, these are my sources and not my arguments.…

    Against

    • "I have demonstrates many reasons why capitalism is a superior system over communism. I look forward to CON's rebuttal." No, you've talked a whole load of sh1t. And there was dirty tactics for you. So much for a text only debate, huh? And those appeals to emotion... Wow.…
    • Yes, I will debate this topic with darkkermit.
  6. 1106.

    Taxing all sales would bring economic benefits

    For

    • If I may be so bold, Maddskillz appears to have conceded not just the last few rounds but the entire debate. I refer Readers to the points I raise in rounds 1 & 2 as My closing arguments.
    • MaddSkillz, having forfeited the prior two rounds, I ask you concede the debate officially.

    Against

    • No it will not help all the inbred rednecks would get pissed off about having to pay extra taxes
  7. 1107.

    Cutting taxes would stimulate the economy

    For

    • I would like to remind myself and the Contender that you can not bring up any new points for Round Three. It is only for rebuttals and conclusions. Thank you.…
    • With tax cuts, business owners would either expand their businesses or lower the prices. An overwhelming majority of businesses will take advantage of tax cuts for the sake of profit, either it be expanding themselves or lowering the prices. If they expand, it requires more…

    Against

    • The thing is about your sauce is its biased. Do you even know what Cato institute is? Its a libertarian website associated with right wing groups. Basically your augment is you repeating the same stuff, mostly cherry picked facts with a biased source. But then again isn't that…
    • "With tax cuts, business owners would either expand their business or lower the prices." Yeah in theory but they don't. In an ideal world maybe big business would give us a break. But people are greedy and immoral. The money wouldn't go to expanding business to give people jobs…
  8. 1108.

    Socialism is superior to capitalism

    For

    • Thank you con for the debate I had a lot of fun, I tried my best. In a capitalist society great advancements are made in the quest for improving products and services in the face of making more profit. This all sounds wonderful, but that is based solely on the economic…
    • Pro made the assertion that the United States" health care system is private. This is far from the truth."- Private health care or private medicine is health care and medicine provided by entities other than the government. That is the definition of private health care. In the…

    Against

    • In this round I'll be presenting my closing arguments. "Private" Health Insurance:Although health insurance today is issued privately, we are far from a private, free market health care system, which is the point I am making here. There are many laws, regulations, and…
    • In this round I will be providing my rebuttals to Pros arguments in the previous round. "Every developed country has some form of socialism." While this may be true to a degree, it is fallacious to equate this with the success of these countries. For example, according to the…
  9. 1109.

    Gender quotas in the EU are good for member states' economies

    For

    • Quotas encourage women to pursue education and professional job positions
    • Gender equality is based on fundamental human rights endorsed by the EU which needs to be addressed

    Against

    • There are other policy options that are less distortive and more advantageous for the economy.
    • There is no clear link between gender quota and economic growth
  10. 1110.

    Reducing the deficit should be the US's top economic priority

    For

    • What do you define as "idealistic"? In response to my opponent's questions: 1.) "I would like for you to point out instances in American history where we were prevented from doing something because of this mounting debt?" Well, the answer is quite simply never. However, never…
    • Seeing as this is a five round debate I will use this round to make some general observations and pose questions that will open avenues for arguments against my opponents. General Observations: My opponent seems to be using quite a bit of copying and pasting--his arguments are…

    Against

    • I'll be adressing the issues that were brought up in the previous post. As far as me repeating arguments- this is done because your points are basically restated from your overview to your contentions for example in the overview you stated that "when the United States…
    • My opponent argues that defecit spending is not in favor of the American working/middle/lower-class, but this argument is iherently flawed. He chooses to only select certain defecit spending measures such as the War in Iraq and Afghanistan which doesn't help the pocket books of…
  11. 1111.

    Fast food minimum wage should not rise to $15 an hour

    For

    • Summary We know McDonald's current cost structure. Raising the minimum wage at McDonald's would raise costs by 17% to 20%. That's $1.14 on a typical meal. Customers, mainly the poor and middle class, would pay more and they would tend to eat out less often. The fast food…
    • 1. Labor is now 25% to 35% of fast food costs Con did not contest my specific evidence that labor costs are 25% to 35% of costs in the fast food industry, that a $15 minimum would increase costs by 17% to 20%, Con cites Sen Warren's figure that doubling the minimum at…

    Against

    • Summary My opponents case rest on the notion of correlation being causation. For me to meet by BOP here, I must either show that with a MW hike, jobs either remain the same, or increase, while my opponent must show they will decrease. I have shown that they have correlated with…
    • Re1: Labour Costs is Indeed 25-30% However, Pro Commits a Straw man Here Con claims I didn't contest his assertion that labour costs are 25-30%. I agree, I did not. Because objectively it is true, but what I did refute what that labour costs would increase as a result of an…
  12. 1112.

    Government should increase spending and lower taxes

    For

    • I never said that taxes were a sub-part of government spending. I said that taxation is one of three ways that government can borrow. I also agree with your definitions of contractionary / expansionary fiscal policy. You've just elaborated on the simple definition I've given…
    • Government spending comes from the money that it borrows. Government borrowing can either be from taxation, money printing, or open market operations. The government chooses to engage in open market operations to finance its borrowing. Private or international investors buy US…

    Against

    • So, for my final argument, let's point out the faults in your argument. First, the US deficit. We are not currently anywhere as low as your $500 billion estimate. We are currently at $17 trillion dollars in debt. Not billions or even millions. Trillions. Your "estimate" or…
    • You have it all wrong. Taxes are not a sub-part of government spending. Taxes are actually the main revenue for the government as of right now. Whatever money the government needs but can't get from taxes, it borrows (1) . Expansionary fiscal policy occurs when government…
  13. 1113.

    Employers should adopt a four-day working week

    For

    • However, despite being tired by the workweek, the person would be able to get work done in a shorter amount of time, and have more time off, and despite not being as balanced, be able to separate work life from personal life.
    • Around 8 hours for students, and the times differ for employees. I understand what you mean by cutting the time each day down to allow people to have more short breaks in between. However, by having a shorter workweek, you could have projects done in a somewhat shorter time…

    Against

    • but won"t we be frustrated that the things we had originally planned to do on the days we work, were bumped to another day? How about not showing up or seeing your children for four days to then come saying you want to spend time with them. Our schedules for the weekend would…
    • On an unrelated note, how many hours of schooling do you get every day? Now to my point, I believe that when you come home from a 10-hour shift you are seriously tired, on top of that you only have 14 hours to catch up on work, sleep, cooking and even family time. a human needs…
  14. 1114.

    The eurozone should abolish the 1 and 2 cent coins

    For

    • I thank con for his rebuttals. In this round I'm going to defend against his rebuttals to show that we should really get rid of the 1 and 2 cent coins.Con said that if we keep the cents you'll eventually end up with a big amount of money. However, you are barely able to spend…
    • Position: the eurozone should get rid of the 1 and 2 cent coinsI thank con for his quick response. In this round I'm going to rebut the argument he gave last round.It seems like con has the idea that the prices including taxes themselves have to be a multiple of 5 cents, but…

    Against

    • This has been an exciting debate, and I have enjoyed it very much. However, I really don't have anything to rebut, as my 3rd round rebuts can be applied to this round. I now end this debate, and encourage everyone to vote.
    • This sure has been an exciting debate. I shall now proceed with my rebuttals. A1, A2, A3: I am going to rebut this case with another argument Pro has put: A2: the cost of producing coins. Sure, if you don't keep them, pennies are useless. However, if we are going to be super…
  15. 1115.

    Centrally planned economies are not the best path to development

    For

    • In that case I hereby conclude this rather uneventful an disappointing debate. Centralised planning is not the most optimal mode of economic development. It worships bigness for the sake of bigness. It creates a sham progress where exaggerated progress are caused by the…
    • I must say central planning also infringes upon personal freedom. The Communist planners, in need to control the flow of labour and capital, as well as the whole economy, must direct every single activity of the citizens. Citizens of these centralised states are essentially…

    Against

    • I accept.
  16. 1116.

    Smart cities cause inflation

    For

    • Let me clarify that I am not a Luddite who is against deploying new technology. I am merely arguing that technology is a useful tool for achieving other objectives and is not a goal in itself. smart cities are ultimately about clustering smart people and not steel-and-chrome…
    • No Sources have been mentioned in the second round because it is a result of my original thinking.

    Against

    • Well, apparently my opponent agrees with me that he has the full burden of proof (since he didn't argue with me). This being the case, I have already won the debate. After all, he plagiarized the first round, fell into a logical fallacy in the second round, and didn't make an…
    • Well, apparently my opponent doesn't deny his plagiarism, and wishes to continue the debate. I am happy to oblige him. First things first... Burden of Proof As the instigator and the one making the positive claim, my opponent has the full burden of proof. He has to make a case…
  17. 1117.

    Governments should abolish patents

    For

    • Since my opponent wasn't here to write an argument for his second round, I shall make a "conclusion speech" akin to one you'd find in formal, real-life debates. That's why I address you, the reader, as "Mr.Speaker". ====================== Mr. Speaker, I believe that there exist…
    • Hello, Unimag8nitiv, and welcome to Debate.org! Firstly, my opponent has stated that if a poor worker discovers a new method for doing what he did at his coal mine and cannot patent it, he would be unable to compete with the original business. He or she has not explained how…

    Against

    • Hello, this is my first debate on this website, so here goes nothing; Patents and copyrights have strong similarities, so eliminating one without affecting the other one would be an impossibility. I'm going to go on a slight tangent, but trust that it relates to the prompt. Jim…
  18. 1118.

    Higher taxes on the rich will not work

    For

    • Everyone pays taxes, so does everyone who has a tax plan have a conflict of interest? Forbes doesn't just like a flat tax cause he will pay less, but because the economy does better. The rich get richer the better the economy gets. Of course poor people are going to vote for…
    • I think it's worth mentioning Steve Forbes likes a flat tax. The flat tax will eliminate the IRS, produce a GDP growth, and put money into the American people. If the American people have more money it means a bigger economy. Also a flat tax gives a rich more money, while…

    Against

    • Well I think I've just about wrapped up the debate at this point. it is clear Pro doesn't actually have any experience debating, and probably meant arguing with their friends about football teams, because it is clear there is no real debate experience here. The majority of my…
    • It's really not worth mentioning that Steve Forbes likes a flat tax. Of course Steve Forbes advocate for a flat tax, it would mean he pays less taxes. That is the definition of a conflict of interest. Eliminating the IRS is one of the most ridiculous policies that exists in the…
  19. 1119.

    New Zealand should adopt a five-point economic plan

    For

    • I'm glad to have faced such a serious challenger! Now to my summary. In this debate I raised five points. First, I proposed that New Zealand indexes tax brackets to the inflation rate. My opponent was so impressed by this point that even he conceded it was "reasonable", with no…
    • I recognise that I am at a significant advantage in this debate, so I appreciate my opponent's courage for taking me on! Because of various time constraints I'm going to post my rounds fairly quickly. Let me now move on to rebuttal.1. Monetary ReformLast round, my opponent gave…

    Against

    • Prsuant to the rules, I will only comment on his plans here. While all none of my opponent;s proposals are bad on their own, collectively they do nothing to improve the economy of New Zealand. Because there are similarities between many of his points, I hope the reader will…
    • I've learned a lot about New Zealand in the last few days, but I'm sure I'm still at a huge disadvantage to my opponent. New Zealand seems to be in much better economic shape than the U.S. at the moment. I've tried to develop a 5 point economic development plan for New Zealand.…
  20. 1120.

    The minimum wage should be abolished

    For

    • Rebuttals:Increases the standard of living for the poorest and most vulnerable class in society:"Clearly, the min. wage would vastly improve the situation for these parents, in turn dealing with the poverty to some extent. This is the fundamental reason to employ a min. wage:…
    • Hello, Chelsea. I saw your argument for minimum wage. I would like to debate this issue with you. As a supporter for the abolition of minimum wage, I think we could have a good conversation on the topic. I will give you the first word this round, if you choose to accept.

    Against

    • My original arguments are paraphrased in italics to give context Your video + Unemployment (as you tied them together): Your video makes the "key observation" that minimum wage increase is a problem. However, a minimum wage increase is NOT part of the resolution. You see,…
    • I thank Valladarex for the opportunity to debate a highly contentious topic. While it unusual to go first in a debate where I technically don't have the burden of proof, I will have a chance to refute Pro's argument in the next round. I will provide some arguments as to why…
  21. 1121.

    Tax rates should rise sharply for the wealthy

    For

    • I accept CON's concession.
    • CON has a really nasty habit of stealing other people's work, and I noticed that he's done this in his other recent debate, so I was pleasantly surprised when I saw what appeared to be an interesting case, but it nevertheless looked familar. I poked around on Google, and lo and…

    Against

    • Yah i admit it i give up
    • To understand raising taxes to increase government revenue would be a good idea, we must look at the Laffer curve. The Laffer curve, which Dr. Arthur Laffer leant his name to the curve after discussing it with some aides from the Ford administration, shows the relationship…
  22. 1122.

    Globalization is the best solution to global wealth inequality

    For

    • Trade benefits all those who are participants in the trade -- otherwise the participants wouldn't take part in it. Global trade increases the number (and quality) of goods and services produced, thereby reducing their cost, and thereby benefiting those who earn/have less.…
    • The examples I used were illustrative of the obvious point: Trade increases wealth. When two parties consent to a trade, they are both better off for the trade, or else they wouldn't do it. Furthermore, with division of labor, a greater number (and higher quality) of goods and…

    Against

    • If you do not understand what I have said before, let me say this one more time. Trading does not necessarily increase the wealth of ALL people: it most likely increases the wealth of the rich, not the public. And that hits the point I have mentioned: the rich gets richer and…
    • There were too many imaginations: comics, novels. .. Those are vague and unsupportive evidence. In the real world, no one can guarantee the living standads are going to be raised; no single government is going to be responsible for the actions you have mentioned before if the…
  23. 1123.

    The concept of money inhibits an ideal society

    For

    • I'm going to be arguing the PRO for this one. Guidelines: I don't want this to be a "debatey" kind of debate. Please don't use phrases like "extend through the flow" or "card. " I'd like this to be a very relaxed discussion between two individuals regarding a theory I'd had a…
    • the main problem with my opponent's argument is that he jumps to conclusions that don't exist. He (or she, I'm not really sure) immediately assumes that a pornstar would have to produce hours upon hours of porn just to get along in a non-monetary society. This isn't necessarily…

    Against

    • Without money there's no way for the government of a nation to assign a value to an item.So if they need more engineer's, as there are in Britain required, they will have to increase salary for engineering and increase it relative to others. If there is an overflow of doctors…
    • Before I begin my closing statement I shall list all uncontested contentions that I have raised throughout debate and my opponent completely failed to either address or successfully refute."Without money there's no way for the government of a nation to assign a value to an…
  24. 1124.

    A national minimum wage should be abolished

    For

    • Their pay is contingent on their productivity. If you raise or lower the minimum wage, those currently employed should not be affected because they are currently getting paid based upon their productivity. If you remove the minimum wage it will create jobs. If you increase the…
    • If prices increase, then it has to be justified by the increased productivity of the worker. If the worker does not increase his productivity, he will be out of a job. Everythign else being equal, that person who is no longer justifiable on an economic basis, will lose his job.…

    Against

    • Well to conclude, No minimum wage will send people to the street. Companies would happily lower their wages and keep the prices the same, or lower them, but not as dramatic as the wages. Like I said, many people need roommates that work minimum wage. The rent isn't going to go…
    • Well, 1. Without a minimum wage, not many people could afford to work. Many minimum wage workers already cannot afford an apartment, car, car insurance, also with the increasing prices of gas. These people survive by roommates or having a spouse with a better job. No minimum…
  25. 1125.

    A higher minimum wage is the answer to poverty

    For

    • Apologize for not answering before. For many people living in minimum wage is it not about maintaining a standard of living, it is about getting a standard living. It is easy to say that a person having a fine life getting a pay raise, possibly will not go out spending it…
    • This is an argument about whether higher minimum wage would be the answer to poverty. I will be pro minimum wage, and my opponent would be con/against. Here are some ground rules: The first round will be acceptance, followed by a starting argument. Grammar is not a valid…

    Against

    • For many people living in minimum wage is it not about maintaining a standard of living, it is about getting a standard living. It is easy to say that a person having a fine life getting a pay raise, possibly will not go out spending it extravagantly. That does, however, not…
    • marke forfeited this round
  26. 1126.

    Labor unions harm the economy

    For

    • extend all arguments
    • "Taxes will raise prices of merchandise, but not dramatically, because other competing businesses would try to stay at a low price." Yes taxes will raise prices of merchandise a lot over time. Hope you like math. you spend 350$ a week, under a non taxation sales tax zone. Under…

    Against

    • Wow. It takes much skill to copy and paste. No offense, but your refutations makes no sense (except the one that I broke one of the rules. Didn't see that). Taxes will raise prices of merchandise, but not dramatically, becuase other competing buisnesses would try to stay at a…
    • To be truthful, this is a silly arguement, because it is so obvious, but I will be nevertheless happy to have this debate, no matter how easy. Labor unions absolutely do not hurt the economy. Labor unions are essential! Teachers, policemen, workers, farmers, all of them are…
  27. 1127.

    Debts should be inherited along with a deceased person's wealth

    For

    • Here's a story. It's sad but true. Having been banned from driving for five years, a very good friend of mine celebrated the recent return of his licence by purchasing a 1963 Series III Bentley Continental Drophead Coupe finished in midnight blue with coachwork by Mulliner Park…
    • Hello again theLwerd and thanks for taking this debate. In reply to my opponent's contribution, I wouldn't say my friend's solicitor is a lousy lawyer, rather that my friend is very unlucky, as she rightly observed. Indeed, he's always been unlucky - I reckon if he fell into a…

    Against

    • A few things: First, Brian says that the woman who died simply did so before ever being able to write his friend a check. That seems unlikely since she apparently got beat up so badly to the point where she died, but more importantly, you'll notice that back in R1 Pro wrote,…
    • It seems as if Brian's friend had a terrible attorney. When someone dies, their estate is left for someone to handle (typically a spouse, child or lawyer). That individual -- in this case, it would be the woman's son -- is responsible for making sure that all final bills are…
  28. 1128.

    The US should build a transcontinental passenger monorail

    For

    • I will first go over my opponents attacks onto my case then say voters. (CR# = Counter Refutation) CR1 Status Quo When I said "current train system" I intended the current transcontinental railroad. I do agree that there is already a current train system but I said that no one…
    • Those definitions are what I had in mind so we shall be using those definitions for trans-continental and monorail. Observation 1: The status quo (inherency, what is going on right now) Currently America's railroad system is a joke "In 1926, almost 32 billion passenger-miles…

    Against

    • Okay, let's get down to business. First off, let's start with a refutation of PRO's arguments. R.1 Status QuoThis point is about how Americans are not riding the train system anymore. Obviously, this is because there are much better options of travel than train, such as plane…
    • By trans-continental, it is meant that the monorail will extend from one side to the other, from sea to sea, that encompasses the entire nation. http://en.wikipedia.org...By monorail, it is a railroad, essentially. http://en.wikipedia.org...Please if you disagree with these…
  29. 1129.

    Married couples with children should be exempt from income tax

    For

    • Sorry about missing the last round to all of the readers. I was preoccupied with a home improvement project. Building a closet. Now on to the debate: "If he is to win this debate he will need to come up with an argument of his own." I will make no rebuttals to anything my…
    • "Since Pro failed to define the limits of the length of complete tax exemption, I will assume that he means to stop the exemption when all children are 18 years of age. I hope he will correct me in the second round if this is not what he had in mind." Yes until the age of 18.…

    Against

    • Pro has altered his resolution somewhat. I ask the readers to forgive him this faux paus because any good reformer is willing to admit a flaw in his proposal and tweak it enough to make it work. Pro has changed his position to not extend his proposed right to the wealthy five…
    • I'm sure Sadolite, a respected member of Debate.org had a valid reason for missing the third round of debate. I ask the audience to forgive him for this round. Since most debates I participate in are three rounds, missing this one in no way limits either of our arguments. My…
  30. 1130.

    Income taxes should be abolished in favor of a flat tax

    For

    • Fair/Flat tax is probably a great idea. It has less control for government, the government would still get money, people would not have to pay for their hard earned money and the United States Government should know better to spend money. Besides stopping income tax would make…
    • Mr 12jPerry, I disagree with you that people under the age of 18 should not be taxed. But I see that you disagree about having Flat.Fair. Tax. I believe that is the best way to improve our economy, middle class, the poor and etc. Paying income tax I believe should not be used.…

    Against

    • First off a flat tax and a fair tax are two very different things. Secondly, the income tax is just a way for the government to piss away more paper money from the federal reserve. We need to get rid of it, and replace it with nothing. It was only supposed to be there for a…
    • I'm going to ignore the arguement for teens under 18 paying taxes, because this debate is about the replacing of the income tax with the flat/fair tax. I am completely against the fair tax, that would be worse in many ways then the income tax. As for the flat tax, it would be…
  31. 1131.

    The minimum wage is a sound economic policy

    For

    • Thank you to Ron-Paul for this intriguing debate. I'll jump right in: Con's first claim is that I am assuming that businesses will pocket the difference between marginal productivity and wages. Yet, he offers no evidence that the the opposite would be the case. In fact, his…
    • In this round I will respond to Con's R2&3 arguments and defend my own case somewhat simultaneously.A key part of Con's case is that the minimum wage (MW) increases unemployment. To support this claim, Con presented both a hypothesis containing a false premise as well as data…

    Against

    • My opponent's claims that wages will fall is illogical. "The argument [yours] is defective. It takes it for granted that the employers pocket the difference between the marginal-productivity wage rate and the lower monopoly rate as an extra monopoly gain and do not pass it on…
    • Here is why the minimum wage will not boost economic growth: The. minimum wage has a negative effect on the American economy, because: 1. Jobs will be cut. 2. Prices on everyday goods will go up. 3. Price inflation will result. 4. Interest rates will increase. 5. Fewer…
  32. 1132.

    The US should pass a balanced budget amendment

    For

    • Thank you for your swift reply.Con 1: War and National EmergenciesI agree with con's point here. As I pointed out in the first round, the Balanced Budget Amendment provides provisions for such an event:Section 7. The Congress may waive the provisions of sections 1, 2, 3, and 5…
    • As another war on the debt limit is looming over us and the fiscal cliff just barely passed over us, we need some serious thoughts on ways to reduce the deficit. One of my proposals is a Balanced Budget Amendment. Pro 1: The BBA Addresses Chronic Deficit For the past several…

    Against

    • My ArgumentsWar and National EmergenciesWhen a country is at war, it has to spend a large amount of money. We did so in every war we spent on. President Franklin Roosevelt had to raise spending by a lot in order to win World War 2. We needed to go into debt to fight this war…
    • Ok, now we can have a good debate!
  33. 1133.

    Foreign labor brings more benefits than harms

    For

    • The opponent has basically forfeited the last round, which shows that he actually agrees with what I said. So what have I told you so far? Firstly, foreign labour is essential in easing the burden on the working population of countries with low replacement rates by supporting…
    • The opposition clearly is cherry-picking examples, using the examples of taxes from Malaysia. However, if one was to look in countries such as Australia or America where minimum wage systems exist, that is not the case as the government is able to regulate the taxes. My point…

    Against

    • Although your argument is quite acceptable in a modern day society, but there are still flaws in your case. Allow me to first point those flaws. Though your idea of the government charging the working immigrants is acceptable, you must still remember that it is required for a…
    • I welcome the challenger first. Firstly i would like to establish my points. Firstly foreign workers help establish job opportunities. An immigrant will take a job within a 3-dimensional sector. Thus providing jobs for native born locals such as being promoted to supervisors.…
  34. 1134.

    IT job opportunities will increase in the future

    For

    • i am a computer science student nowadays the field of IT not rapidly growing. but the the idle growth has been. so what's is the future of IT. will it useful for the after those who will choose this field?

    Against

    • This is some deep sh!t http://www.youtube.com...
    • what an interesting rebuttal...
  35. 1135.

    Deficit spending is the best approach for the economy now and in the future

    For

    • ----The Cost of Debt----- As I already posted in my first post interest rates on new government debt are currently negative this makes your argument completely invalid. -----The Cost of Printing Money----- First off you are incorrect, there are many things that effect the value…
    • 1)A) Infrastructure is something that is required to have a modern economy. We need transportation, power lines, water, and energy in order for the economy to perform. Now and in the future infrastructure will need to be build and replaced regardless. B)The first question is…

    Against

    • -----Rebuttals-----1A - Yes, infrastructure is important, but that in and of itself doesn't justify borrowing or printing money to pay for it. When considering a budget, the most important things should be taken care of first, rather than just saying 'we can always borrow money…
    • -----The Resolution-----Firstly I would like to point out that the resolution isn't solely on the benefits of building infrastructure, but the method of obtaining the money to pay such infrastructure. "...for the government to borrow more money and spend it on infrastructure…
  36. 1136.

    Viable alternatives to the current monetary system exist

    For

    • My opponent has no intrest in debating this. Likewise, he got me involved in a debate he didn't understand.
    • I. What is the Monetary systemA monetary system is a complex method of marketplace stimulation, which involves money circulating into the government as taxes, and back into the populous as stimuli, creating a cycle of economic growth determined by the people and legislation.…

    Against

    • Yay! Ok jon, get it together. "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." (US Declaration of Independence) The…
    • Nothing is free. This is the montra of our modern society. Everything measured in dollar bills, monetary value. If you want a car, you pay. If you want, shelter, you can pay for it. If you're hungry or thirsty, theres a value put on that. Things that would otherwise be free…
  37. 1137.

    Universal basic income should be implemented in Western countries

    For

    • Before I proceed to point out the multitude of flaws in your argument I would like to point out the fact that 'broad and illogical' is not how you should describe it, as an opener to a debate it is meant to be broad, and illogical will be disproved later in the argument. Now…
    • UBI is an undeniably good choice for the western world, as it eliminates extreme poverty and allows more economic freedom. For those who don't know UBI, or Universal Basic Income, it is where the government gives every citizen a base income of around $10,000 that you can spend…

    Against

    • Hello ISDA, Before I proceed to point out the multitude of flaws regarding a USI system, I would like to point out that your opening argument is very broad and illogical. You define a Universal Basic Income system as '...the government [giving] EVERY citizen a base income of…
    • You have still failed to identify my main point... a UBI system is not a feasible replacement for welfare. The truth is, ordinary middle class, working citizens in their prime working age range DO NOT require the payment from a UBI system. It baffles me how you have failed to…
  38. 1138.

    France's decision to force big supermarkets to donate unsold food to charities was justified

    For

    • Everyone notice that Pro is only refer to what could go wrong in third world countries. He poses a good argument, but I don't think it should be nearly enough to simply watch them starve. And, there isn't only poverty far away from us in third world countries where cash crops…
    • Con poses a good argument. But that shouldn't be enough to win. If you are deciding which side you should vote for, think about this. Sure it could potentially cause splash crops, I understand that, but is that really enough to make you decide that France's supermarkets should…

    Against

    • "Think about this: If you lived in a third world country with little to nothing to eat in a day, and people started supplying you with much needed food, would you stop working? " Con If you ever gardened, you will realize just how hard it is to grow crops with no tools. Much of…
    • "Approximately 1 in 9 people around the world don't have enough food in a day to lead a healthy lifestyle. " Pro While this statement may be true, providing evidence would make this claim stronger. The rest of Pro's statement is emotional but lacks evidence. Con contends that…
  39. 1139.

    Taxes are extortion and theft

    For

    • "Your body needs food to survive does it not? If you don't eat then you'll die. Is your body extorting money for food from you?" No, because this is simply a natural need. Your body cannot "intimidate" you. Hunger pains are just a sign of it. "Now if we look at the definition…
    • If the demand of payment is for services and privileges someone did not ask to receive or cannot opt out of, this is still extortion. To counter your analogy, if McDonald's were the only fast food restaurant in a given area, delivered their food unasked for to people under…

    Against

    • You sir are a great debater. I could continue but it is clear to me that I have lost this debate.I respectfully and honorably concede the point.Thank you.
    • Your body needs food to survive does it not? If you don't eat then you'll die. Is your body extorting money for food from you? Now if we look at the definition you provided for extortion we see that it is the securing of money through means of violence and intimidation. Jail…
  40. 1140.

    The gender wage gap does not exist in America

    For

    • This is a controversial topic, relax and let's have a nice debate 2. I will be arguing that "The wage gap between men and women does not exist in America" 3. BIASED and UNRELIABLE sources are not allowed (philosophy, statistics, logic, and everything else is allowed. ) 4.…
    • Background - To clarify, I will first be defending my own case, and then attacking my opponent's case.Defense 1 - I didn't concede the arguement, and I clarified the definitions in my first round response, and the comments.Here is what I wrote in quotations" Clearifications -…

    Against

    • Point 1 - Pro ConcedesA major one and the most significant, Pro concedes the argument.The topic of the debate is "The wage gap between men and women does not exist in America". As per R1 Pro will be arguing that "The wage gap between men and women does not exist in America". In…
  41. 1141.

    Capitalism is a better economic system than socialism

    For

    • What you are saying is that the government needs to take more from the rich and give to the poor. What needs to happen is keep what you earn instead of giving it to someone else. That will have less productivity, and more government. The private sector needs to grow to get more…
    • In capitalism any one can get ahead for an economic and social structure, when using capitalism you keep what you have and get what you can get. I do agree we need to have a set limit on how much you can keep for yourself, but there is no oppressing in the fact that you can…

    Against

    • What I am saying is the redistribution of wealth is tantamount to building a fairer society. Without going into my political and economic aspirations, the system is broken and the already wealthy are exploiting everyone below them creating an ever increasing inequality gap by…
    • How can someone with no means of funding an education or having social capital ever get ahead in the hyper competitive job market or achieve social mobility? When using capitalism you get a fraction of what you should get and have to pay a ridiculous amount of money to…
  42. 1142.

    The United States should eliminate the penny

    For

    • You have forfeited therefore I win.
    • Briefly perhaps, but most of the information that passes through the brain is permanently forgotten. If the brain recorded moments like a tape recorder, then it would be theoretically possible to produce a transcript of every sentence you ever heard in your lifetime: every…

    Against

    • Just because the penny will be soon forgotten and people will not care about it after awhile does not mean that it must go. The penny and other discontinued change have been forgotten these day's because the people hve been forced to forget! It's gone, no more of it and common…
    • Is it a good thing that we got rid of the pennie's?EXPRESS YOURSELF
  43. 1143.

    Fractional reserve banking should be illegal

    For

    • Arguments extended
    • arguments extended

    Against

    • ==Framework and Definitions==Con has accepted the BOP and resolution analysis I have offered, as well as my definitions, so extend those. ==Background==I provided a definition in the last round, but I feel the need to briefly explain mathematically what fractional reserve…
    • However, i feel the need to define our terms and to outline the burdens before diving into this debate. Pro may feel free to contest any of these definitions or any of my analysis in his following round. ==Definitions==Fractional reserve banking - "A banking system in which…
  44. 1144.

    Globalization is good for the world

    For

    • I believe that globalization is good. The following definitions are provided for clarity from http://dictionary.reference.com... Globalization: to extend to other or all parts of the globe; make worldwide Good: beneficial ================== Contentions ================== I.…

    Against

    • This is also bad for the workers in Mexico and China, who are being paid very little. These workers usually have to keep the jobs anyway so they can provide money for their families. Ultimately, it will deliver a worse product to the consumer because less skilled workers will…
    • My opponent is unable to finish the debate. I hope to be able to debate this topic with him in the future. In the meantime, I will continue my arguments. I will expound upon argument A: According to a study done by the Economic Policy Institute, NAFTA "displaced production that…
  45. 1145.

    Governments should provide microfinance access for the unbanked

    For

    • Rebuilding agricultural systems
    • Small is beautiful: community empowerment

    Against

    • Realistic barriers
    • Deeper issues unresolved
  46. 1146.

    Federal Reserve policy has harmed the US economy

    For

    • I know its not a fish, but it is worse than ever.
    • On a debate, I said that the Fed destroyed our economy, my opponent said that "our GDP is better than ever, if that is economic hardship, we should have more of it", I'm sorry to tell you this, but I don't measure how good an economy by how high it's GDP is, I judge it by the…

    Against

    • No, our economy is not a fish.
    • If trump wins we will be rich.
  47. 1147.

    The gender wage gap is not a meaningful problem

    For

    • No disrespect, But like I said earlier, There is a gender earnings gap, Not a wage gap. Men on general have earned more, Women haven't. I realize how poor my word choice was when I created this, And I'm sorry, But the show must go on.
    • Since the 1963 Equal Pay act, It has been illegal to pay women less. The reason why modern women aren't making as much money is because of the life choices each gender make. Men are more likely to ask for promotions(1), They are more likely to succeed negotiations in…

    Against

    • You should have said, "The wage gap is due to sexism" and labeled yourself as con. What's the difference between a gender earnings gap and a wage gap?
    • I'm not saying the gap is due to sexism, Men make more because they tend to work harder in the workplace and they tend to have better paying jobs. However, The wage gap still exists, Men still make more then women it's just not motivated by supposed workplace sexism…
  48. 1148.

    The tipping system should be abolished

    For

    • wdscfdw
    • con argues tipping gives an incentive for good service. he almost seems to argue you'd get bad service without tipping. the problem is that other service industries get along just fine without tipping, food prep, walmart employees, carry outs, etc. the wage itself is enough…

    Against

    • Tipping gives people incentive to work hard. If waiters get paid the same amount no matter how well they perform, they have no reason to work hard. Waiters try to give customers a good expierence in order to get a good tip. Take that away and there's no reason to give customers…
  49. 1149.

    The US should abolish the penny

    For

    • The problem with pennies as stated in my first argument is that pennies are no longer convenient. Even after that penny in the $0.99 transaction is returned, the penny will most likely end up in a jar dead to the economy not fulfilling its role as currency. The fact that…
    • I would like to thank Forthelulz for accepting this debate On to my arguments: Argument 1: Pennies are a waste of money As of now it takes 1.7 cents to make a penny when a penny is only worth 1 cent. Because the US makes billions of these per year the costs add up. In 2014,…

    Against

    • Okay, dropping a few definitions of my own, not conflicting with any Pro provided. Hope Pro doesn't mind. Consumerism - the theory that an increasing consumption of goods and services is economically desirable. Instant gratification - The consumer receiving the good/service…
    • I believe we should keep the penny around.
  50. 1150.

    Tax rates should be static rather than changing with income

    For

    • Kasper.....did you even read the debate question? Unless you can answer in a sensible and intelligent way you should really think about removing yourself from this forum!!
    • Static tax is a fundamentally fair system both logically and morally unlike progressive tax which is unfair and effectively dis-incentivises society to be high income earners. This could in time lead to a changing of the law or disruptive tax avoidance strategies being…

    Against

    • Did you even read my response? You have framed the motion in manner which implies that a static tax rate is fair. I have offered four points of rebuttal to your assertion that a static taxation system is morally and logically fair. I challenge you to define fairness, and…
    • I fundamentally disagree with your assertion of proposing a static tax system as fair for the following reasons. 1) In order for a static taxation to be fair we have to make a number of presumptions. Firstly we have to define what is fair? Do we equate fairness to…

How to use these debate topics

  • Vote, discuss, revote. Poll the room on the motion, give 5 minutes of discussion, then vote again and look at who changed their mind.
  • Four corners. Label corners strongly agree → strongly disagree; people move, then each corner makes its best case.
  • Switch sides. Halfway through, everyone argues the side they disagree with. It sharpens listening.

Run them live

Want every person to answer on their own phone, with a timer and a live leaderboard? Use these questions in an EngageSlide Vote · Discuss · Revote — free to start.

Tick questions on any page — your set is kept while you browse (or take the first 10 here) — and they become ready-to-play slides. What is EngageSlide?

More question collections

Questions adapted from args.me corpus (CC BY 4.0), edited for clarity. This collection may be reused under the same terms — see sources & licenses.