Law Debate Topics — page 31
2,217 debate topics, all ages. Debatable motions with arguments for and against. Open the arguments below, pick one at random, or present them full-screen.
- 1501.
The death penalty is a just form of punishment
For
- Ok, this is really sad. Anyways, my opponent has failed to show why the death penalty is injust. I will simply offer the fact that the fear of death would stop many people from committing crimes. -Thank you.
- Extend my arguments
Against
- I will Let my opponet make the first argument
- 1502.
Groups using BITE mind control techniques should be banned
For
- Sorry to read that Opiumfiend!Though I admit that even I find it a difficult subject to debate against such evidence, so I admire you for having a go.Not the sort of subject I would have chosen to be Con on, so I hope you can grab a debate that it is easier to cut your debating…
- Thank You opiumfiend for accepting this Debate/Discussion on the misuse of BITE mind control techniques in society.In answer to your main points:1: "banning these groups is a violation of freedom of speech."I disagree, in that I don't advocate they would be banned from voicing…
Against
- thank you
- I have to forfeit this debate. the only arguments i can offer relate to the fact that the banning would be to difficult to apply or that the banning would drive the cults under ground. however in the cases of Ken Ham this would be a good thing as it would remove their ability…
- 1503.
Recreational use of mind-altering drugs should be a crime
For
- "The human body is "hooked" on many other substances that aren't drugs, like food and water, except to a much larger degree. To advocate for mind-altering drugs to be illegal on this premise should include an advocation for food and water to be illegal as well. " There is a big…
- "Actions that do not infringe on the individual freedoms of others should not be illegal. When an individual chooses to consume mind-altering drugs, they are knowingly governing their own behaviour. " That may be true, but these are drugs. Once your hooked, you are probably…
Against
- ==Addiction== My opponent contends that food and water do not cause people to commit crimes. This is not the case. Man's addiction to food and water can cause him to commit theft and murder. Following my opponent's logic, the solution is to make food and water illegal. Unlike…
- ===Answering my opponent's first objection=== "Once your [sic] hooked, you are probably going to be hooked for a while. " The human body is "hooked" on many other substances that aren't drugs, like food and water, except to a much larger degree. To advocate for mind-altering…
- 1504.
Vigilantism is justified when government fails to enforce the law
For
- Affirmation V: Societal welfare VC: Will to Power of societal order Thesis: The will to power is an individual's struggle against their surroundings that culminates in personal growth, and the ability to assert power. Vigilantism is justified through this struggle against the…
Against
- Extend
- Err... Ok maybe we can finish in round 3?
- 1505.
The United States should submit to international court jurisdiction
For
- My opponent has no imperical evedence proving the burden i've placed on him, and he gave the example of Tom Bradley trying to prove that ALL polls are inaccurate. It is a logical fallacy to say that one poll was inaccurate, therefore ALL polls are inaccurate. Until he proves MY…
- Short and sweet: I have proven my burden of doing what is within the American citizen's best interest(refer to sub point C under my 1st contention), and the negative has not proved the burden placed on them by me(refer to directly under my criterion).
Against
- While I may not have Evidence to Prove my opponents Poll inaccurate I HAVE provided evidence that polls are not accurate. We do not decide elections based on polls.... Also As I challenged the Accuracy of the Poll it has become the Burden of the AFF to prove it accurate. I have…
- My opponent Drops Both Values, Criterion and Cases instead he focus' on one subpoint of his contention one, saying this proves his entire Case.... So lets look at this point then shall we... Here were my attacks I placed on it last round, that remain un-refuted... 1. AFF…
- 1506.
Guns should be available to the law-abiding public
For
- Since con has forfeited I shall continue. Guns should be available to the law abiding public to give them a chance against a criminal/criminals who wish to do them harm. The average 911 response time is slowing, with no signs of speedy up(1.) So with that knowledge, how can you…
- i would like to point out to the audience that 1st round was supposed to be acceptance. I would also like to point out that the one thing that the Columbine and Aurora shooters had in common was lack of mental health. The Columbine shooters were mentally ill and so was the…
Against
- If people have gunes than more mass killing sprees can happen. Do you really want another Columbines??????? What about the batman shooting? Nobody should have the right to have a gun, because you never know if the person sitting next to you is a serial killer. Looks can be…
- 1507.
The United States should decriminalize drugs
For
- I. Intro I'll mostly be going over the major points of contention and showing you why Pro has won this debate. II. Harm Principle No matter whether you buy my argument here or my opponent's, I win this argument, and therefore, the debate. If you believe me and think that people…
- I. Intro What we have is a system that is not working. It's clear from my case, as well as various other issues. It's time to try something new, and that pathway leads to decriminalization. In order to prove that drugs should remain illegal, Con has three pillars to uphold. The…
Against
- Final Rebuttals/Closing ArgumentThroughout round four, Pro more or less simply states that he should win without really going into any great detail as to why he should win. I've demonstrated in my argument that illicit drugs are extremely dangerous to ones health, and have…
- RebuttalsHarm PrincipleHere, Pro contends that people essentially have the right to take illegal drugs--all the while still acknowledging their harms. However if there was nothing inherently wrong with harming oneself, things like traditional self-harm (mutilation of the body)…
- 1508.
Acts of racism should be illegal
For
- We're all people until race divided us, wealth classified us, and stereotypes difined us. You're clearly forfieting the arguement becasue you nothing to say when your primitive ideologies are tested. I assume your Christian or something... so do you think Jesus would agree with…
- You must a total troll, you didn't even read my previous argument since I explained why that 1/3 black people nonsense was flawed (go read it). You also just copy pasted your previous rant to mine. You say your not a racist, but you say their dark skin absorbs too much sunlight…
Against
- God would be okay if black people go to prison or go to hell. Ham disgraced his father, and as the father of all Africans, black people are naturally cursed. As a 100% Russian straight and able-bodied male, I don't care what happens to black people, gay people, retarded people,…
- Let me say that there is noting wrong with racism. Nuff said. Yadda yadda yadda, I'm outta here.
- 1509.
Abortion should be legal in all US states
For
- Yes, I am aware I wasn't given much information on justifying my opinion, because I waiting for what YOU had to say, but now that you said what you said, here's the fun part. Are you ready?? As you stated that there is no such thing as being a "legal human" yes, I am going to…
- I feel that a woman can do whatever she wants with her body. Christians and Catholics need to stop throwing their religion in everyone's faces. If Christianity is a such a loving religion, then how come whenever a woman gets an abortion she is treated like crap? No, abortion is…
Against
- While reading Pro's opening, it's easy to get distracted by the many irrelevant claims that Pro makes. The question for this debate is whether abortion needs to be legalized in all states (nevermind whether it already is legal in all states). It's irrelevant whether…
- Pro disputes that the zygote is alive on the basis that it doesn't have arms and legs. That's plainly absurd. The man in this video is obviously very much alive even though he doesn't have any arms and legs. I explained in the last round that a zygote is alive because it has…
- 1510.
Marijuana should be legalized for all ages
For
- Well what if the parents buy weed for themselves, but don't let the kids have it? Then the exact same thing can happen with the weed instead of the alcohol. Oh. Oh snap. You see? I'm untouchable. And you just kept repeating the same thing over again. And so I win. Accept it.…
- Wasn't it totally available in like, the 20's? And alcohol is much more available, I mean, what if a kid was home alone after school? Open the fridge, pop out some wine, and drink that sh*t up. The weed would be less available, because they have to pay for it. And their parents…
Against
- My Opponent: "Well what if the parents buy weed for themselves, but don't let the kids have it? Then the exact same thing can happen with the weed instead of the alcohol. Oh. Oh snap." What's the problem then? I mean, parents don't have a say in what their children consume? My…
- My opponent claims that alcohol is much more available to drugs in today's soceity. This is true, but it is still illegal for anyone under the age of 21 to consumer an alcoholic beverage. To the scenario about the kid home by himself after school, this is strictly the…
- 1511.
Marijuana should be made illegal
For
- I know that my sources have failed and my arguments have been poor. But let me tell you about the time I ran into a man who was so high he thought he was an orange. It was last year, around October 15, it was a relatively warm day and I was on leave from Iraq. I saw a police…
- Just because It makes you happy, doesn't mean you loose your natural rights. Marijuana is a drug, not just a plant. It should be illegal. look at these pictures and tell me that you want to smell and look like these people. 1. botswana-alcoholaids.tripod.com 2. www.bubblews.com…
Against
- 1. I will assume this story shows Marijuana is bad because 1.He can't break his habit 2. Citizens shouldn't ebed to use it because it can make you temporarily dumber. I will assume this because: "I felt bad for him and so I told him it was his choice to get high and that I hope…
- 1. Your sources have failed to prove anything. 2. You failed to refute nearly any of my argument. 3. The education system teaches that Marijuana is bad, and if you know about the dangers you should be able to use it. Fast food is bad, does that mean it should be made illegal.…
- 1512.
Same-sex marriage should be legally recognized
For
- My position is that marriage between partners of the same gender has no significant negative effects on society and therefor should be legal. My opponent has the burden of proof to show that there are negative effects (or can reasonably argue that there will be) and should go…
- Dann continues to argue his opinions about whether the comparison between gay rights and civil rights is a correct one (while still giving no argument as to why he believes this; just that it is "apples and oranges". He gives his opinions about whether the discrimination of…
Against
- I accept this debate and will be arguing that gay marriage should not be legally allowed. Marriage. Traditionally, marriage has been a formal act of union between a man and a woman. An act recognised as the formation of the nucleus of another of the cells that make up society;…
- "Dann continues to argue his opinions about whether the comparison between gay rights and civil rights is a correct one (while still giving no argument as to why he believes this; just that it is "apples and oranges"." I have given an argument as to why I believe there is no…
- 1513.
Some crimes should be punishable by death with a higher standard of proof
For
- To begin, I wish to rebut some of the arguments the Con side has made. First of all, the Con side has pointed out that the rate of prison escapes has decreased drastically. Though I cannot argue with the statistics that Con side has given me, I believe the actual occurrence of…
- The first main point I have identified in this debate are the societal benefits of punishing some crimes by death. There are 3 main societal benefits I have identified. The first is peace of mind. How would you feel if you knew there was an army of terrible criminals just…
Against
- I will start by apologizing to the pro side and to our precious readers for failing to provide a source for the cost argument. Here it is: https://deathpenaltyinfo.org...I was too hasty, and I am extremely desolated. I will pay more attention from now on.I won't be rebutting…
- I shall be rebutting them one by one, and of course, I'll be putting my sources at the end of the post. Ladies and gentlemen, let us proceed:Pro argues by saying that the death penalty offers social benifits; the first one being peace of mind. I agree that the possibility of a…
- 1514.
The United States should abolish solitary confinement in prisons
For
- 1. Interaction with guards is not the interaction needed when going through the rehabilitation process. 2 That is subjective and has been shown to cause issues in the future. 3. It is unethical and immoral because it is against human rights. 4. Being disciplined is good when…
- 1. Solitary confinement is the isolation of a prisoner in a separate cell as a punishment in jail and prison. 2. Solitary confinement cause prisoners severe mental harm and places them at risk of even more devastating psychological harm in the future. 3. Craig Haney, a…
Against
- 1. I agree with the definition of solitary confinement; however, I would also like to add that they are allowed to see/interact with prison guards.2. If a person is placed into solitary confinement, then they will be properly disciplined. 3. Solitary confinement is not entirely…
- 1. Solitary confinement can be perceived as a form of discipline, whereas most consider it punishment. 2. Prison is strictly for having the convicted make amends for their mistakes. 3. Solitary confinement is not entirely immoral nor is it unethical because of its intention of…
- 1515.
Marijuana should be decriminalized
For
- First, I apologize for my relatively inadequate argument in the last round. As I already explained, I had an extremely limited amount of time.Cancer ClaimI will address cervical cancer and prostate cancer separately. It has been proven in studies that medical marijuana (which…
- Rebuttal: It is proven that marijuana is not severely detrimental to healthMy opponent presents a source from WebMD. I would like to present a source from the exact same site, but the article states that there is in fact no connection between marijuana use and cancer. [1]…
Against
- Cancer argument: For starters, there's a reason as to why my opponent's evidence says the exact opposite as to what my evidence is saying: the studies are looking at two different kinds of cancer. While my evidence is looking toward the incidence of prostate and cervical cancer…
- I will move on to the iteration of my main points. Contention 1: Marijuana is indeed detrimental to health. As this following point will prove through the provision of evidence, marijuana is indeed detrimental to the health of the human being.1a. Marijuana leads to an increased…
- 1516.
Same-sex marriage should be legally recognized
For
- at first, i had thought that gay marriage was all wrong, however i see it differently now. what if you wish to spend the rest of your life with a person you truely love but however is the same gender? you can't help the fact that you're either a male or female. it's all about…
Against
- The proponent unfortunately did not defend her position, which makes it more difficult for me, and any observers to challenge and refine my/their opinions. I have nothing more to add.
- You shouldn't start a debate you are not prepared to participate in. Modern marriage has lost virtually all of it's traditional significance(look at the divorce rates). The most significant commitments in a relationship are implicit, and do not require the acknowledgment of…
- 1517.
Separation of church and state is legitimate
For
- "What would a state established religion do to prohibit the rights of the people? The only point in my argument was that states are, and should be, able to establish their own religion. I don't think that if State A wants to make it's religion, say, Christianity, that it would…
- I must admit, this is an interesting point you've brought up. For a long time, the bill of rights only applied to the federal government rather than state and local governments. This double standard of protecting individual's rights on the federal level while somewhat…
Against
- Your Fourteenth Amendment argument is indeed a good one, and I grimaced a few times. I have my own opinions on the Fourteenth Amendment, and I plan on debating it in the future. Yes, it is true the states may not make laws that would infringe on the rights of it's people. What…
- Yes, it is true that if one religion should be respected, then all religions should, as well. That's why we should teach all dominating religions in school, not just Christianity, Satanism, and all else. You are correct in saying that the First Amendment guarantees a government…
- 1518.
Same-sex marriage should be illegal in the United States
For
- Extend all arguments.
- Well that's unfortunate. I await my opponent's response in R3.
Against
- Seeing as the Pro normally go first, as far as parameter for LD debate goes, I'll let the challenger go first. I ask that whomever accepts the challenge is prepared for this, and hopefully is fit to make Pro arguments. Thank you.
- 1519.
Laws should be based on the Bible
For
- Yes. I have lost.
- You win. I kind of just chose this topic because it was the only available one to challenge.
Against
- You wrote, "I assumed you meant all of the Bible". Most Christians believe Christ saved us from judgement of the OT law. There are numerous verses that support this view, for instance, Paul wrote in Romans, "For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has made me free…
- I will say, I expected a debater with views that were a little further from my own, but for the debates sake, I'll continue. I do agree with you to the extent that, biblical principles do improve peoples lives. I also accept the quote from St, Augustine. A nation that holds…
- 1520.
Abortion should not be illegal
For
- Judges, I sincerely apologize to you and my opponent for not posting an argument when it was needed. With this being said, I will still provide my own side of the arguments and refute my opponent's case. We must understand that for one thing, my opponent has the entirety of the…
- The next few rounds will be for the actual argumentation of the topic.
Against
- It is unfortunate that my opponent did not respond in two rounds of this debate, as I was genuinely hoping to have my views challenged. However, after his limited arguments, I am only more affirmed in my beliefs. Since I have made my arguments in detail above, let me summarize…
- ScarletGhost, I am glad you were able to make it. I am very interested in this debate, and am glad we get to sharpen our ideas together. I am sorry for mistaking the resolution, but the title was relatively vague. Since abortion is technically not fully legal anywhere (abortion…
- 1521.
All drugs should be legalized and addiction treated as a health issue
For
- A drug addict is not nessecarily a criminal. As we send the drug addicts to prison and radicalize them into criminals, we create a society where we look at people with addictions as the scum of the society. In Portugal drugs for personal use have been legal since 2001. What…
- The greatest problem for drug users are that they never know what they get. The reason for this is that as the drugs goes from drug cartel to user, it passes through a system of middlemen. These middlemen are eager to make money, and therefore they mix their drug with e.g.…
Against
- Since their widespread popularity in the mid-1900s, recreational drugs have shown the world their worth. They have created a generation of people disconnected from reality, disrespectful of society, and counterproductive to our nation. Recreational drugs should not be legalized…
- Before I start my closing argument, I would like to point out a credibility issue with my opponents argument. Three out of four of his sources come from Wikipedia, an easy source for flawed and biased information. In future debates, it would do my opponent well to find credible…
- 1522.
Illegal drugs should be legalized
For
- Illegal drugs should be legalized what do you think?
Against
- Woohoo =)
- Negation CaseP1: Ricin is an illegal drugThe drug I will showcase here is Ricin. Ricin is illegal, as indicated by this article where a student was arrested for making the substance [2] Officially, Ricin is: "...considered both a chemical and biological weapon and is explicitly…
- 1523.
Life without parole is preferable to the death penalty
For
- There are bad people out there who deserve to die do not get me wrong. However, there is no doubt the death penalty withholds too many risks and has too many cons to be considered preferable. These criminals most likely want to die as well, so part of their punishment should be…
- When you state "A life for a life" then that opinion is only held by some families of the victims. However, many families are already suffering and the long process that comes with the death penalty would extend their suffering. Locking up the prisoner will allow closure for…
Against
- That is a lot of money to be killing 13 people but so many more are facing death because of their hideous crimes. Lavere bryant, a habitual offender for sexual assault, murdered two 20 year old family dollar tree employees and was sentenced to life in prison without parole. the…
- Even though the death penalty is more expensive it is an extremely powerful deterrent. When put on death row prisoners and lawyers do everything they can to stay out of death penalty because they want to go to prison even though they don't know what it is like. Most people…
- 1524.
The federal government should legalize soft drugs such as marijuana and psilocybin
For
- >>> the war on drugs used money that could have been spent in other places... but we ar3e not debating weather or not the government spends it's money well. +++ The topic is about the fact that the United States should legalise soft drugs. The utilization of money is included…
- >>> Your argument for legalizing the "softer drugs" is that the drug is "less damaging to the health than a hard drug. " +++ This is an untrue assumption. I support the legalisation of hard drugs, but that is not what this debate is about. It's about soft drugs. >>> However…
Against
- Okay well yes the war on drugs used money that could have been spent in other places... but we ar3e not debating weather or not the government spends it's money well. Also there are several websites that state that weed is a gateway drug so if i wanted to do what you are doing…
- Your argument for legalizing the "softer drugs" is that the drug is "less damaging to the health than a hard drug." However although it is less damaging it is still damaging. It is kinda like tobacco. No it is not as damaging as say Meth but it still causes thousands of deaths…
- 1525.
Cold cases should be reopened when new evidence emerges
For
- It's the most tragic cold case I heard of
Against
- Another one? Damm.
- BOP is on my opponent because he is suggesting we take a certain course of action that deviates from the status quo (i. e. we should start investigating a crime from not investigating a crime). So for the most part I'll wait to hear his case for why it should be re-opened, but…
- 1526.
Convicted felons should be barred from owning guns
For
- Con wins this debate i surrender
- you win
Against
- Extend all arguments.
- Extend all arguments.
- 1527.
The death penalty should be abolished because it is ineffective
For
- To Opponent:Thank you once again for your submission. Since we are running out of rounds, let's continue with the rebuttals for these two rounds. I could clearly tell that you have not paid any attention to what I have said. First off, let's review zealotry once again. I have…
- -Thank you for such a well written argument. I could already tell that you are a deep thinker and a man that supports humanitarian ideas just like I do. I clearly instructed that a minimum of 1,000 words is required, but you have broken this rule, I will pay no attention to…
Against
- Pro, I have no idea what you want to debate anymore. I will just forfeit the rest of the debate. Thanks for taking the time.
- Sorry about the 1000 word rule. I wasn't paying attention. I brought up Texas because both Bush and Perry in my view are political zealots, and Bush is a religions one as well. Both have had numerous death penalties come to their desk for review. An investigation reported in…
- 1528.
Citizens should retain the right to bear arms
For
- FINAL ROUND!!The obesity: what I'm trying to say that is in reality Snorlax is this amazing guy who can take huge hits as well as dish out humongous lazers that will destroy any bad guys in their sight.Flowers: bad guys get destroyed by flowers, don't you know? "AHHHHHH…
- REBUTTALS1. Bear's unresponsibilitySnorlax is amazing. He has the right to sleep. His amazing powers...just wow. Watch the youtube video. Just watch the Youtube video.http://www.youtube.com...(Skip to 4:10 for the important part) As for wrong hands, you obviously didn't read my…
Against
- Snorlax is a badassThis point is completely true. However if it weren't for his bear arms making him a fatso, he could be a bigger badass.Flowers destroy bad guysAccording to my opponent, flowers burn bad guys. This wouldn't matter however. Bad guys are immune to heat.…
- First off, Pro didn't even refute the obesity argument, so that still stands. The only point that the video really made is that snorlax can shoot lazers. That's irrelevant to his bear arms and his obesity they provide him. Wrong Hands Argument My opponent tries to say that…
- 1529.
The death penalty should be abolished
For
- So Im going to put them back into Contentions because I think it is easier to read a flow the arguments Contention I I would like to say that I never advocated the "eye for an eye" policy but simply for a just punishment for such a hanus crime. My opponent over exaggerates the…
- Based on my opponent definition I would like to say this on the word "Criminal" This is a person that has violently and often committed a premeditated murder. This is to say that they took the life of another human being, this is a reprehensible action that deserves to be…
Against
- "I would like to say that I never advocated the "eye for an eye" policy but simply for a just punishment for such a hanus crime. My opponent over exaggerates the situation, there are better solutions. Like in Louisiana recently the governor passed chemical castration as a…
- "It isn't really a hypocritical theory, it is law. Law is the guidelines for which societies are ruled and it is through these laws that a minimal peace is created. The death penalty is a form of punishment for those who choose to break the law, causing chaos and in this case…
- 1530.
The United States should legalize recreational marijuana use
For
- Thanks for the debate.
- Racism & Poverty: Nothing for me to rebut here, any concerns Con raises here would be solved through legalization as well. Why Legalization Won't Work:Crime: Con begins by focussing on stats coming out of California. However, there is a large problem doing this. Marijuana for…
Against
- Pass.
- My opinion has chaned.
- 1531.
Recreational drugs should be legalized
For
- Unfortunately, his forfeiture of the second round really hurt the flow of the debate. Since round 3 was intentionally meant for rebuttals, I will be breaking down and refuting my opponent's arguments. 'What makes these drugs different from their natural bases is the ways in…
- It seems to be that my opponent has forfeited his round. I will not post any arguments. I'll give him another chance to post his arguments.
Against
- Why are drugs bad? After all, anybody can walk into a grocery store or local pharmacy and take their pick of over the counter pain killers, sleep aids, anti-histamines and illness relievers. Why are those drugs perfectly safe but other drugs aren't? What makes cocaine different…
- Examples include marijuana, cocaine, heroine, etc. I look forward to debating this with you.
- 1532.
All law-abiding adult citizens should have the right to own guns
For
- I will be arguing that all law-abiding citizens should be able to obtain a gun license. Con will be arguing that citizens should not have access to guns unless their job requires it. Burden of proof is shared.
- It is now time for conclusions. Remember not to read mine until after you post yours. Suicides Con says that guns are the most common suicide method. However, if they were eliminated, people would poison themselves, jump off buildings, cut themselves with knives, or suffocate…
Against
- Since the instigator has made this debate five rounds, I would like to institute an organized round structure. Round 1: Acceptance/Greetings/Rules/WhatevsRound 2: Opening Arguments (Neither opponent can respond to what is said in Round 2)Round 3: Rebuttals of Opening…
- Since this is my last response, I have not read my opponent's conclusion yet, and I will conclude what has already been said in the debate. And therefore, as agreed upon, not bring up any new arguments or evidence. In this entire debate, my opponent has only brought up one…
- 1533.
Western democracies should recognize religious-based courts
For
- the reality, there's still big amount of people who believe in their own religion. They breath, eat, drink and doing everything with religious guidelines, so religion is important for them, and of course because it is important, they want to follow the guidelines as good as…
- Right to believe. Right of the people to be treated the way as system they believe. There's a people who believe a different policy, which is religion policy. why they believe in this kind of policy? because the state policy is universal and some of the state policy different…
Against
- If religion is important enough for them to live by, and people think that using that as a form of punishment or as a form of justice, then they should go find a group of people that agree with them and live by that lifestyle somewhere else. America, or any western civilization…
- Extend the arguments
- 1534.
Torture should be legal
For
- I will be arguing that it should be legal for our military to use torture on terrorist suspects if they see it is necessary. First round is acceptance. My opponent must show why tortue by our military shouldn't be condoned. By torture, I'm mainly talking about waterboarding,…
- 1.Legality"My opponent says that terrorists are not part of a country, we should not abide by the Geneva Conventions. He is basically saying "it is okay" that we torture random citizens who are of a threat to our nation."_Contra, Round 3, R1. LegalityNo, I stated that because…
Against
- Thanks for the debate. R1: Legality Since most terrorists are not part of a country, that Geneva Conventions wouldn't apply to them. However the Constitution's 8th amendment states: "No person…shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself," and the…
- ==========Rebuttals==========R1: LegalityMy opponent says that terrorists are not part of a country, we should not abide by the Geneva Conventions. He is basically saying "it is okay" that we torture random citizens who are of a threat to our nation.And he doesn't refute my…
- 1535.
Capital punishment in the United States is flawed and should end
For
- I will present the following arguments to start with in favor of my position. Capital punishment is replying to one death sentence with another. Murder indeed constitutes the death penalty. It deprives an individual of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. It should…
- As I've stated twice now, Universality in this case goes as follows: by their action the murderer has said all should do the same, regardless of personal motivations. This does not apply to what is actually their reason (if there is one) to kill, but once again refers to "act…
Against
- Good Debate I'd like to say. _Refuting my opponents case same way as before_ 1. Again I don't really understand my opponents point here. By Kant's statement we are saying that it should be a law that is enacted. It's not universal law if a government wants to punish by using a…
- _I will refute my opponent's case paragraph by paragraph_ 1. Murderers have not accepted that all people should act this way; in fact many times murderers have their own hidden motives to commit a felony unless they have a mental handicap which alters their view on the world…
- 1536.
Governments should maintain DNA databases for criminal profiling
For
- Cost effectiveness DNA databases are more cost effective compared to other police counterparts. Without the use of DNA databases, it becomes more difficult to find individual subjects. This normally means increasing the task force by hiring more police officers which can result…
- DNA databases exonerates wrongfully convicted defendants. Along with this, DNA allows for the release for those wrongfully incriminated. Throughout history, there have been multiple cases of evidence seeming to prove an individual wrong when in actuality, they are innocent.…
Against
- Logistics are the final reason why DNA databases are a bad idea for the entire world. Even under current laws collecting DNA from criminals, there are differences on who is responsible for taking and handling the DNA. This would cause a huge problem for the entire population.…
- Another reason DNA databases are a bad idea is due to the fact that it directly goes against everyone's 4th amendment. Taking a sample from someones body to have DNA is considered a search/seize of that person. Getting that sample without a valid warrant is a direct violation…
- 1537.
Marijuana use, sale, and manufacture should be legalized in more US states
For
- Forward all points.
- Forward all points.
Against
- I accept and agree to your challenge
- You stated the responsible American adult thus I told you about the modern culture of American society on what you call responsibility which is a matter of opinion on how you look at the average adult on responsibility. I presented 3 scenario's based on human nature and you…
- 1538.
Polygamy should be legal in the United States
For
- It's obvious what I'm for so. Polygamy- Having more than one spouse at a time. Is there a viable reason against it?
- 1) Yes, I do. The resolution is "Polygamy should be allowed in the United States." In my opening words I said, "Is there a viable reason against it?" Clearly, this means that it has been deemed wrong and I want an answer as for why. What else can it mean? Just simply stating…
Against
- Polygamy should not be allowed in the US. To start off, I will use my opponent's definition of polygamy, which is having more than one spouse at a time. First and foremost, we must look at polygamy as a social policy, simply because marriage is a social issue. A marriage…
- 1) In this point, I am merely addressing an issue and setting the standards for the round accordingly. My opponent never set any round standards, as the Affirmative is supposed to do. I simply pointed out the issue of polygamy and defined how we should debate it. I list the…
- 1539.
Bestiality should be illegal
For
- Wow... Conceded!
- I feel very sorry (and stupid) for screwing this up.____________________________________________All sexual-relations/mariage should be legal between consenting adults. However, animals cannot consent, are not easily definable "adults", and any pregnancy would be…
Against
- --
- "I feel very sorry (and stupid) for screwing this up." It's all good, I have a feeling this site's structure serves only to validate a sense of propriety that is in fact totally hollow in any case. "All sexual-relations/mariage should be legal between consenting adults.…
- 1540.
Everyone of sound mind being armed would make society safer
For
- After 1996, less than 10% of nonfatal violent crimes involved firearms. http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov....... So criminals with guns are hardly an issue, as most just don't have guns, which in your society, they will. This is to say that ninety percent of the non fatal violent crimes…
- A. Guns save more lives than they take; prevent more injuries than they inflict * Guns used 2.5 million times a year in self-defense. Law-abiding citizens use guns to defend themselves against criminals as many as 2.5 million times every year -- or about 6,850 times a day.1…
Against
- It appears my opponent believes that everyone is born one of three ways; Good, Bad or crazy. He doesn't understand that the good can become the bad and that 95% of the bad isn't crazy at all. "I argue that the 10 percent or less would be less likely to commit the crime in the…
- My opponent appears to have forgotten his own resolution. "We would all be safer if everyone of sound mind was armed". What this means is that he believes, that a society in which every adult( I'm assuming adult. He didn't specify but semantics aren't really my thing) is…
- 1541.
Same-sex marriage should be legal nationwide
For
- #1: The Constitution "The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States." - Article 4 Section 2 (1) The Government has a duty to its people. To protect them against unjust laws and maintain equality amongst them.…
- I am FOR legallizing Gay Marriage nationally. The rules to this debate are simple. 1) no foul language, 2) when using statistics provide your source(s), & 3) no disrespecting any religions and/or belief systems. I will begin with my first argument. #1: The Constitution -…
Against
- 1: The ConstitutionPro has misread what Article 4, Section 2 means. It means that all citizen's shall have the privileges of being a citizen. One citizen may not be refused the legal rights (like right to a lawyer) that another has. If The Pro hadn't cherry-picked Article 4,…
- Before I started, I wanted to say...3) no disrespecting any religions and/or belief systems. I will begin with my first argument.This trait is highly appreciated. Now to start.================================================1) The Constitution:1a) Freedom to Marry:Doing a quick…
- 1542.
All drugs should be legalized for recreational use
For
- Drug Consumption Will IncreaseActually it seems drug consumption drops off with legalisation. Here is a graph of drug consumption in porchagal before and after legalisation (all drugs were effectively legalised in 2001).download (1).jpgDrug's Will be Easier to Access Actually…
- We don't Have a Right to Control Other PeopleTo a person who says that that drugs should not be legalised my first response is always: What gives you the right to control what a person chooses to put into their body in the privacy of their own home? Allows Federal Control of…
Against
- Again, It appears that Pro has forfeited. To sum up: Decriminalization in Portugal has not helped their doomed economy. It has contributed significantly to the rise in addiction, and therefore the costs involved to treat them. Crime is rising in Portugal. The crack epidemic…
- My opponent has quit the last round, so I'll carry my points on.
- 1543.
Firearms should be heavily regulated by the government
For
- I believe firearms should be always under regulation by the government. I welcome you to debate me on this, and maybe even change my mind.Rounds:1. Acceptance. Don't present arguments in the first round.2. Arguments. Con can't rebuttal Pro.3. Rebuttal and more arguments.4.…
- I believe firearms should be always under regulation by the government. I welcome you to debate me on this, and maybe even change my mind. Rounds: 1. Acceptance. Don't present arguments in the first round. 2. Arguments. Con can't rebuttal Pro. 3. Rebuttal and more arguments.…
Against
- I accept the challenge. Good luck.
- I accept. Good luck.
- 1544.
Attempted murder should carry the same sentence as murder
For
- I'd like to start by saying that I am not suggesting that we throw every attempted murderer in prison for life (uk) or in the us kill them because I am saying they should get the same punishment as they get in murder and they should like in murder trials be given a fair trial.…
- Attempted murder when a person try's to murder someone but fails is it really different from the real thing? Murder is so much different for the victim and his family but for the murderer it only mean s a shorter prison sentence and this means they are just out on the street…
Against
- I would like start by rebuting Charlie's point bcause people that have these problems and get carried away and try to commit murder can be send to mental asylums where they can be treated and the will be taken care off. We wouldnt benefit from that person going to jail. We…
- Hello and thank you for letting me debate with you. It is my first debate. I would like to start off by saying that the prison sentence for attempted murder should not be the same as murder due o few simple reasons. Firstly, the murderer in question could have been carried away…
- 1545.
Abortion should be legal nationwide for women 16 and older without parental consent
For
- I agree with you on that. I think that would be a good option.
- I do not agreed that it should be raised to 21. That is an extremely high age to have parental control over a young woman's body. Parents do not always know best. There are still many parents who are bigoted and would force a woman to have a child she didn't want. Some parents…
Against
- most of the cases I've known where children are pregnant abortion is the better option. But I think the involvement of responsible adults in helping them reach a decision to have one is important.. I didn't specify who these adults should be but limiting it to those whose…
- Before having an abortion a woman under the age of 21 would be required to present a form signed by a parent or responsible adult certifying the abortion is in the woman's best interest and she has made a well reasoned decision to choose an abortion. There could be someone at…
- 1546.
Same-sex couples should be allowed to marry
For
- Con has conceded his round.
- I thank con for his opening round, however he has failed in his attempt to show why there should be no Gay Marriage.Con puts forward a few assumptions that I would like to deal with individually.Con asserts that marriage has always been between a man and a woman, and that…
Against
- It Is Not Marriage. Marriage has always been between a man and a woman and we should not change that. It Always Denies a Child Either a Father or a Mother. A child will always be missing either a father or mother after gay marriage. This makes a child have different intrests…
- 1547.
Supporters of strict drug policy share blame for drunk driving deaths
For
- You do not have the burden of proof, granted. But if you let my points slip by uncontested, then you are making a big mistake! As I see it, you have let quite a few of my points slip through without a whimper, and you are losing ground with every one of them. Whether or not you…
- Thank you for accepting my challenge, paradigm lost. Points unanswered in round 1: Contention 1) Con did not provide ample evidence that drug war is working Contention 2) Con did not contest that kids are "eased" into a life of crime by harsh alcohol/drug laws Contention 3) Con…
Against
- You know, this website is horribly prone to bias. People seem to vote on pre-conditioned responses rather than judging them on the merits of their stengths. I suppose this is to be expected to some degree when the average age on here is all of 16 years. Because this is the…
- "CONTENTION 1) CON DID NOT PROVIDE AMPLE EVIDENCE THAT DRUG WAR IS WORKING." Since you were the one making the assertion the burden of proof lies with you, not with me. As well, I never said I was in favor of a, as you call it, "a staunch drug war." My contention is with your…
- 1548.
Teens who sext should not face criminal charges
For
- My opponent's arguments are not new, and they have not contested my arguments. I urge you to vote in my side's favor.
- Sexting among teens has one stated problem by my opponent: potential loss of job opportunity in the future. I contend only if the recipient of such text violates social norms of privacy does that sext become visible to an employer. Meanwhile sexting is a form of expression…
Against
- I didn't mean to forfeit but ill continue my arguments
- sexting is causing big problems around the world why send photos of your own body to people who in the long run don't care about you...teenagers are not thinking before doing this. these pictures could cost you a job in the long run. good luck to my challenger
- 1549.
Private businesses should be allowed to discriminate against whomever they choose
For
- Intro: Most self-appointed spokesmen for "oppressed" groups love to blame the free market for the "inequities" of modern society. Were it not for benevolent government intervention, these people claim, lacks would still use separate water fountains and women would serve only as…
- By "discrimination" i refer to Wikipedia's definition; "the prejudicial treatment of an individual based solely on their membership in a certain group or category". Begin! :D
Against
- As You can clearly See, there is no reason for me to even restate my opponents arguments.
- Pro Dropped all arguements.
- 1550.
Abortion opponents should face civil lawsuits
For
- Thank you, buckIPDA, for participating in this Debate.Regarding the definitions that Con chose:1. The link supplied for "baby" includes all of these nouns:a. baby, babe, infant (a very young child (birth to 1 year) who has not yet begun to walk or talk) "the baby began to cry…
- This Debate will focus on the claim, made by abortion opponents, that an unborn human can be called a "baby" or a "child". I will endeavor to show that that claim is propaganda at best, and an outright lie at worst, and causes severe emotional suffering whenever a natural…
Against
- = Framework = > Definitions My opponent provides a loose definition for "propaganda" and as of this point in the debate, the term is (while not the most ideal) acceptable. I do however reserve the right to protest this definition if at any later point it becomes abusive. I will…
How to use these debate topics
- Vote, discuss, revote. Poll the room on the motion, give 5 minutes of discussion, then vote again and look at who changed their mind.
- Four corners. Label corners strongly agree → strongly disagree; people move, then each corner makes its best case.
- Switch sides. Halfway through, everyone argues the side they disagree with. It sharpens listening.
Run them live
Want every person to answer on their own phone, with a timer and a live leaderboard? Use these questions in an EngageSlide Vote · Discuss · Revote — free to start.
Tick questions on any page — your set is kept while you browse (or take the first 10 here) — and they become ready-to-play slides. What is EngageSlide?