Discussly

Economy Debate Topics for Students — page 4

1,282 debate topics, students. Debatable motions with arguments for and against. Open the arguments below, pick one at random, or present them full-screen.

StudentsDebatePage 4 of 26
  1. 151.

    African governments should adopt an open skies agreement

    For

    • Incorporating foreign airlines
    • A competitive airline industry

    Against

    • Terrorism
    • Alliances not open skies
  2. 152.

    Key industries should be nationalized

    For

    • I will let my opponent go first

    Against

    • Why have a debate if you don't intend to argue.
    • Why have you forfeited this round? My opponent has no counter arguments to make or even some evidence to make.
  3. 153.

    Kazakhstan can improve oil production without foreign partners

    For

    • Foreign partners get more money than local company because of they have technology and stuff for producing oil.

    Against

    • Pro has not filled his BOP.
    • Extend BOP waiting time
  4. 154.

    Socialism is the best economic system

    For

    • well what about black people huh? since the government is rigged against them how are they going to get money to survive in the world huh? or mexicans or asains! the top 1% has the money that the 99% has combined! thats crazy! thats why we need socilism!
    • this is the definition of socilism = a political and economic theory of social organization that advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole. that means captilist pigs wont hog money anymore! if we…

    Against

    • Pro raises a contention: minority groups are "discriminated against" not by the market, but by the government. There are two responses:1) If the government is biased, that's a problem for socialism, not capitalism. In a capitalist society, government stays out of the economy.…
    • You've made my case for me, Pro. The danger of socialism is that it allows other people to run your life.It makes you a tool of a community rather than an individual.Capitalism, on the other hand, respects each person's uniqueness, individualism. It gives liberty to all,…
  5. 155.

    Governments should switch from capitalism to socialism due to technology

    For

    • Rebuttals and Conclusions only this round please. No new arguments. Before I start my argument, I will give the definition of "contribution" and "quality/quantity of work", which are used interchangeably in my argument. Ex. If Bob bakes 100 tasty bread while Joe bakes 100…
    • Thank you for a great argument. *I am sorry for not clearly defining the word "socialism" since I have a right wing view on capitalism. It was supposed to be "wealth redistribution" or any government similar to Norway and Sweden's. However, you can ignore the post and I will…

    Against

    • Notice how this motion is phrased'Governments should switch from capitalism to socialism due to technological advances'Pro is representing the side changing the status quo. He has to convince you governments should switch from capitalism TO SOCIALISM. You should not vote for…
    • First, I will give the definition of Communism Communism: A political and economic ideology based on communal ownership (while private property is abolished) and the absence of class. (http://www.investopedia.com...) 1. In your argument, you have defined socialism as 'a…
  6. 156.

    Keynesian economic policies are ineffective in the long run

    For

    • Also, some definitions to clear up any confusion: Long-run: The period of time in which all prices, especially wages, are flexible, and have achieved their equilibrium levels. Keynesian: Acting along the lines of the Keynesian school of economic thought, which is based upon the…

    Against

    • Unfortunately, my opponent has forfeted all rounds. As Con, I do not have to prove anything, because the Burden of Proof (BOP) rests on Pro. Therefore, because Pro has not proven anything, I have fulfilled my duty and should automatically win. That said, I will make the case…
    • Passing.
  7. 157.

    Oil has been more a curse than a blessing for the Middle East

    For

    • The oil in the middle east has caused them to be engaged in many wars over the scarce resource e.g Iran and Iraq

    Against

    • I will give my opponent the beginning of the next round to make a case, otherwise I will proceed with my argument.
    • I accept your challenge. I contend that most strife in the Middle East is caused by issues other than oil. Ancient and modern rivalries revolving around tribe and religion are the main driving force of Middle East conflicts.
  8. 158.

    The US should substantially invest in sidewalks and cycle paths

    For

    • As this debate is inspired by a personal grievance, I would ask my fellow debaters to please forgive my self-indulgence in starting this argument. The thing is, the nearest bar to my place (in the suburbs of Bradenton, FL) is three and a half miles away* and since I don't want…
    • Thank you to A time and a place, for taking this debate. My opponent starts by pointing out that building the infrastructure involved to create sidewalks and cycle paths would be expensive. This is true, but the US is the richest country in the world and, besides, what price…

    Against

    • "My opponent starts by pointing out that building the infrastructure involved to create sidewalks and cycle paths would be expensive. This is true, but the US is the richest country in the world and, besides, what price can you put on the lives of people killed by drunk…
    • It's not cheap, to put in cycle paths or sidewalks where there aren't any would require a economically viable number of people demanding it. You needing a safe route to cycle drunkenly home from the bar probably doesn't meet that requirement I'm afraid. In general, I think…
  9. 159.

    The monetary system does not work for everyone

    For

    • Based on the fact that paper money is literally worthless, the fact that money basically represent a 'promise' to pay later,but with what. Gold is the only true representation of true wealth. The worlds money is controlled by a few highly addicted and greedy people. They…

    Against

    • k
    • I'll skip this round
  10. 160.

    Some corporations are too big to fail

    For

    • I've been trying to decide whether to be mean and post a full round or to just be nice and post nothing. I've decided to post what I had already typed up PRIOR to darkkermit's forfeit, since it's not my fault he couldn't post his argument. Here we are: I'll begin with a very…
    • Thanks for an interesting topic darkkermit. It is one I (claim to) know a great deal about. The Glass-Steagall Act, passed during the Great Depression, prevented the merger of commercial banks, investment banks, and insurance companies. There were good reasons for doing so, as…

    Against

    • Many thanks to my opponent, bluesteel. The role of profits:Profits are a signal that demonstrate that a good or service is demanded by society. For example, people buy food, clothing, and such because these goods and services are desirable. Profits = Revenue - Expenses. If…
    • Wow I did not have access to the internet, and didn't realize how little time I had left once I went to the local library. There's still 3 rounds available for debating, so do you mind skipping this round? Sorry about that. :p.
  11. 161.

    Americans should buy only American-made cars

    For

    • 1. No, I am not. Buying within ones own country no matter what the race of those who live there supports further trade within their own country. this increases the probability of the money you spending on that car being used to support your business. Also, not everyone, or even…
    • Thank you for taking this debate. This is something I feel strongly about and have discussed it with my peers numerous times. It's better however to do it here, in an intellectual environment with more opportunity for each side to gather facts. However I do not believe that…

    Against

    • Thanks Pro, for your quick response. 1. Pro is still a xenophobe "The reason you should support American businesses is because you live here." Non-sequitur. Geopolitical boundaries are totally arbitrary. There is absolutely no reason why I should care more about John Smith than…
    • Thanks Pro, for instigating. Protection is an extremely harmful policy. I'm always baffled when I hear conservatives who support it. It's essentially based on the same argument that all trade is exploitative which drives many liberal policies. The "buy American" fad is…
  12. 162.

    Debts should be inherited along with a deceased person's wealth

    For

    • Here's a story. It's sad but true. Having been banned from driving for five years, a very good friend of mine celebrated the recent return of his licence by purchasing a 1963 Series III Bentley Continental Drophead Coupe finished in midnight blue with coachwork by Mulliner Park…
    • Hello again theLwerd and thanks for taking this debate. In reply to my opponent's contribution, I wouldn't say my friend's solicitor is a lousy lawyer, rather that my friend is very unlucky, as she rightly observed. Indeed, he's always been unlucky - I reckon if he fell into a…

    Against

    • A few things: First, Brian says that the woman who died simply did so before ever being able to write his friend a check. That seems unlikely since she apparently got beat up so badly to the point where she died, but more importantly, you'll notice that back in R1 Pro wrote,…
    • It seems as if Brian's friend had a terrible attorney. When someone dies, their estate is left for someone to handle (typically a spouse, child or lawyer). That individual -- in this case, it would be the woman's son -- is responsible for making sure that all final bills are…
  13. 163.

    Governments should act to stop manufacturing jobs moving overseas

    For

    • The trade deficit and the loss of manufacturing jobs are one in the same. One must understand one in order to understand the other and the negative results of both. I had to devote a whole round in order to educate people as to why we have a trade deficit in order to provide…
    • Just a few questions and facts before I begin Why has free trade been so beneficial for most countries but such a disastrous albatross for the U.S.? A totally out-of-control trade deficit that is simply not sustainable. Why is it that among the developed and industrialized…

    Against

    • We have agreed that trade deficits are a serious problem that must be resolved. Pro claims in his resolution that there is only one solution to the trade deficit problem: to erect trade barriers that keep out foreign goods, including oil. con points to many countries that have…
    • Pro has chosen to ignore the topic he posted for the debate, and instead has decide to provide arguments for a different topic, that trade deficits are a bad thing and that high trade deficits are not sustainable in the long run. I quite agree that trade deficits are a bad…
  14. 164.

    The minimum wage should be increased

    For

    • P1: Minimum wage, in many households in the U.S., does not cover the basic cost of living. ( http://www.cbsnews.com... ) P2: Increased purchasing power of low-wage workers will help stimulate the economy. C: The government should increase the minimum wage.
    • P1: I'm not talking about the unemployed I'm talking about low wage workers. That includes people in poverty who DO work, for minimum wage. "More working-age adults picked up low-wage jobs in the slowly improving economy but still struggled to pay living expenses. "…

    Against

    • P1) About 60% of the officially poor don't work, so the only thing raising the minimum wage does for them is to make it harder for them to get a job if they ever decide they want one. Workers must bring at least as much value to the firm as they are paid or the firm will fail…
    • P1) Raising the minimum wage will hurt small businesses who cannot afford to pay employees the increased wage. Since business will not be able to pay the increased wage they will be forced to cut employee hours or cut the number of employees they have all together. When this…
  15. 165.

    Taxes on the wealthy should be increased

    For

    • The wealthy may not be at fault for such policies, however that does not mean it is morally acceptable to let such behavior continue to occur within this country. They are taking advantage of the system and it has to be stopped, if not, at least an attempt must be made to…
    • Unfair is the fact that individuals who make a fraction of what the wealthy make, have to pay a larger proportion of taxes from their hard earned income than the wealthy do. Meanwhile the wealthy have loopholes and tax breaks that allow them to legally avoid paying taxes.…

    Against

    • Is it morally acceptable for unemployed citizens to receive state and federal assistance to help them live their lives while they sit on their behinds all day. Although the wealthy does not pay as much taxes as other citizens would like them to, they do make up for it. There…
    • I agree that there are many loopholes and tax breaks for the wealthy, however that is not their fault. You can not blame them for using these systems that were created by the government to benefit themserlves, especially if it isn't illegal. There are many governmental services…
  16. 166.

    Raising the minimum wage won't solve economic problems

    For

    • MINIMUM WAGE IN 1968Who's relying on Internet memes? I used one to show a point, but either way Gold and Silver retain their value almost exactly over long periods of time, so they are the best way to measure value or inflation. So let's take the minimum wage in 1968, 1.10$,…
    • Raising the minimum wage won't solve anything because they could just inflate the money, and make that 15$ a our worth even less than 7.25$.

    Against

    • You fail to see the point of a Federal Reserve; you probably should not rely on Internet memes to beat me in an argument. The problem with a low income is a cause of inequality, i.e. the rich is shanking you out of your money, and if you don't agree to their mugging, they kill…
    • I will let you have the first argument.
  17. 167.

    All government handouts amount to freeloading

    For

    • Post your particular interest.I was on a bus once and there was a discussion about replacing the republican governor with a democrat because the bus fare subsidies were going to be raised from 2 dollars to 3 dollars. How shallow does a person have to be to vote over a dollar .I…
    • I believe that anyone taking another mans earned income by government force is corrupt in their thinking.Government is not for meeting peoples needs.Government is to enforce contract law and to protect a persons right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, which is…

    Against

    • The reason I have a particular interest in this subject is that I do a lot of work to help people who have been left homeless and starving as a result of being wrongly denied the support to which they have been entitled. This includes people with serious diseases such as…
    • I would be interested in debating this topic with you, as this is an area in which I have a particular interest.
  18. 168.

    The US federal government should act to close the gender wage gap

    For

    • Wage DiscrepancyI thought it might be useful to first prove the severity of this institutionalized discrimination. "Some argue that the wage gap is purely due to 'women's choices,' but such a characterization hides the cultural and social factors that go into women's decisions…
    • Hello! I saw your post on this opinion (. http://www.debate.org...) and thought that this would make an interesting debate, should you accept it. DefinitionsUSFG: United States Federal Government (specifically the legislative and executive branches)Gender Wage Gap: The…

    Against

    • Yes, I accept your challenge. I think this will be fun. Good luck. Here's a few of my definitions that I think will come in handy: work (noun): the labor, task, or duty that is one's accustomed means of livelihood [1] money (noun): something (such as coins or bills) used as a…
    • I accept (again). Good luck.
  19. 169.

    The United States is not truly capitalist

    For

    • You are hilarious, um, nah, I can't think of anything, except the Federal reserve, they control our economy.
    • "Capitalism is a social system based on the principle of individual rights. Politically, it is the system of laissez-faire(freedom). Legally it is a system of objective laws (rule of law as opposed to rule of man). Economically, when such freedom is applied to the sphere of…

    Against

    • "cap"i"tal"ism G2;kapədlG6;izəm/ noun noun: capitalism an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state. synonyms:free enterprise, private enterprise, the free market; enterprise…
    • "America is not capitalist" Definition of capitalist: (merriem webster, any alternative definition may be used) "of or relating to capitalism : using capitalism as an economic system" So the question becomes does america use capitalism as an economic system? If america does,…
  20. 170.

    Capitalism does not require democracy

    For

    • This debate is open to anyone. N00b sniping is not a problem for me. I'll take on all comers.First round is acceptance.Second round is arguments.Third round is counter-arguments and closing statement.The debate topic is: Capitalism does not require democracy.BOP will be…
    • Looks like a forfeit. I extend all arguments.

    Against

    • Thank you for making this debate and allowing me to debate with you sir. I just wish to point out that everyone has different views on everything and therefore making debates possible, I do not believe that we should start fights or cause any type of stirred anger towards one…
  21. 171.

    A flat tax is fairer than a progressive tax

    For

    • The example of the NBA players is specious because it applies to every aspect of life. It's not only the NBA players but also doctors and teachers like you brought up. Every person has a different job that dictates their salary but that's just the inevitable reality, flat tax…
    • Even though a society is a group of people working towards a mutual goal, you can't treat it as a single unit. Some people in that society work more, some work less, which means they deserve to be rewarded respectively. By saying that progressive tax is more fair on the basis…

    Against

    • "The example of the NBA players is specious because it applies to every aspect of life. It's not only the NBA players but also doctors and teachers like you brought up. Every person has a different job that dictates their salary but that's just the inevitable reality, flat tax…
    • Working harder/smarter only goes so far, we as people are different, we have different ability's, different interest and different talents. The #1 professional women basketball player no matter how hard she works will not make even close to the worst men professional player…
  22. 172.

    The welfare system should be replaced by a negative income tax

    For

    • Eliminate expensive administrative costs
    • It would be much simpler and fairer

    Against

    • It would abandon the worst off
    • It would be too complex and radical to instate
  23. 173.

    Progressive taxation should be upheld

    For

    • My contentions: 1.Progressive taxation was set forth as a transfer of the wealth. The rich have more to offer, and are there by taxed more. Thus the wealth is evened out, as all citizens receive a flat fee of services from the government. 2.Even with taxes, the rich have an…
    • 1.Progressive taxation was set forth as a transfer of the wealth. The rich have more to offer, and are there by taxed more. Thus the wealth is evened out, as all citizens receive a flat fee of services from the government. 2.Even with taxes, the rich have an immensely higher…

    Against

    • "None of these have been explicitly refuted." Ignoring my argument does not make it not there. :) "In addition, my opponent has changed the topic from flat vs. even to taxes vs. none, which is a conduct breach." Incorrect - the resolution is "Progressive tax should be upheld."…
    • "1.Progressive taxation was set forth as a transfer of the wealth. The rich have more to offer, and are there by taxed more. Thus the wealth is evened out, as all citizens receive a flat fee of services from the government." Transfer is simply a political term for theft.…
  24. 174.

    The US federal government should reduce subsidies for electric vehicles

    For

    • First I would like to point out that national debt is at record levels, and we have already seen the government of Greece on the verge of collapse due to debt. It is highly relevant to the debate. If the government collapses, there are NO subsidies of electric vehicles. I…
    • First I would like to address a very important point, and then address my opponent's points. The most important point is funding. Where are we going to get the money to continue subsidies of electric vehicles? Right now we're spending $1.5 trillion a year that we do not have. I…

    Against

    • I will first focus on my opponent's argument, then continue with my own. The United States has been in National Debt since the Revolutionary War. Specific numbers can be found in numerous locations. I prefer the following: http://www.wisc-online.com... Because of such, I…
    • I will be supporting why the Federal Government should not decrease subsidies of electric vehicles. My first argument will be the most obvious: Typical vehicles that use oil to function work by burning fossil fuels. Burning fossil fuels, however, is terrible for the environment…
  25. 175.

    The US should adopt more protectionist trade policies

    For

    • My opponent has discussed with me the possibility of leaving this final round as a brief summary to conclude the debate, so that we both will have had equal argumentation time. While I am inclined to focus on some issues my opponent brought up, I will not cite sources or argue…
    • He assumes, for example, that I feel that trade is "deadly" rather than that unlimited free trade is undesirable. He also assumes that because a job is 'closely associated' with a form of trade, that job must depend upon that associated trade. Moreover, the one source he cites…

    Against

    • First of all, I apologize if I exaggerated my opponent's position. I understand that he does not truly believe free trade to be "deadly. " I will refute his other claims pertaining to assumptions and conflation later in this round. My opponent states that I have made an…
    • My opponent continues to believe that protectionism will save America from the clutches of the recession, but nothing could be further from the truth. Contrary to my opponent's judgement, I do not believe that American consumers "have pools of wealth that are diminished solely…
  26. 176.

    Michigan automakers should not replace low-skill workers with automation

    For

    • I'm not saying the companies will go bankrupt I stating that the initial investment is a bit more of a financial stretch than they can handel at the moment. Making the cars with machinery would not make them cheaper. The mechanics and other employees hired to take care of…
    • Your information is inconclusive. If the low skill laborers are laid off and automation takes effect in these factories, the prices of cars will increase. The initial investment to provide automation in Michigan's automotive factories will cost more than or the same as the…

    Against

    • Again I would liek to reiterate that the economists that these companies have working for them will know when it is the right time to act and replace the workers. They will be able to insure long-term success with these machines. They also will calculate the annual costs of…
    • So you are saying that if these machines are installed, then the companies will all go bankrupt. Uhh... then why would they be considering it. These companies have brilliant economists who have thought this out a bunch. Also, althought these workers are "lowskill" they still…
  27. 177.

    The minimum wage should be abolished in the United States

    For

    • Whether or not most countries have minimum wage laws is hardly relevant, and considering the fact that most of the world's nations are doing poorly economically, it doesn't really strengthen your position. You ask me to prove that the Negative Income Tax is not communist.…
    • I would first like to respond to the following statement you made: "In a Country that does not have a Minimum wage, employees are forced to work at employer rates, in countries with some minimum wage they aren't." In a country that does not have minimum wage, there are three…

    Against

    • Basically my opponent forfieted, and he doesn't even have an active acount anymore.
    • My opponent did not as I asked prove the amount of inflation that would be reduced if the jobs where done in america. All he said was he vowed for 40% not 50%. W/e, still you gotta show me something to go off of. My opponent reverse income taxes idea is still flawed because it…
  28. 178.

    The EU should abandon the Common Agricultural Policy

    For

    • It doesn't serve its purpose (subsidies to larger farmers)
    • It is unfair to new members of EU

    Against

    • It protects rural communities
    • CAP protects the quality of the food in EU
  29. 179.

    Vast economic inequality harms the US economy

    For

    • "The incredible fact" is calculated by the sources mentioned underneath. Source: U.S. Census Bureau; Minnesota Population Center/IPUMS Explanation and analysis: http://www.nytimes.com... For the sake of fairness (and partly due to my exam tomorrow of which I must bone up), let…
    • Thanks for challenging this notion and for participating in this debate, 16kadams. (1) Income inequality may or may not be increasing. As inequality has increased, the wealth of the poor has also increased. Between 2000 - 2010, inequality has actually decreased. Let us be clear…

    Against

    • I will reiterate my last round summary: (1) Inequality may or may not be increasing(1a) Measurments of inequality are flawed(1b) Measurments exagerate income inequaliy(2) Economic disparity can be good under certian situations(2a) The 'good' economic disparity is what exists in…
    • R1) Inequality growth Technically, if you look at long term rates, the rate is unchanged. It increased throughout the 70s, fell, and then has increased to levels to those at about the 1920s [1. http://www.jstor.org...]. And, again, this begs the question as to whether or not…
  30. 180.

    Child labour should be permitted in some circumstances

    For

    • children are at work in China and India and their economies have soared in the last few decades, coming to match most Western powers. Obviously the countries would rather have workers and besides, they can go to school in the morning or evening, before or after work. another…
    • Children can work for small amounts, even less then minimum wage if nessasary. plus they can fit in small places inacessible to fully grown men and women like chambers in plants and bridges and under equipment in factories.

    Against

    • Children who work in dangerous places get ripped off because they make less a dollar a day, and often are beaten and some are even killed. Plus, we people can work for themselves.
    • Its not fair that children work in dangerous places and get paid such a little amount. Adults should be working. Children should be going to school.
  31. 181.

    Economic freedom should be valued above equity

    For

    • And we can celebrate when we have a government that has earned back the trust of the people it serves... when we have a government that honors our Constitution and stands up for the values that have made America, America: economic freedom, individual liberty, and personal…
    • thank you for posting con. i will just jump right in to my response. 1.The standard I"m not sure when the con proposed the standard but I disagree with your value of moral value for multiple reasons starting with: a.No such thing as absolute moral rightness First of all we must…

    Against

    • I didn"t see any rules so I will assume that Pro has the BOP. I will then respond to what she perceives are "arguments" and the voters will judge if I correctly denied her claims. R1 : Response to : Contention1- equity violate liberty and freedom of thought First of all, I…
    • Well.. Too bad...
  32. 182.

    A speculation tax on Wall Street is acceptable

    For

    • Although it saddens me to see that my opponent has once again forfeited the round, I once again reiterate my previous points.
    • I ask that the viewers of the debate not put Mr. Speaker's forfeit against him. I reiterate my previous points and once again await my opponents rebuttal.

    Against

    • Greetings, I am honored to have been challenged by name to this debate which will (hopefully) be an exceptional one. Since this is Pro's first debate, I feel obliged to offer a few brief pointers: 1. The debate topic is excellent as a speculation tax on Wall St. is a current,…
  33. 183.

    The gold standard should be restored

    For

    • Thank you for such a quick reply! RC1: Not everyone in the world trades gold in this way One of the best things that the gold standard does for America is that it gives us a solid currency that other countries can trade with. Some of the countries that we would be trading with…
    • C1: Inflation is rare Something can only be valuable when it is somewhat rare. If a certain currency has been printed to an extent where there is too much in the economy, it loses it's value. The reason for this is because it has lost a portion of it's rarity making it less…

    Against

    • Thanks you PRO for your response. RC1: Gold despite its famous stable nature is still a product If anybody had taken economics they would know the price of anything is dependent on the supply and demand. Changes in supply and changes in demand both affect the price of a…
    • C1: Technology changes the value for gold Some problems with todays world is that technology is taking over jewelry. If you haven't realized fewer and fewer people are buying jewelry for their loved ones and the market for a lot of jewelry is changing. If a modern person were…
  34. 184.

    Marxism is a superior economic system to capitalism

    For

    • Now, onto the rebuttals. FRAMEWORK: You didn't really attack my framework much after my rebutt of your original critique but no matter. All I have to do is explain why Bolshevik/Soviet Communism is not an example of Communism. To be honest, by the near universal definition of…
    • To begin with, my framework is perfectly valid. I will now quote wikipedia. "Communism (from Latin communis - common, universal) is a revolutionary socialist movement to create a classless and stateless social order structured upon common ownership of the means of production,…

    Against

    • I extend my appreciation toward my opponent for taking time out of his busy life to talk about a very prevalent issue. I will refute my opponent's point and then talk about the voting issues and wrap up this debate. 1. I understand your point, but you don't seem to realize that…
    • First, I will refute my opponent's framework, again, refute his contentions, and talk about voting issues and how the opposition has clearly won this debate. My opponent's repeatedly states that Bolshevik Communism should be ruled out. However, we should use this as a prime…
  35. 185.

    A mandated minimum wage does more damage than good

    For

    • This debate will consist of four rounds. Round One catalogs the pertinent definitions and rules, wherein my opponent may address any concerns. Rounds Two and Three shall comprise the claims, counter-claims, and evidence in a Lincoln-Douglas style debate. Round Four will be…
    • Obviously my opponent has forfeit.

    Against

    • Good day to those who will be observing this debate. I would first like to ask how a mandated minimum wage does more harm than a minimum wage without being mandated? Secondly Without a mandated minimum wage wouldn't an unfair form of favoritism become present in the workplace?…
    • As I begin my conclusion, I would like to remind voters of the resolution: A mandated minimum wage does more damage than good." Note that I was under no obligation to prove that the minimum wage was necessarily beneficial, only that the costs do not outweigh the benefits. For…
  36. 186.

    Foreign aid to Africa should be eliminated

    For

    • Hello Khalif! Had you been a student of Logic, you would agree that proving my statement only requires a single supporting example. I will explain if you need me to. My grandfather is named Calle - he fought in Africa during WW2. The guys often used racism to achieve military…
    • Anybody who says different will stand to loose this debate. That is not a threat, but a promise... I guarantee you an unconventional debate that borders on racism, but never crosses the line. To me, racism is not necessary a negative phenomenon, it can indeed be used as a tool…

    Against

    • My opponent has forfeited and offered no arguments. Vote con ^.^
    • I am a student of logic, and as such I can say your arguments are red herrings.The resolution: "African aid is wrong and the money is better spent on popcorn and movies"Wrong:" not in accordance with what is morally right or good".In order to fulfil the BoP, my opponent must…
  37. 187.

    The United States should outsource jobs to other countries

    For

    • Actually the United States outsourcing less than people think. According to the NCPA, is increased economic globalization has caused jobs to move to the United States as well as away from it. The United States does outsource IT companies to India, however we have companies that…
    • 1.Some people are against outsourcing because they feel like they are losing local jobs to overseas countries, however I disagree..While companies like outsourcing because they are able to save a lot of money in hiring costs, they are also promoting goods to developing…

    Against

    • Thank you for the chance for this debate. Reply 1. We may be helping developing countries and selling items at a cheaper rate however how can we have a working economy while so many people are unemployed and need govt. aid just to eat if we encourage our nation to outsource…
    • I don't believe in outsourcing jobs to other countries. We need to focus on growing our economy and our employment. When we focus primarily on profit of big business we are not benefitting the United States, but focusing on other countries to grow their employment through our…
  38. 188.

    A hybrid of capitalism and socialism is the best economic system

    For

    • The argument is that a hybrid approach is best in general, not arguing for one of many specific detailed approaches. In R1 I stated this debate would be high-level rather than detailed. So, in this debate I am not require to go into specifics or degrees of socialism/capitalism…
    • Socialism - a political and economic theory of social organization that advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole. Captialism - an economic and political system in which a country's trade and…

    Against

    • I understand the brief as you put it in R1, but to argue that the USA is a hybrid system which is failing and then say 'what we need is a hybrid system' is clearly not a satisfactory argument. Specifics were required to clarify how exactly a hybrid system would be a better…
    • 'We can already see a hybrid approach in every major economic country in the world, to varying degrees.' So, what we need is a hybrid approach to ensure that global economies are no longer 'doomed to fail'. Contradictory? The question you need to answer is to what degree. I…
  39. 189.

    Oil companies are responsible for high gas prices

    For

    • Although I do respect the simplistic approach you are taking to the issue, the fact of the matter is that the sale of crude oil is a very complex matter. The US can only buy as much oil as Canada is willing to sell, since it needs its own oil too. Also, the oil that comes from…
    • I will accept under the condition that "the middle" refers to the middle east and also I will request that the debate centers around why "we" (the USA, I'm assuming) do not import MORE oil from Canada and less from the middle east. I request this because the largest supplier of…

    Against

    • Alright, my argument is that Obama wants to try and be friendlier to the Middle East so ergo he buys the oil from them, which costs more for the U.S. If we got more of the oil from Canada than in most probability gas prices would go down, it might not be all that much but it…
    • Whoever accepts to take this argument will be talking about how we are getting gas from the middle instead of Canada. Which to me makes absolutely no sense. Thank you, -Tyler
  40. 190.

    Government employee unions have a positive impact on the United States

    For

    • (see conmments)
    • Thank you.

    Against

    • Since my opponent is still holding his lines I shall continue this debate. Here are my rebuttals. My opponent has stated in his first point that "it isn't fair to decrease the public sector's pay because of the recession". Well, if we pay someone who does not work, what good is…
    • My opponent has forfeited but I will give him another chance to attack my points, If he continues to forfeit, I shall forfeit as well.
  41. 191.

    Taxes should be significantly cut

    For

    • Point 1: Well it's impossible to have no taxes unless you want no Government (I'm not an Anarchist or extreme Libertarian). "On average, the wealthiest people in America pay a lot more taxes than the middle class or the poor, according to private and government data."" The 10%…
    • Point 1: Some taxes are justifiable and needed, but the current tax rates are terrible. The taxes we pay for public services with should come from the individual State and not the Country because the public services come from the State, so you would be paying for other's…

    Against

    • C1: Taxation in General "Some taxes are justifiable and needed, but the current tax rates are terrible"So you and me agree that taxes are justifiable and needed. Plus, public services come from the nation as well, including regulatory protections with our environment, food,…
    • Taxes are justifiable: Taxes are justifiable and needed. First, the taxes we pay are used to pay for infrastructure, our legal system, educational resources, and economic opportunities that allow people to make a lot of wealth in the first place. Second, providing for our…
  42. 192.

    Minimum wage laws harm the economy

    For

    • 1) You're completely nonresponsive to my argument that minimum wage laws to not actually provide a check on discriminatory wages. Just because women must make at least the minimum wage does not guarantee that they will be making the same as men. If you're looking for the…
    • 1) I agree with your point that there should be a check on discrimination between the pay of men and women, but minimum wage laws are not the way to go about it. Not only do the harms of economy decline outweigh any possible benefits, but minimum wage laws don't even solve this…

    Against

    • Firstly I would like to congratulate you lol. That is the strongest argument you've had. Now to assess your arguments… 1) What I was trying to imply with vague wording on the connection between minimum wage laws and discrimination is actually fairly simple. Discrimination will…
    • 1) As a woman and not yet an adult I would at least like to have the comfort of a minimum wage. This comfort allows me to have the knowledge that I will get at least as much as an adult male with the same work experience as I. Without the minimum wage the 1920's will be…
  43. 193.

    A flat tax would be fair

    For

    • The Flat Tax would be a fair system where everyone pays the same percentage in taxes. This system would have many benefits because most flat tax plans remove deductions and loopholes so that way no one can cheat on their taxes. The main opposing argument for the fairness of a…

    Against

    • So many forfeits.
    • Oh, well.
  44. 194.

    The minimum wage should not be raised

    For

    • Round 1 is acceptanceRound 2 & 3 are argumentsRound 4 is final statements; no new information this roundNo forfeitingHappy π Day.
    • So, for the reasons that I listed minimum wage should not be raised. Thank you for debating.

    Against

    • I would be happy to tell you where I got my 98% number. I made it up. It was not, nor was it ever intended to be a supportable statistic. It's use was satirical.You argued: "The Minimum Wage should not be raised."You then argued: "Indeed, the minimum wage should go up with…
    • I accept. 98% of DDO users make Minimum wage. You're locking them into the same pay rate for the rest of their life. Inflation will require an adjustment anways.In 1960, it was $1.60. So it should still be $1.60? Inflation says it should and will go up. Why are you subjecting…
  45. 195.

    Governments should prohibit appearance-based discrimination in hiring

    For

    • In todays world, particularly in the Business World, when hired or getting paid higher salary, many studies show that attractive people tend to get the most benefits, and people who are perceived as unattractive tend be below the rate then the attractive people. People call it…

    Against

    • vote moi
    • I extend my thesis to the next round.
  46. 196.

    Capitalism is an immoral system

    For

    • I agree with my opponent that state-owned companies are immoral, but that is not the form of economy I argue for anyways, and is rather irrelevant. An economy of state-owned companies is called state capitalism, by the way. I would actually consider that a misnomer and I'm sure…
    • First, I shall point out that in capitalism, hierarchy is basically inevitable. It is something necessary to have for capitalism to exist and do well as an economic system. There has to be someone who owns a business and people who work under that person. One can argue that a…

    Against

    • I had agreed that capitalism denotes the private ownership of means of production as opposed to state ownership of the means of production, which is the most common usage of the term (1)(2). Capitalism does not preclude certain types of private ownership, such as cooperatives,…
    • The attempt to define an economic system as either moral or immoral is a difficult undertaking. For my purposes, I will agree to use my opponent"s proposed basis for determining the ethical nature of an economic system: a system is moral if it only has "positions which are…
  47. 197.

    Liberal economic policies harm the American economy

    For

    • Extend. Vote for me, as my opponent has conceded.
    • Extend current argument.As for changing my opponent's opinions: That was not the aim of my debate. The aim was to prove, not to persuade.I shall take this as your formal concession, declaring myself winner of this debate. Just keep extending your concession over the next few…

    Against

    • Concede
    • Concede!
  48. 198.

    The minimum wage should be raised

    For

    • The con side has forfeited the 2nd round so I will keep this short to keep it fair. The point of the minimum wage, as put by FDR, is to make sure someone can have a decent level of living. The current minimum wage is a poverty wage and needs to be raised. I do not want 15…
    • I accept the challenge and will debate that we should raise the minimum wage. The resolution or the con speaker did not define or say how far reaching this raise was or how much it will be, so I will debate that this will be a increase on the existing federal minimum wage. I…

    Against

    • The purpose of the minimum wage is to help those disenfranchised workers who earn far less than what most Americans would consider acceptable. However, raising the minimum wage will only hurt those same marginalized workers. This is because you force those disenfranchised…
    • "My opponent claims that if we raise the minimum wage, that it would make such a difference that it would make employers not want to hire any laborers." My argument against the minimum wage is primarily an argument on economic principle, not an actual dollar amount - I am not…
  49. 199.

    A negative income tax should replace welfare programs

    For

    • I would like to debate the idea of a negative income tax. The idea is simple: The Gov sets a poverty threshold of X$, anyone earning below X$ would get the difference paid by the Gov. I recently made a poll about this topic and was surprised by how many people were against it.…
    • Your "low accuracy - high precision" argument is very interesting. I admit that indeed the Mincome study had to take that into account. ************************************************************************************************************ Your quote: "Objection : What…

    Against

    • " If Mr. Mario knows that he could get 1000$/month anyway, he would have the power to negotiate his salary in a fair way with his employer. Mr. Mario would probably say "Listen boss, if you don't pay me more than a 1000$/month, I simply quit, I will get mincome anyway"So you…
    • REBUTTALSI find this Canadian study very interesting. However while looking at the results of these studies we have to consider some facts :- People knew the study was temporary, therefore their condition was precarious and left unchanged financial motivation to work harder in…
  50. 200.

    Welfare programs promote laziness

    For

    • For a brief roadmap i will be covering all of my opponents prior arguments, and proving how my side of the debate should be the one accepted. Obervation 1: My opponent stated that people commit suicide for a number of reasons, but there is one underlining issue left. He never…
    • For a brief roadmap i will be covering all of my opponents prior arguments, and proving how my side of the debate should be the one accepted. Observation1: First of all "proud" is a word that has several definitions. According to dictionary.com proud is defined as "having,…

    Against

    • I've already proven my stance in round one (which my opponent has not covered) so please extend all of my arguments as voting issues. I will go through my opponent's last speech and deconstruct their arguments piece by piece. Obs1: This has become irrelevant to the resolution…
    • I'm just going offer a few observations on the round thus far, and then proceed to argue straight down the flow. Obs1: in my opponent's initial arguments, they've laid down the groundwork arguments; and in these very arguments, they've given them-self the burden to prove that…

How to use these debate topics

  • Vote, discuss, revote. Poll the room on the motion, give 5 minutes of discussion, then vote again and look at who changed their mind.
  • Four corners. Label corners strongly agree → strongly disagree; people move, then each corner makes its best case.
  • Switch sides. Halfway through, everyone argues the side they disagree with. It sharpens listening.

Run them live

Want every person to answer on their own phone, with a timer and a live leaderboard? Use these questions in an EngageSlide Vote · Discuss · Revote — free to start.

Tick questions on any page — your set is kept while you browse (or take the first 10 here) — and they become ready-to-play slides. What is EngageSlide?

More question collections

Questions adapted from args.me corpus (CC BY 4.0), edited for clarity. This collection may be reused under the same terms — see sources & licenses.