Religion Debate Topics — page 63
3,675 debate topics, all ages. Debatable motions with arguments for and against. Open the arguments below, pick one at random, or present them full-screen.
- 3101.
Arguments against the Christian God are valid
For
- =====Argument from Evil===== 1. Burden to prove free will trumps God's desire to eliminate evil >>>Free will is not free will if we are morally perfect. <<< I never said it was. I was offering other options than free will (since you say free will causes people to do evil).…
- Delicious :). I thank my opponent for accepting this debate. I agree with my opponent's observations - I have a certain burden to uphold. =====Counterarguments===== 1. Argument from Evil 1A. Evil exists in the world >>>...God gave us free will to choose what path we want to…
Against
- I'll list major points, and then respond. 1. Other options to Free Will --> Christian Framework: Free Will is assumed for this debate. (Not assumption as in the totality of assumption, but we must assume it either exists or it does not.) --> He never provides a warranted…
- He argued the following: 1. My burden to prove free will w/o moral perfection --> Free will is not free will if we are morally perfect. For example, I am given a bunch of choclate chip cookies right? I can only eat these cookies, do I have free will then? Obviously not. If God…
- 3102.
Religion causes many of the world's problems
For
- Looking at many past and current problems in the world, I believe that Religion causes many more problems in the world than people may think.
- For your final argument, I would suggest just arguing against my Round Three argument. Thank you.
Against
- Before I begin, I like your profile picture Pro! I will be arguing that religion does not cause the world's problems. Let's set some definitions. Definitions:Religion is defined as the belief in a god or in a group of gods [1. . http://www.merriam-webster.com...] Cause means…
- I am on vacation for the weekend and wont have time to complete the argument. I will be back for the final round.
- 3103.
No religion is the one true religion
For
- I too have read these texts along with Pagan, Christian (and many of the permutations there of) along with that of Wicca Buddhist, Taoist, and zen. I am well aware that there are many that I have not touched upon. The argument that you provide about humans having created god…
- Having searched religions to find which is right for me. I have found that all have some measure of truth. My argument is that there is no one true religion as we will never have all the facts. The bible is supposed to be the word of the Christian god but it has been diluted…
Against
- okay so i shall finish, i am not the most religious person living on earth and neither m i the best researcher or the most acknowledged person but now allow me to talk not just about my religion that is Islam instead lets talk on the basic believes of all religions. starting…
- What in this world really makes sense without the support of a religion and what in this world actually tells you the purpose of you being in this world? It is a religion that gives you the answers to your basic questions that are unanswered by Science that is suppose to give…
- 3104.
Catholics should be considered Christians
For
- The three different traditions *Are Christianity. Here is something you may not know about Protestants, they have over 36,000 denominations. Each one worships God in a very different way. And as I have said, Protestant is not synonymous with Catholic, which means Protestant…
- Just check this site, "http://www.ncregister.com...; Protestant is not exactly synonymous with Christian. There are Three Christian Traditions, Protestant, Catholic, and Eastern Orthodox
Against
- I believe this says it all:https://www.diffen.com... So like I keep saying:even the slightest difference tells us apart. Catholics and christians are not the same.
- Still, how we worship god is different. Although what we do is similar,why do you think they made three different traditions? Because how we worship god is different. So yes we are somelike similar to each other but even the slightest difference shouldnt be ignored. And the…
- 3105.
There is no proof that God exists
For
- It made an interesting first debate for me on here and I will certainly be taking part in more. Up until not I actually hadn't heard of the arguement proposed! I would also like to apoligise as I missed putting in my source link at the end of round 3 and even though the debate…
- However he has failed on many points, especially since we have specified that we are talking about the Christian God. To Begin Con states that "One does not have to show that a world where a pig flies is logically or metaphysically possible". This is true, and I feel he is…
Against
- Speeding things along.
- I was just trying to play devil's advocate. However, I feel kind of silly defending this argument is it so bad. I'll concede.
- 3106.
Christianity and science can coexist
For
- Good Luck, Con. The main point of my argument is that many parts of the Bible are meant to be taken metaphorically. In analysis of the scriptures you used, I don't see how any of them say that the Bible cannot be taken metaphorically. Under normal circumstances, I would use…
- It is a common misconception that because a person is religious, namely Christian, they must also deny evolution, old-earth theory, and many other scientific principles. I don't pretend to know everything about religion or science. Far from it. All I am saying is that there is…
Against
- My opponent has forfeited his round. He must see my point. I have already shown that according to God's word, the bible is mean to be taken literally and, I will spend my last round presenting a few additional inconsistencies the bible and science have with one another. Genesis…
- Lets settle something. You say there are parables in the bible not meant to be taken literally but you provide NO proof in the bible where it says that they aren't meant to be taken literally. Then I'm just going to throw this out there "The parts of Greek mythology that are…
- 3107.
Atheism is more dangerous than theism
For
- I am sorry that my opponent has forfeited the round.Im summary, the contender has failed to show anything in the fundamental assumptions of atheism which would encourage good behavior, and he has failed to argue against the fundamental assumptions which i pointed out would…
- Thankyou Con for your response and sorry for my time getting back to you;Con replied:"The fact that there is no higher authority than yourself does not automatically mean that crime becomes a good thing."This isn't my point at all. Belief in a higher authority is a leash to…
Against
- I am terribly sorry for ignoring you call for acceptance, but please excuse that as i am simply a beginner. I apologize for any inconvenience i may have caused. The fact that there is no higher authority than yourself does not automatically mean that crime becomes a good thing.…
- Atheists are NOT fundamentally more dangerous than theists. Atheism does not mean disbelief in god. It is believing that there is NO SUCH THING as god. What we do each day, depends on what we, personally believe. It is a reflection of our morals and what we believe is right.…
- 3108.
The Bible is a reliable historical source
For
- Blessed are you when people insult you, persecute you and falsely say all kinds of evil against you because of me. 12 Rejoice and be glad, because great is your reward in heaven, for in the same way they persecuted the prophets who were before you. Love, humans have love, we…
- A lot these prophecies are still to come just assuming they are from the Old Testament doesn't mean it hasn't happened yet. Also a few others have been result from the failing of the Jewish people not going forward with God's plan. It cannot happen if the correct people…
Against
- So you basically say they are not happened yet. What if they never happen? Have you considered the other side of the coin? These assumptions can be made by a 12 year old school kid anyways. "One day this river will dry!". "One day we will all go back to earth we came from" Pro,…
- Sir if i am blinded, you are in a coma. since you stated some sources from bible that appears to be truely happened according to history, let me tell you there are thousands of predictions where bible fails. I cant write them all down because of 10k characters max yet I want…
- 3109.
Islam honors and respects women
For
- The common belief and misconception of Islam oppressing women is totally out of this world. Sure some Muslim by name countries look down on women, but it has nothing to do with the Islamic faith itself. Furthermore all of these hate/evangelical sites (that can be easily found)…
- I will ask my opponent to analyze further what he brings. He claims he has not copied from anti-Islam sites yet his material reflect. I mean the out-of-context verses? The unreliable hadiths? It's quite obvious to me he did not come up with his work on his own. Also It amazes…
Against
- The tone of my opponent's argument switches to a plea as she enters the third round. Then she accuses me of introducing obvious errors (which are at best her opinion), plagiarizing from anti-Islam sites (without any sort of proof), and arguing with red herrings (the only…
- Readers, my opponent claims I have "brought verses out of their original meaning" and "misinterpreted commentary." Further, she accuses my answers of being copied from "anti-Islam" sites. Ironically, I introduced no text whatsoever that was not from a document of Islam. If…
- 3110.
Science offers no compelling evidence that God is personal
For
- RationalMadMan, As much as I appreciate your point of view, I feel it does very little to strengthen your position of arguing for A God who is personal with his subjects. In fact, it seems your argument leans more towards an impersonal God who doesn't want to interfere. You…
- Rationalmadman. So are you saying God is able to be personal but won't ? What you are saying is very vague. Please provide a sound argument as to how God can be shown to be personal.
Against
- You wish for a bigger penis, God gives it to you. What has this done to any and all men competing with you for a woman? Caused a disadvantage. What has this in turn done to children of that woman? Forced them to have your genetics as opposed to what they could have had. What…
- The moment God assists some people, he inherently has caused a disadvantage to others in this world of competition. In other words whatever God does "Yin" will always have a downfall "Yan" thus god is incapable of being personal without affecting everything and everyone by the…
- 3111.
The Christian God exists
For
- Goodbey and Goodnight
- Okay yes but if you put gears and all the components to make a watch into a bag then trust and shaked to bag around then opened it what is the chance that a clock would appear fully entacted functional and how long and how amy shakes would it take to get a watch out of the bag.…
Against
- Its completely fine, however, there is the fact of probability. If you shake the bag, there is lets say a 1/10000000 of a chance that everything aligns into one specific pattern. But with that argument said, the earth has been in existence for BILLIONS of years. And humans have…
- I hope you do settle this topic for yourself and find how "God" cannot be real. Also, relating to your anecdote, I would have to say that a pocketwatch and nature are two completely different things. One (stopwatch) has a definitive history which can be proven, while nature…
- 3112.
Scientology should be recognized as a legitimate religion
For
- No arguments have been offered against the resolution. Resolution affirmed.
- Resolved: That the word Scientology is a pairing of the Latin word scienti ("Knowledg The resolution is an incomplete fragment, but I will assume it was meant to be: The word Scientology is a pairing of the Latin word scientia ("knowledge", "skill"), which comes from the verb…
Against
- Double, double, toil and trouble; Fire burn and cauldron bubble. Pour in sow's blood that hath eaten her nine farrow; grease that's sweaten from the muderer's gibbet throw into the flame; finger of birth-strangled babe, ditch-deliver'd by a drab; Make the gruel thick and slab,…
- Scientology is a body of beliefs and related practices created by L. Ron Hubbard (1911–1986), starting in 1952, as a successor to his earlier self-help system, Dianetics.[1] Hubbard characterized Scientology as a religion and in 1953 incorporated the Church of Scientology in…
- 3113.
The biblical global flood actually happened
For
- If you notice that my text may sound rushed, that's probably because it is. My PC has recovered and now I just found out that I have seven hours left for this round. Now onto my rebuttal. Argument 1 Tectonic plate movement In my opponent's text, he implies that a entirely…
- These arguments presented by my opponent have a rational ring to them. Others have noticed that as well, for these are the usual statements presented against creationists. Withal, in this round I will soundly disprove each of them as well as strengthen mine in the process of…
Against
- Plate TectonicsPlate tectonics is not "just" a theory. Plate motions have been measured using high-precision GPS and have been found to be in exceptionally good agreement with predictions [45]. In fact, my opponent's arguments requires plate tectonics to raise up the ocean…
- I'm sorry to hear that my opponent's computer and busy schedule have been giving him grief. Here's hoping that things are looking up.Tiny DifferencesLast round I neglected to address the following quote that my opponent provided:"The hypsographic (Gk. hypsos=height) chart shows…
- 3114.
God exists and humans are without excuse for denying Him
For
- All of them. There is no other religion/worldview that can give an account for truth. They all have inconsistencies. Christianity is the only religion that can account for epistemology (how we know anything), ethics (right and wrong), and metaphysics (creation).
- The Christian God is the one and true God. Hopefully this debate will show how nobody can say anything to try and disprove God and will lead the unbeliever into repentance.
Against
- Please list ten of them and say what is wrong with each of them
- I am a, 100%, non-believer. Please list the other gods who are not true gods
- 3115.
God should be taken completely out of school
For
- Thank you for your response and your thoughts. In your opening you stated kids will not just randomly walk into a church too learn about other religions. If kids or students are not interested in different religions then what would make a student take a class on religions. In…
- In response to your opening statement. While I agree knowledge of any kind should not be denied children that want to learn there are other and superior ways of obtaining theology information then a public school. Most churches and mosque have an open door policy and if…
Against
- While I don't know the reason my opponent forfeiting the previous round, I would like to make one last point and state that Religion is important in the world and it is the foundation of what a person believes and what their morals are, so the way the country is going (away for…
- First off there is no reason to be offended about being taught about different religions, I am a Christian and yet when I'm in school and I'm in Biology class learning about evolution, I don't get offended AND IT'S FORCED! so there's no reason to get offended if its being…
- 3116.
LaVeyan Satanism is no more harmful than other religions
For
- I will be arguing on the premise that Laveyan Satanism is not bad and that it should not be looked down upon in today's society. Con will obviously be refuting what I say. First Round is for acceptance, then we start to argue. To whomever it may be, Good Luck!
- Since my opponent has forfeited, I will not continue arguments, so that he can respond to my original argument.
Against
- Well I am a strong Christian, and I hope to change your views. I look forward to this.
- 3117.
Tithing has become a dependency for many churches
For
- What I mean by that is that tithing is the needle, the concoction of out of context and old testament scripture manipulation, mixed up just right is the 'heroin', and the high is the justification by old testament law and man. That is the tithers reward. LoL! Hear ye hear ye…
- What I mean by that is that tithing is the needle, the concoction of out of context and old testament scripture manipulation, mixed up just right is the 'heroin', and the high is the justification by old testament law and man. That is the tithers reward.
Against
- You state "What I mean by that is that tithing is the needle, the concoction of out of context and old testament scripture manipulation, mixed up just right is the 'heroin', and the high is the justification by old testament law and man. That is the tithers reward." Hear ye,…
- Our time together has come to an end, and I have enjoyed it immensely. As you can SEE for yourselves, despite Gods Holy Word being shown to persons Like Pro ... it IS disregarded, for what? For what "THEY" believe. Despite Gods Word to "LEAN NOT" unto their OWN understanding…
- 3118.
Muhammad was a prophet of God
For
- Religious background is irrelevant in this debate, but Muhammad is a prophet of God none the less. I will start the debate by considering what makes God God. We are three dimensional beings that pass through the world and always restricted in our understanding of what else is…
- Proposing the motion that Muhammad is a prophet of God. I welcome my opponent to start the debate and should they defer, I will take the reigns.
Against
- So Muhammad? Your Muslim right? So tell why you think he's a prophet?
- That's proof right there. You can judge which to me and I think most people it's wrong. And there's a lot of Muslim extremists which force people into their ways which is taking away peoples free will. I think Muhammad probably was influential but not the last prophet of god.
- 3119.
Islam will ultimately prevail over the LGBT movement
For
- Simple: Between the two movements taking place, MUSLIMS claim persecution, LGBT claim persecution. Islam persecutes LGBT, but still poses as the one provoked in any attack it offers, media culture hi-lights this all the time with the false sensation of what really even took…
- References: http://lgbt.wikia.com... http://www.mpvusa.org... Jordan's muslim country from the internet's browsing ability seems to appear the most progressive towards LGBT. However, even they seem to be non-protective of legally enforcing the LGBT individuals. (At least from…
Against
- Sexual diversity is a biological reality. It was around millions years ago and will exist millions years from now. Islam is a human constructed institution. It will eventually end like all institutions. After Islam eventually ends, sexual diversity will still exist and be…
- How can I argue with racism? I mean this is really not a winning strategy. I'm wasting my time. Go believe and live your bigotry. I've got better things to do than waste breath on some white supremacist internet scum.
- 3120.
The Trinity is true and Jesus is God
For
- In the Old Testament, like the New Testament we find 3 distinct beings who are God: 1. THE LORD (FATHER) 2. Angel of the LORD (SON) 3. Sprit of the LORD (Holy Spirit) Now, we can all agree on the first one, but onto the second. The Word for Angel in Hebrew Mlakim, is simply…
- Hi will debate you on this issue
Against
- I forgot round 4. Oh well. Would it make sense that God would send a bunch of prophets over a span of thousands of years with a rational and consistent message of complete monotheism only to all of a sudden reveal a trinity, a doctrine that contradicts his previous prophets'…
- R1: AcceptanceR2: WhateverR3: WhateverR4: WhateverRules:1. No preaching. 2. Don't rebuke me in the name of Jesus3. Don't call me demon possessed 4. No speaking in tongues
- 3121.
God, as described in the Bible, does not exist
For
- I am looking forward to this debate. Forgive me if I mess up as this is my first debate. The God of the Bible is supposedly omnipotent. Therefore, I cannot have any control over this being; God's creation has control over the Biblical God Therefore, the Bible God does not exist…
- It is my assertion and contention that the God of the Bible does not and cannot exist. My opponent, on the other hand, will be negating that resolution.
Against
- arguments extended. Pro forfeited.
- All arguments extended.....again.
- 3122.
Belief that there is no god is justified
For
- Recent changes to the definition of atheism states that it is a lack of belief towards god/gods, and that this definition of an atheist does not have to prove anything because they neither accept nor deny the notions that god exists or god does not exist. I am defending the…
Against
- I accept. 5 rounds is probably 2-3 rounds too many. Atheists do not attribute the term atheist to themselves. Atheist / atheism is a descriptive term that other people attribute to atheists. Please describe how tribal people in New Guinea have a belief in a God with which to…
- Pro forfeited.
- 3123.
God cannot exist, since feeling joy requires feeling pain
For
- you need it
- pew pew
Against
- Lol. Pass.
- Pass
- 3124.
Christianity is harmful to society
For
- Extend all arguments at this point and vote for me because I was the only one with an argument. My opponent could make an argument at this point, but that would be abuse because I would not be able to make a counterargument.
- My opponent has made no case of his own, so extend all of m.y points across the flow. Thank you
Against
- Ok, I accept
- 3125.
At least one god exists
For
- I'm going to list a few reasons why a rational person ought to believe in God. 1) The Cosmological Argument I. Everything with a beginning has a cause II. The universe has a beginning III. Therefore, The universe has a cause. 2) The Teleological Argument Had the conditions of…
Against
- On the resurrection of Jesus Christ, It seems that the proponent made bold claims without backing them up with evidence. To make a valid case against the resurrection of Jesus, I will cite the historian Richard Carrier (https://infidels.…
- The cosmological argument does not prove theism at all. The only thing it proves is that the universe has a prime cause. It doesn"t suggest, Let alone prove, That the cause was a being, And it doesn"t suggest that this cause was a being that is eternal, Omnipotent, Omniscient,…
- 3126.
The Christian God exists
For
- Enough said till there is a response.
- Enough said till there is a response.
Against
- To define the parameters of this debate: God is a being conceived as the perfect, omnipotent, omniscient originator and ruler of the universe, the principal object of faith and worship in Christianity. The burden of proof is on the Pro side - however truisms from the con side…
- I have no doubt that he truly believes what he is professing. Though this is unconvincing to me, it cannot be said of my opponent that he is attempting to deceive or put forth arguments he does not believe in. I hope it is understood that I feel I too have been sincere. With…
- 3127.
Historical, archaeological, and scriptural evidence proves Jesus is the Messiah
For
- The bible is a witness of truth. If rightly divided. And eternal document that will stand forever. Unlike Darwin and his theory of evolution. Which is just wrong. I challenge my opponent to prove that Christ who died on a cross, born a virgin, and who was in Eden ,did not…
- My opponent seems to speak for all of Humanity! America is about self expression and independence is the illusion of USA one nation under God! I refute your assertion about 'what matters' , are you, the World Judge who decides what is good for everyone? I am not crazy because I…
Against
- We learned about Jesus from the Bible, so the story of Jesus (with all its details) would be true if the Bible was true, what is something that no one can prove without raising doubts. The Bible is a ancient document like many others, which suffered many modifications due to…
- Again you insist on what I don"t said. I don"t talk in the name of all humanity. And you are making judgments as much as me or even more. For example, it was you who began this debate saying that atheists are wrong. This is a judgment already. And it is you who are putting…
- 3128.
The Christian God exists and Christ is a reality, not a religion
For
- 1. I refute my opponents false claim that Christianity is anyway supported by the bible! That is a lie. The word "Christianity' is not even in the bible. I also refute your false claim that the bible in anyway supports any;"Christian Reality".The word Christian means Christ…
- Thank you for this debate. The Christian God is The Alpha of the bible, The Root of David, The Son of David, John 1:1, Luke 3:38=Adam, The man formed to til the ground, The Root and Offspring of David Rev.22:16, The Alpha of the Bible, The Omega of the Bible. 1. I argue that…
Against
- Well, this debate is over since my opponent just conceded."The BoP has been established. Jesus Christ is the Christian God,The Root of David, Adam, the Alpha of the Bible. Rev.22:16 The Root and Offspring of David. My opponent needs to prove Jesus Christ never existed ever or,…
- After looking through Pro's round, I found zero arguments. At a stretch, he might have made two points.1. The bible supports the Christian reality.My refutation is that Pro has given no reason as to why the Bible is reliable.2. Islam and other religions are bad.This is…
- 3129.
God supports same-sex marriage
For
- My argument is the logical proof. In short it is this:P1) God is fairP2) Gays are born gayC1) Gays have the same religious rights to marriageIn long it is the following:P1) God existsP2) God is fairP3) God creates people and their characteristics intentionally P4) Homosexuality…
- The topic is that god, according to the christian doctrine, agrees with gay marriage. The debate will solely be refutation of my logical proof. You do not accept the folowing upon acceptance of the round...P1.) The Christian God is a fair god.P2.) There are homosexuals who are…
Against
- I do believe that there are compelling non-religious reasons for forbidding same-sex marriage. As this is a debate about religion, I do not expect it to convince non-religious people. That is irrelevant, though, as this debate is about whether or not the Christian God supports…
- Additionally, Pro is correct, that just because homosexual marriage is opposed to the Bible, it does not mean that we should force that view on the general public. As I indicated in the first round, my arguments here will not convince someone who doesn't believe in the Bible. I…
- 3130.
Islam is compatible with peaceful societies
For
- Islam is incapable by its nature of being peaceful. The Koran was made by Muhammad, a child molester and war lord. He instructs Muslims to jihad (a holy war) and the end goal of Islam is world domination; and it's working because they are the fastest growing religion.
- If you take the book literally and are seen as a terrorist, then maybe the Koran is violent. Also, stoning, beheading and legal raping happens legally all the time. You also cannot deny the oppression of women in Islamic countries.
Against
- My opponent is stating that Islam is a naturally violent religion, now while I am of a different faith I do not see this as being the case. If you were to do what I did and actually look up what the Islamic beliefs are you would come across the "Five Pillars of Islam." The…
- The Qur'an is not violent, it's the dang terrorists. I'm getting tired of stating that, but it's the truth. It's not Islam that's violent, it's not the book, it's not their gods, it's the terrorists. The terrorists are the ones who are stoning people, beheading them, and raping…
- 3131.
The Catholic Church is the most corrupt institution in history
For
- First off I resent being referred to as "my opponent" I'm am Josh not a reference word. and second off id like to point out that "Inquire truth" has focused more on diversion argument and pointing the finger at every other "bad religion" other than its self. Although he has…
- Few who are members of the Catholic faith truly realise its shocking history, in this debate I hope to drag up some hardcore reality check material to throw in the face of all those self delusional bigots who dare to assume they, above others, are favored by "a higher being".…
Against
- ================== Introduction: ================== My opponent (I'm sorry if this offends, it is not a pejorative term), has not come close to meeting his burden. But I will not let his rhetoric go without comment. As another note, I am not Catholic myself as my opponent seems…
- ============ Introduction ============ My opponent has an incredibly large burden – he need not only show that the Catholic church is by and large a corrupt institution, but that it is, among the copious list of crazy and corrupt cults and organizations, the single most corrupt…
- 3132.
Atheism is a system of argument rather than a belief
For
- I may not have fully understood some of your more subtle points so let me apologize now if I inadvertently misrepresent your views or argue against something you did not assert. I will reassert, in the light of your objections, my argument that atheism is not a lack of belief…
- I will argue that the only logical use of the word "atheism" is to refer to a system of argumentation. This proposal has the necessary implications that the word "atheist" should only be used to refer to people who, in one way or another, engage in this system of argumentation.…
Against
- "Cats and babies should not be called atheists ..." Refer to R1 where I specifically state applying a status of belief claims to entities unable to formulate belief claims or even religious perspectives is nonsensical to begin with. "Consider a man who was raised under a…
- There are really only two main issues here that I need to contend. Firstly, what is atheism and secondly why it isn't a system of argumentation. To that end the majority of my opponent's argument can be ignored since I only need to address the one definition of what atheism is…
- 3133.
Jesus can be proven to be the Messiah
For
- You may use quotes from google docs, but not a whole doc. Let the debate begin. Jesus was regarded by the Jews as a man of God and a prophet. But they rejected him on the will of the Pharisees, who were afraid of an uprising of their power and Rome. But they never looked at the…
- RonPaul, I would like to trash our former debate and debate you on Jesus. I will be trying to prove to you He is the Messiah and you are to try and prove he is not. The Format shall be as follows: 2nd round: Arguments 3rd Round: Rebuttals 4th Round: Counter-Arguments 5th Round:…
Against
- 1. Alma means young woman, not virgin, as a matter of fact this same word was used 7 times in the Tanakh and these same translators translated the other six as "a young woman."2. Anyone can be born in Bethlehem, Jesus still hasn't provided his birth certificate that he was born…
- Well this should be intresting, are google docs allowed? If so whats the page limit?
- 3134.
Jesus is not portrayed as God in the Gospel of Mark
For
- CONCLUSIONI am sorry if I have not been clear. I'll endeavour to state the case without ambiguity. It's very simple.First, I quote the Catechism as it states my point exactly. I am saying that the title "Son of God" does not have to mean that Jesus is God, as it is used in…
- I am proposing that Jesus is not God in the Gospel of Mark. Of course, Jesus is viewed as the Messiah, or Christ, and in that sense sent by God, but he is not viewed as himself Divine, though he can perform magic and miracles just as other prophets of God were able to do…
Against
- In my closing arguments, I'll attempt to recap how the debate went and see if any conclusions can be drawn. theskeptic's arguments theskeptic was arguing that in the Gospel of Mark Christ is not considered divine and you attempted to show this through two points. 1. There is no…
- What?!?Let me see if I understand, you claim that Mark shows us a Christ that did miracles, was the Messiah/Christ, was sent by God, and had a unique relationship with God, but was not God? Then to support your claim that being called the son of God is no big deal you appeal to…
- 3135.
Deism is the most truthful worldview
For
- I apologize, because I did fail to read the conclusion of your essay, as at the end of a day of hard physical and mental labor, I am prone to running off at the mouth/keyboard, often time to the detriment of my ELO score. The fact is that I was raised Catholic also, and…
- I really cannot argue, as your argument is essentially the truth in my mind, and has not disproved my statement, only strengthened it. Thank you for taking this debate.
Against
- Well, dissecting my opponent's response, it seems we agree on far more points than I first predicted. My opponent seems to reject the rather harsh stance of deism, in favor of one which embraces a closer, more involved God.Since this debate is not about the temporal or…
- I'm not sure if my opponent fully read my argument. The conclusion I drew at the end is that God would most likely provide revelation to mankind of His existence. However, deism necessarily rejects this kind of revelation as part of its definition -- otherwise, deism would not…
- 3136.
Evolution and belief in God are compatible
For
- However, I would have to say that my opponent has also failed to make his case, and in fact seems to be arguing a very different topic than the one he himself originally submitted. He has also failed to address the objections I have raised, especially in the last round. For…
- To continue, re my opponent's opening remarks in the 2nd round: "First, I noticed that you failed to respond to the scientific part of what I had said in the opening statements....Assuming that a supernatural being DID exist and DID create life on earth, as you might say, as a…
Against
- I will start with the mentioned problems of a literal reading of the book of Genesis. I noted that in translation, the words in Hebrew were quite literal. The definitions of the words that I noted were very precise, as Hebrew is generally a much more precise language than…
- First, I noticed that you failed to respond to the scientific part of what I had said in the opening statements. Evolution, from the way it is described in the Mcgraw-Hill books "Life" and "Biology, 8th edition," finds its motor in natural selection. Natural selection, as the…
- 3137.
It is impossible for God to exist
For
- Extremely sorry for not replying I'm on holiday and the wifi here isn't great but I'm here. Since we know that we don't have all the knowledge in the universe, suppose if we had 5% of that knowledge in the universe wouldn't if the 95% of the knowledge we don't know contradicts…
- I want to know from any athiest or agnostics about whether it is impossible for God to exist.
Against
- Extend again.
- Well goodness gracious. Extend.
- 3138.
The Bible is not a reliable source of historical information
For
- My opponent forfeits. I am disappointed. . I believe I have made my points, unlike my opponent, and I will allow him to make up for the arguments he forfeited. I doubt, however, he still has a chance to win.
- My opponent forfeits. I still await his rebuttal and his responses to my questions. If he fails to do so, I will be highly disappointed.
Against
- I truly look forward to debating this with you. Since your first round didn't state the setup, in this round I will post my first argument as well as a rebuttal to each if your points. Opening Statements/ Introduction: For the sake of the debate, I will define a few important…
- I accept. I would like to thank WilliamsP for creating this debate. I look forward to debating this topic with you and respect your arguments. I would also like to point out to anyone who is reading this or voting in this that both debaters are 14 years old, so this should be…
- 3139.
Water baptism is necessary for the remission of sins
For
- Ha! You stopped due to being "out of characters"? Dang, I was laughing so hard, I'll give you an encore.
- Well, I suppose it's my job to dispute the negative, although I think a reader could judge for himself without my comments. I agree with con on several points: 1. "As I don't know what Mark 16:16 is. " I'll whole-heartedly agree. 2. "I'll accept the translation, but truthfully…
Against
- Pro is, to put it lightly, a fool. Rather than make any attempt to respond to my interpretation of Biblical events, my opponent has capitalized on my ONE misreading of a SINGLE verse. My opponent has utterly failed to do anything resembling a debate. Quoting the Bible isn't an…
- Wow, you could at least try to be subtle. Or maybe not. Whatever. I guess I'll respond by point, as there isn't much else to do. I agree with pro on every point with "Agreed" next to it, but I'd like to point out that (4.) was followed by the statement that there are also…
- 3140.
God does not answer to humans
For
- God is all perfect and he does everything all perefect; however, God does not do everything. Say right after Da Vinci signed his name to the Mona Lisa someone came and gashed it with a knife. 1. If Da Vinci is a great artist, he creates wonderful artwork. 2. Wonderful artwork…
- You addressed my statement of God is Beyond Our Reproach, but you didn't really address anything else I said. As far as imperfections in the universe, I stated that God allowed for there to be something outside of him to come into existence that we could choose and we did. As a…
Against
- We are debating is god beyond our reproach? P1) If god is beyond reproach, god is all perfectP2) A perfect being, does everything all perfectP3) God created the universeP4) The universe is not perfectC1) God is not perfectC2) God is not beyond reproachIf I can find one…
- Pro has missed the point -.-" The Epicurean Paradox defies logic. With that argument one could say "darkness exists therefore the sun does not exist." Is the sun responsible for darkness? Or is the absence of the sun responsible for darkness?"Do you honestly think this is…
- 3141.
The Devil is a better role model than God
For
- That being said, Con has conceded. Therefore I urge a Pro vote.
- C1. Knowledge and Freedom From Control.The primary reasoning behind my opponent's (eloquently written) counter is that God was not punishing Adam and Eve for gaining knowledge per se. It was because they disobeyed his direct order towards them. He writes: "The true reason for…
Against
- I certainly hope that if he chooses to redo it, then good luck to him. The debate has provoked some interesting research into a few theological concepts that unfortunately are not, in union, efficient to advance the debate. I thank Socialpinko for understanding as well as for…
- After a discussion with my opponent, I have decided to concede the debate to Socialpinko due to a few issues at hand; I won't discuss them but will simply note that the burden I created due to poor research and understanding of the material, as well as a few unrecognized time…
- 3142.
Pentecostalism is the only true way to be saved
For
- As talked about with my opponent, I will be passing this round. Change of structure. :)
- It should have been stated in the beginning of the debate, that in order for Con to win, he must show us that in the Bible, it says you don't have to be filled with the Holy Spirit (speaking in tongues) to get into heaves, thus far, he has not done so. . Rebuttal #1 Exodus…
Against
- The Problem with interpretation My opponent dismisses my example as irrelevant, without fully understanding it's impact. Obviously modern day writing is extremely different then the much older text in the bible. The entire point is about how we as humans see things the way we…
- Just a quick setup fix, all the structure is correct with just the Pro and Con being reversed. My apologies on my mistake, it was copy/pasted from another debate in which I was Pro rather than Con. Framework Framework for this debate will be setting up specific burdens. Con"s…
- 3143.
Wearing the niqab is obligatory for Muslim women
For
- My opponent says that the founders of the four Madhabs didn't find that it was obligatory to cover the face. This is a very big misunderstanding. And very, very wrong.Even If It's Not Obligatory, It's Obligatory "The third degree of Islamic legal Hijab about which jurists…
- The Word 'Jilbab'I find it interesting that you bring up the verses that tell the believing women to cover themselves. But what the problem is, is that you actually misinterpret the verses, you mistranslate them, let me show you why.What did the first Muslims believe the word…
Against
- 1- Pro says even if it is not obligatory it still is obligatory ! Does anyone else see a contradiction here ?! he is able to assume it isn't obligatory in Islam , to prove it is obligatory with some men logic. unfortunately Islam is a revelation and does not accept people's…
- Time for Rebuttals:I will be organizing my rebuttals in points :1- is the woman truly all Awrah including her face ?The "Hadeeth" mentioned by my opponent is not even a hadeeth but some scholar opinion and he acknowledged it honestly in the comment section.By the consensus of…
- 3144.
Christian doctrine undermines its own moral foundations
For
- My opponent's rebuttal is part on-topic, part red herring. His second contention concerning the problem of evil is immaterial - no part of my original argument hinges on the problem of evil itself. My opponent is simply attempting to draw myself, and you, the reader, into an…
- The proposition on offer is that Christian doctrine undermines its own conceptualization of morality through inconsistent beliefs and practices. The root of this debate is based on the conceptualization of God as omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent, and omnibenevolent. This is…
Against
- =========== Introduction: =========== I would like to formerly thank my esteemed opponent, JustCallMeTarzan, for initiating this debate. I am looking forward to our future encounters with due anticipation. My opponent contends that theological fatalism leads to inconsistent…
- My opponent unintentionally forfeited his final round – since his absence is understood and not typical, I request that the readers not consider his forfeiture when voting. We can consider this a two round debate.
- 3145.
The Bible teaches predestination and salvation by faith alone
For
- Thanks to my opponent for challenging me to this debate. I look forward to an edifying exchange, and hope that I can do justice to the doctrines of Grace, and the Gospel of Christ, which is the the only source of our salvation.My job in this debate will be to simply prove that…
- I don't believe my opponent is even trying any more. He hasn't addressed any of the scriptures I presented, he hasn't made any real argument, so by default I should win this debate. However, I'll make a few more points, even though I'm repeating myself. Con says that Grace…
Against
- All arguments extended.
- I admit I will backtrack on the resolution. I believe that predestination is taught in the bible, because the exact word is indeed used. However, I don't believe that my opponent's interpretation of predestination is taught by the Bible. Hopefully my opponent my forgives my…
- 3146.
Religious bigotry mainly has sociological or biological origins
For
- I said prescriptions, not predictions. Rules such as the dietary rules in Leviticus were clearly included to stop people getting ill eating tainted pork and sea food. The anti-gay passages were clearly an attempt to maximize the reproduction potential of adherents, see also "be…
- I contest that the vast majority of prescriptions in any religious text did not stem from a divine source but rather real world problems at the time of it's writing, either a real problem or one perceived by it's human writer. These books were the earliest forms of law, created…
Against
- The Biblical text is divine in origin, but that it did not come from humans because it includes a progressive knowledge of God from Gen. to Rev. How is it that the prophecies in the Bible come true far later than it's time? For example, how is it that Psalm 22:16 "My enemies…
- My opponent claims that "Most religious bigotry and dogma has a real world sociological or biological origin", but has failed to back it up with sociological and biological evidence given by experts, therefore he failed to defend his position.
- 3147.
The Bible is the word of God
For
- true, the bible which was written and percieved by man is full of contradictions. but, the real point of the bible is not for(in my eyes)gods word. the point of the bible is to sum everything up for something as imperfect and unevolved as humans. so, in the end what is the…
- sadly, I have to agree and disagree with you in your case so bear with me as I am new. First of all, noone knows for sure weather or not it is gods word as it was written by humans and interpreted as such. second I don't really have the burden of proof because I am for and…
Against
- Extend all arguments?
- Yet another Biblical Validity debate gone downhill.
- 3148.
Christianity is a form of idol worship
For
- This Xtian responded to a 9000 word response about 10 minutes. HaHaHaHaHa. Notice he failed to address any of the talking points which i brought up. . . That's what he calls a debate? My previous response brought as a precedent an entirely different sugia of the Book of Isaiah.…
- You arrogant Xtians know nothing. YOUR see here, I can quote what's written, Therefore the text means as I believe it to intend - haughty none sense. Dude the Middle Ages have long sensed past into oblivion. You arrogant xtian fools no longer have a sword at the throat of the…
Against
- There is no doubt that the Jewish people desperately want a re-interpretation of Isaiah 53. However, What that re-interpretation consists of is a man-made doctrine, Which no real Apologist will chase after. The DEBATE was about Christianity being labeled as a false idol and the…
- As has been shown in this DEBATE, Isaiah chapter 53 is the death-nell for anyone trying to prove that the Jewish religion is valid and the Christian religion is invalid, According to even the Old Testament. It wasn't enough for my opponent to give secular history behind his…
- 3149.
Catholicism is a contradictory religion
For
- =Opening Statement=Welcome to this debate. As you can see/according to the title of the debate I will debate that the religion of Catholicism is a contradictory religion that has been contradicting itself from the time it was established. Since the establishment of the Catholic…
Against
- ride em cowgirl
- alfk
- 3150.
Belief in God is rationally justified
For
- My opponent has seemed to veer completely off track. Almost all of his last argument was devoted to showing why he thinks God is evil. As much as I would love to debate that, I must adhere to the resolution at hand. Thus far, my opponent has given no solid evidence as to why…
- Sorry ladies and gentlemen, my opponent has misspoken. Well it appears that my opponent does not believe in God after all. God -A being of supernatural powers or attributes, believed in and worshiped by a people, especially a male deity thought to control some part of nature or…
Against
- First I will say the miracles performed by Jesus in the new testament also break the laws of physics but you still choose to believe this man did them even though it is impossible. Ok how was god created if matter can not be created then it means that he couldn't have been…
- I do not believe in God one bit lets make that clear I was theoretically saying where's your "god" when you need him to show that there is no reason to believe in him but seems like you have no reasons of your own. One thing is that Jesus did exist but he WASN'T THE SON OF GOD…
How to use these debate topics
- Vote, discuss, revote. Poll the room on the motion, give 5 minutes of discussion, then vote again and look at who changed their mind.
- Four corners. Label corners strongly agree → strongly disagree; people move, then each corner makes its best case.
- Switch sides. Halfway through, everyone argues the side they disagree with. It sharpens listening.
Run them live
Want every person to answer on their own phone, with a timer and a live leaderboard? Use these questions in an EngageSlide Vote · Discuss · Revote — free to start.
Tick questions on any page — your set is kept while you browse (or take the first 10 here) — and they become ready-to-play slides. What is EngageSlide?