Discussly

Law Debate Topics — page 14

2,217 debate topics, all ages. Debatable motions with arguments for and against. Open the arguments below, pick one at random, or present them full-screen.

All agesDebatePage 14 of 45
  1. 651.

    Police profiling is justified

    For

    • yay.....i win..................................................................................................................................................................................... how does this appear to not be gramatically correct?
    • alrighty then you force me to go blah because of the required characters to type,thanks alot,omg how many more are there to go?sjgfijazigljilfghalhfgjiuhiazfhigdppppppppppbggggggggggsa

    Against

    • Police profiling in other words...using stereotypes. I think the worst thing for our country is racist, as a country i believe that we need to unite. It's wrong to think that a African American probably stole something because he has a different skin tone from you and me.
  2. 652.

    Civilians should be allowed to own assault weapons

    For

    • What if we don't have access to a gun, then what are going to do?
    • We need assault weapons to keep us alive longer.

    Against

    • Living in the UK I'm thankful everyday that we have to have a license to use a gun or anything of the sort meaning you have to be fully qualified to use a gun. People say they need to protect themselves against criminals braking into their houses but usually they will have a…
  3. 653.

    Gun bans reduce crime rates

    For

    • Sorry buddy I didn't read it carefully . You win. Still even with England's gun ban they are the most dangerous country in Europe in terms of crime.
    • A good example is the UK. After they banned hand guns in 1997 they has a violent crime increase by 70% and a homicide increase of 50%. Gun control didn't reduce crime it made crime worse. An important thing to remember when comparing countries is that America has 317million…

    Against

    • I haven't seen convincing evidence that gun bans enacted in various countries have had noticeable effects on overall crime rates.
    • End
  4. 654.

    The death penalty is never justified

    For

    • So, the last round. I'll first go over why my argument already addressed the concerns raised by Con and then summarize what went down in the debate and why my argument stands.Before I begin, as I understand it- the critical difference between me and Con on the issue is our…
    • "The truth is that some crimes are so outrageous that society insists on adequate punishment, because the wrong doer deserves it" PRO attempts to diffuse this justification by 1) citing the futility of the death penalty as any form of solace, 2) how it devalues life, and 3) how…

    Against

    • ForwardCermank has informed me that she will more than likely be unable to complete this debate. Nevertheless I will go ahead and post the round given that the weekend is around the corner and that she only has one round left to complete, lol, so maybe she may have a couple…
    • I will first focus upon why the death penalty exists, and then proffer hypotheticals that demonstrate the necessity for a death penalty in extremely rare cases. Why does the death penalty exist? PRO posits that it is due to "some of the crimes having no place in a civilised…
  5. 655.

    Dzhokhar Tsarnaev is innocent of the Boston Marathon bombing

    For

    • Ok. If it gets messed up we can debate it in the comment section. People at the marathon where the bombs went off say that they were told "it's a drill stay calm" also with all the bomb sniffing dogs that were at the marathon I find it hard to believe that those dogs didn't…
    • Thank you for agreeing to watch the documentary and debate this with me.

    Against

    • I. The BOP has not been filledI considered my opponents time on this site would of taught her what a debate looks like. This is not it. The opposition has not provided even a slight resemblance to having argued, and her BOP is 100% negated. If Pro is unwilling to engage in a…
    • Extend BOP waiting time
  6. 656.

    The death penalty should be banned

    For

    • Argument 1- Con says,"Why do innocent people get killed? Because of fault in police investigation. The judiciary gives death penalty based on the evidences presented before it. So death penalty can't be blamed for death of these innocent people. "You are not getting my point,…
    • Argument 1- Con says," 'I personally have always voted for the death penalty because I believe that people who go out prepared to take the lives of other people forfeit their own right to live.'-Margaret Thatcher". Just quoting somebody doesn't prove your point. Argument 2- Con…

    Against

    • Argument 1- Con says 'Just quoting somebody doesn't prove your point.' Argument 2-'You kill somebody as a punishment for killing someone else?An eye for an eye and the world will go blind. Also, if a person kills somebody, he is violating the victim's 'Right to Life' but if you…
    • Argument 1-Pro says ' Innocent People are Killed The death penalty is irreversible.' Why do innocent people get killed?Because of fault in police investigation.The judiciary gives death penalty based on the evidences presented before it.So death penalty can't be blamed for…
  7. 657.

    The federal government should keep allowing abortion in the first two trimesters

    For

    • Opponent>>> i personally think that abortion will lead to infanticide, which will lead to a cleansing of human beings.For example, In the future im afraid that if a woman has a baby with blue eyes, instead of, i dont know, green eyes, she'll just give up her "fetus" and try…
    • +++ Well. Maybe somebody does love the baby. Maybe not. That's not what this debate is about. +++ You cannot kill hobos, because the hobo will not be an emotional and financial leech for 18 years of your life. And a hobo is a person. +++ We have seen your definition of…

    Against

    • i wasnt 'trampling' the constitution,but i am trampling the way youre translating it. i dont think our founding fathers would, if ever possible, look into the future and enjoy seeing the fetal products of their hardwork sucked out and utterly destroyed. Du you think they would…
    • i clearly said i think if a woman is raped she should be given a choice. For people that actually think a human life, no matter at what stage, could accomplish amazing things, the thought of a whore having unprotected sex with every guy she meets, and just aborting something…
  8. 658.

    Governments should require a license to marry

    For

    • /debate.
    • Extend all arguments.

    Against

    • Currently in the United Sates government requires people to be licensed to get married. It is this license that prevents polygamy and homosexual marriage. Marriage is a union between consenting individuals and god. Therefore: I assert that the government has no business…
  9. 659.

    Concealed guns should be allowed on college campuses

    For

    • As stated above, my argument is that it should be the responsibility of college administrations to determine whether or not guns ought to be allowed on campuses and to what extent they should be prohibited. No one else has any right to intervene in that regard. C1: Property…
    • I'm still waiting for my opponent's case.

    Against

    • i would like to start by combining round two and three together as well as round four and five for a total of three rounds. ===Argument=== when it comes to the issue of concealed weapons whitin college campus, it is quite clear that the United states "States government" simply…
    • i will be arguing that the United States government should not allow guns in college campuses. Round one: intro Round two: main round Round three:cross examination/ additional info/ question Round four: answers Round five: conclusion
  10. 660.

    Birthright citizenship should be abolished in the US

    For

    • I stand in firm affirmation of this resolution. I believe that it is unfair, unjust, cheating, and not what the creators of the 14th Amendment originally intended. Firstly, it is important to know that birthright citizenship is one of the most controversial issues in…
    • I ask that my opponent does not use arguments that are not written by him or herself unless given permission by the original creator. This will be a PF type Debate.

    Against

    • ugh....well Forfeiting 2/3 rounds= I win.
    • >.>
  11. 661.

    Julian Assange should be freed from his charges

    For

    • Lets get started Julian Assange has been called a lot of names like traitor and whistle blower but he did what he had to do to show the world the corruption and scandals that was going on in this world and destroying the top 1% of the top 1%. He got shamed later in his life by…
    • please follow all rules 1: be open minded 2: have a basic knowledge on the topic 3: good luck

    Against

    • I was hoping for a better debate.
    • My opponent has forfeited the round. I'm going to give him/her the benefit of doubt and assume s/he got busy. Hopefully you'll be able to make a response in the final round.
  12. 662.

    Dog fighting should be legal

    For

    • Dog fighting is a type of blood sport generally defined as opposing two game dogs against one another in a ring or a pit, for the entertainment of the spectators or the gratification of the dogfighters. Please note that just because I think dog fighting should be legal, doesn't…
    • Many apologies to ThinkBig for the forfeit; weekends are too busy for me to get on DDO. Re: The Moral Status of Animals1. The government does not recognize animal rights. My opponent completely dropped my contentions on this point. A) The vast majority of humans are not…

    Against

    • I do apologize that this is not my best response. I have been moving into a new house and physically and mentally exhausted. I do hope that Danielle and I can debate again sometime. Burden of ProofRemember that because Danielle is arguing against the status quo, the burden of…
    • Sad to see a forfeit. Hope all is well. Extend arguments.
  13. 663.

    All drugs should be legalized

    For

    • Extend. I would like voters to vote for me because my opponent forfeited 2 rounds.
    • Extend

    Against

    • 1) People on drugs do, quite often, hurt people. There are many deaths in drunk driving related accidents. 2) I also think that Marijuana should be legalized, just not other drugs. Cigarettes and alcohol are more dangerous, and shouldn't be legal compared to marijuana. 3) I…
    • I accept this challenge. This is my first ever debate on this website and I think I know my way around but I apologize in advance if I make any errors.
  14. 664.

    Tax evaders should be sent to workhouses

    For

    • Many thanks to grape for accepting this challenge. My opponent's victim 'mugging-off the mugger' scam is a very clever analogy. But wait! All is not what it seems. The mugger might actually be a have-a-go hero who saw the man lift the wallet out of a blind man's jacket and who…
    • Tax evasion is a numbers game. Let's take the hypothetical example of a braying young aristocrat who has an unearned income of �100,000 per year, this money being accrued through an offshore trust fund that his over-privileged mummy and daddy set up for him when he was born.…

    Against

    • Brian continues to make indignant suggestions that are both economically and morally fallacious. That this form of reasoning is considered at all rational in Britain is perhaps the best explanation of why they are now our lapdog and not the other way around. That's right, I…
    • A man is walking down a street in a neighborhood of questionable safety one night when he is set upon by a mugger. The mugger puts a gun to the man's head and demands that he forfeit all his money. Craftily, the unfortunate victim gives the mugger a fake wallet that contains…
  15. 665.

    The US should adopt stricter gun control laws

    For

    • I would firstly like to state my framework for this debate, and then move on to state my contentions for this debate. Framework: The affirmation states "Adopt stricter gun control laws. " This means that the proposition only needs to prove one gun law that should be stricter in…

    Against

    • Current laws are not enforced concerning firearms. New ones will not be enforced efficiently either.People have the right to protect themselves from terrorists, murderers, rapists, and even our own government. Our government can't rid the world of 30-40,000 ISIS militants. How…
    • Current laws are usually poorly enforced. Criminals are often able to buy guns even when the law says they should be prohibited. We need to enforce the laws we have right now first.Guns do not kill people. People do. We need to concentrate on the values and morals of our…
  16. 666.

    Gun control is a necessary factor in keeping homicide rates low

    For

    • All I want to do this round is do a rebuttal of Con's latest argument, oh wait a minute, I meant debate; no that doesn't sound right."Why are you debating with me if you're not even an American citizen?" I knew it, I bloody knew that you would say this. Why am I not allowed to…
    • In this round I am going to do some refutations of the contender's first argument."Guns are not only used for killing, as a person who has used guns for almost my whole life, killing has only been a part of it for a fraction of the time, and human death has never been a part.…

    Against

    • I really do think you have lost control. Why are you debating with me if you're not even an American citizen? And this is a debate, not an argument, but you probably don't know the difference. Defining control or any other words merely for the context that is most beneficial to…
    • I'm not going to be extremely formal, I'm just going to prove your points wrong. Gun control has not been proven to lower the rate of homicides, whether it be with guns, knives, bats, hammers, even bathtubs. For example, in the United Kingdom, a universal handgun ban was…
  17. 667.

    Private ownership of firearms should be banned in the United States

    For

    • Only in death is there agency -- only in death can we ever liberate ourselves. Through death, we own nothing, and through death we affirm. Poetics is pretty cool, it allows us to remove ourselves from the structure of debate through killing ourselves.
    • We return to the question of Lenin, that of "what is to be done?"I won't spoil the secret for my opponent for what is to be done, hopefully they can figure it out by themselves!(Hint: there is no private ownership in death!)

    Against

    • The debate is for Lexus.Resolution: In the United States, private ownership of handguns ought to be banned.Definitonshandguns: small type of gun used for one handprivate owneship: anything that is owned from a person banned: a stopped to, declineRules1. Forfeiting is a loss of…
    • I will quote my opponent's round. "We return to the question of Lenin, that of "what is to be done?" I won't spoil the secret for my opponent for what is to be done, hopefully they can figure it out by themselves!(Hint: there is no private ownership in death!)"I will answer my…
  18. 668.

    Polygamy should be decriminalized in the United States

    For

    • Per our agreement this debate will end in a tie.
    • Thanks, levelwithme for proposing the conventional restraints, since I neglected to do so. I agree- round2 for arguments, round3 for counterarguments and summation. Conditions 1 and 2, however, may prove too confining for my argument, which is more about changing prevailing…

    Against

    • This concludes the debate.
    • Per Round 1 conditions and reservations, I am withdrawing from the debate after the scope and restrictions of the debate changed(see comments, first post of Round 2). The debate will end in a tie.
  19. 669.

    The War on Drugs has failed

    For

    • To rebut this round, I will match my opponent's tactic, by using bold lettering when quoting him. " However, it was offered within the context of reassuring me that the rates of usage of dangerous narcotics might increase as a result of ending the WoD, and that there are very…
    • I suppose I will rebut each statement my opponent has made in the corresponding numbers. 1. United States drug policy technically began in 1914 through the Harrison Narcotics Tex Act. As many of us know, heroin and cocaine were first manufactured pharmaceuticals. Advertisements…

    Against

    • I want to sincerely thank my debate partner for a quick yet engaging contest. I feel that he has conducted himself well, and has provided the readers with a perspective that is not often seen. For my part, I have enjoyed the exercise, and regret somewhat its speedy conclusion.…
    • It is important, in arguing any important topic, that it is presented well. Both my partner and I share serious concerns about the direction that the WoD is taking, and we both hope to see much more intelligent policy be implemented going forward. However, exactly because I…
  20. 670.

    The death penalty is morally wrong and should be illegal

    For

    • Tell me why you think that you have the right to take another persons life if they take another or otherwise why do we get to take the life with chemicals and drugs that we inject to their body. studys show that it could take hours to kill that person or seconds. now in my book…
    • Now some of this argument is going to be on the fact that we have a comment on saying that we should kill them all and der it over with! you and the rest of your family and the world when we find out that the "killer" is innocent!!! i should refute your points i know this but i…

    Against

    • As he does not see my viewpoints as worth debating though, I am a little confused. As my opponent would rather state his opinion than debate you must vote CON.
    • To start off I'll point out the fact that my opponent, in failing to refute my points, has tacitly agreed to them. "how is it that the death penalty is just. if we criticize the people that kill others and then we turn around and kill them that is just a little hypocritical is…
  21. 671.

    The United States should end the war on drugs

    For

    • Thanks, Con. Milton Friedman once said that it is not the purpose of government to make people moral or upright. Laws are created to resolve discrepancies in the way people live, act and trade - not command people on how to treat their own person. While together individuals…
    • Many thanks in advance to whomever accepts this debate. == Clarifications == The War on Drugs is a campaign of prohibition intended to both define and reduce the illegal drug trade. This initiative includes a set of drug policies of the United States that are intended to…

    Against

    • Individuals participate in society because it is in the best interests of all who participate. Left to their own device, people are selfish, cruel, and miserable. Many people simply lack the logic and proper ability to reason to make effective choices even if all the required…
    • Thank you for proposing this debate. I accept the definition of the War On Drugs. However, I would like to clarify that my position is not simply that the status quo ought to remain the same. I will contend that in order for the War on Drugs to truly succeed, it will be…
  22. 672.

    Police should be given time before giving statements after shootings

    For

    • I apologize to my opponent, but this is going to have to be a one round debate for me, which I acknowledge puts me at a huge disadvantage.
    • 3,000 characters. Resolution: police officers should be allowed atleast 48 hours before writing their statement in use of force situation, involving the use of lethal force.

    Against

    • Extend.
    • okay.
  23. 673.

    Biological parents should be banned from contacting children given up for adoption

    For

    • I still remain inquisitive in the willingness of my opponent to revert to Lincoln Douglas, Public Forum, or other similar types of debate flow structures for easier point construction and rebuttals, and am still waiting for an answer. Moving on: 1: My opponent's only response…
    • Due to the purpose of this debate, I suggest that we utilize other forms of debate structures, such as Lincoln Douglas or even Public Forum in order to better allow for a general debate flow structure that most individuals can understand on a day-to-day basis. It would merely…

    Against

    • I just want to clear any misunderstanding; I had no intention of communicating that my knowledge about the debate style (THW format) puts me in the running for this debate. On with the arguments and rebuttals. .. As the instigator supporting the CON side of this debate, my…
    • Thank you for accepting and here is my response to your inquiries which will clarify any confusion... THW is not alluding to the German Federal Agency for Technical Relief, it actually is an abbreviation for "This house will..." or "This house would..." in BP (British…
  24. 674.

    The death penalty should remain legal

    For

    • There is a large argument about the Death Penalty and how it is inhuman or unconstitutional. Your reasons is invalid and unrealistic, this is the Law people, a law thought out carefully to uphold our justice, Protecting our rights.
    • IntroductionI want to clarify where this debate headed. This is my understanding of the new debate from your previous responsesFirst Pro-Resolution is as follows: Death penalty is Justice Con-Resolution is as follows: The Death penalty is no Justice Con Stated "I am opposed to…

    Against

    • Original resolution negated. Second resolution burden of proof left unfilled.
    • Extended.
  25. 675.

    Capital punishment is a justified form of justice

    For

    • I am putting forward an open debate relating to capital punishment. I believe that capital punishment should be considered as a form of justice and therefore, should be allowed.
    • 1) Capital Punishment reduces crime rates by 3.47%. This happens to be an article I read in the times of India a couple of days or so ago. However, I have not yet been able to find a source to this article on the net. Therefore, I shall not be able to furnish a source to the…

    Against

    • I accept. I'm assuming we will be arguing based on the jucidal system of the United States?
    • Additionally, while I am thrilled that my opponent has begun sourcing his arguments, most of his more important claims are unsourced. I would like my opponent to provide, in his next round, sources for: - His claim that the additional charges of the Death Penalty is only $75000…
  26. 676.

    Marijuana should be regulated like alcohol

    For

    • Ok well I'm not going to type as much as I would like(due to time restraints) ill combat to your points. 1.Marijuana does have some minor side effects, But these effects are far much less than what legal drugs can do to you, i.e tobacco and alcohol causing much more addiction…
    • Its my first one also! But lets get down to business. Everyone knows the government will do anything it can to not give any attention to marijuana. Its listed as a schedule 1 drug which means its apparently more dangerous than cocaine. For a drug to be in schedule 1, it has to…

    Against

    • 1) That statement is false. marijuana is as addictive as tobacco and alcohol. "Marijuana addiction has the same characteristics as any other addiction to other drugs including alcohol, tobacco or even caffeine" (1) And yes the gateway theory is a theory. But so are gravity and…
    • I agree that marijuana has medical benefits, as i simply is true. however, I would say our agreement may end there. 1) Marijuana use has negative side effects. Your argument made it seem as though marijuana was safe and harmless. Whether or not this was your intention, i ought…
  27. 677.

    Making recreational drugs illegal does more harm than good

    For

    • internet sales will increase if drugs are legalised.
    • The Illegality Of Recreational Drugs Results In Unnecessary Risks For Those Who Choose To Consume Them

    Against

    • what will it do to thoes who use
    • Will these be glorified like cigarettes and alcohol to our children by advertising?
  28. 678.

    Businesses should have the right to discriminate

    For

    • Thank you for your interesting points. You write " A private business, while owned by someone privately, is a service that you provide to others. By selling a product or providing an active service you put yourself out there for criticism and legal punishment." Why do I lose…
    • Thank you for your acceptance and I greatly look forward to hearing your side of this debate. I will keep my opening statement short. In arguing in favor of this motion, I will repeatedly set forth to show that this position is both correct from a moral and legal perspective as…

    Against

    • Thank you for continuing to present thought-out points throughout your debate. First of all, the prospect of a jail sentence was never brought up. There are many forms of illegal, and many punishments as well, and not all of those are jail time. Even I must admit that jailing…
    • Thank you for your acceptance and I too look forward to hearing and considering your reasoning. My opening statement will attempt to be just as brief: In arguing against this motion I will attempt to show that my position is the more reasonable in the same aspects that you…
  29. 679.

    All citizens who have not committed a crime should have the right to purchase a gun

    For

    • You've forgotten the most important fact of all. You know how the Constitution states our god-given rights that cannot be taken away by anyone? The constitution of the United States says, "the right of the People to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed." Therefore, people…
    • Quote from your argument- So your biggest negative impact is that criminals will get a leg up and hurt helpless citizens. To minimize that impact I provide 3 rational. 1) Most Americans do not own a gun; therefore, the number of citizens that will be defenseless will not…

    Against

    • First of all, I'd like to point out the abuse of this situation. It is round 3! He has completely trashed his original case and started an entirely new debate! I am expected to leave the case I have worked on and answer an entirely new pro case like it is round 1, this is a…
    • OK, so your ENTIRE rebuttal was a defense of the attacks I made on your case. Keep in mind, you don't simply win if I don't land an argument against your case, I have given 4 well supported reasons why banning private ownership of guns would do FAR more good than bad. At this…
  30. 680.

    Gun control laws are unconstitutional

    For

    • Your argument is good, but there are several flaws in your argument. In your first argument, you talk about how the wording of the 2nd amendment specifically pertains to a "well regulated militia." While at first glance, it may seem as though they were referring to a militia…
    • The second amendment very clearly states "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." By implementing gun control, we are infringing the rights to bear arms, and therefore, we are implementing an unconstitutional law. Con can go first.

    Against

    • Rebuttals:"According to District of Columbia v. Heller, the term "militia" should not be confined to those serving in the military, because at the time the term referred to all able-bodied men who were capable of being called to such service (Source:…
    • I have two main arguments, plus a rebuttal.Argument 1: The WordingThe full text of the Second Amendment reads: "A well regulated militia, being necessary for the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."Notice the first two…
  31. 681.

    The death penalty should be legal

    For

    • In my eyes, the person is first found guilty. The authorities have found him guilty. His fingerprints are on the gun. The other man is surely dead. They don't deserve life on Earth after the other is dead. Say the man is not given life in prison. After ten years he is bailed…
    • The death penalty is a serious problem the world. For other countries they kill without a crime. There needs to be some sort of law to stop these crimes. I don't understand why some people are for abortion but against a death penalty. How could you kill a defenseless, innocent…

    Against

    • I have read many cases where innocent people have been given the death penalty. I think jail time is a better solution. Yes, it costs more money, but it will save lives. And to be honest, and I think I am not the only one who thinks this, I would rather be killed than live in…
    • I disagree. I think assumed criminals should not be given the death penalty. I think life in jail will be a much better solution. What if the assumed criminal is later found not guilty AFTER he is killed. What will happen then? I think life in jail is better for this exact…
  32. 682.

    The death penalty should be legal in all states

    For

    • As stated in an article "A Case for the Death Penalty" the murder rates raised when capital punishment was declared unconstitutional. This is a prime example of murders rates rising when there is no punishment. As stated in the article… When executions went down, the number of…
    • The death penalty should be legal in all states across the United States considering some people commit crimes knowing they will get away with it. If the death penalty was implemented, those murderers might reconsider before committing the act.

    Against

    • Fin
    • Extend arguments.
  33. 683.

    Americans have a right to bear arms

    For

    • 2nd amendment guarantees both militia and individual arms rights
    • 2nd amendment secures equally the right of the militia and the individual to arms.

    Against

    • English Bill of Rights restricted right to arms
    • The people" in the Second Amendment refers to a collective right to arms
  34. 684.

    Racial profiling should be encouraged as a law enforcement tool

    For

    • Firstly, when arguing that utilization of racial profiling as one of many techniques in identifying an offender violates the 14th amendment you clearly did not read the definition I stated in the terms of this debate. I am not arguing for law enforcement to stop anyone they…
    • Terms of discussion: - 1st round is for acceptance and opening statements - Opponent will be arguing against the use of racial profiling in any form by law enforcement. - Definition of racial profiling: The use of race or ethnicity as grounds for suspecting someone of having…

    Against

    • Racial profiling definitely should not be encouraged in law enforcement. Most obviously, it violates the 14th amendment by not granting equal protection under the law for all citizens. It violates the due process of the law because there's not enough evidence of a crime to…
    • I'm reading your argument and I'm honestly still confused. Where is 'profiling' already being used, and how is RP not being used there already? I'm not saying you need to give an entire description of the profiling process, but what crimes are profiles used in? Murder? Because,…
  35. 685.

    Flogging with the cat o' nine tails should be legal

    For

    • First of all, I should like to address the You Tube clip my opponent embedded which depicted a flogging scene from the olden days. Now, we don't know who the prisoner was or what his crime was, but you can bet it was more than illegally parking his chariot – more likely…
    • Flogging offenders with a cat o' nine tails [1] is the fairest, most egalitarian way to punish petty crimes. Let's say, for example, that someone parks their car illegally and gets a ticket. It may be a low-paid single father who illegally parked his beaten-up old Vauxhall…

    Against

    • It seems my opponent felt there was warrant for giving a paragraph of jokes on the man being whipped in my video but did not find there was warrant actually address the argument I gave with it. Had my point been 'look how unjust that was' then maybe it would be relevant to…
    • From Pro's argument he seems to think the Rich feel free to commit petty crimes petty crimes because they know they can pay the fines without a second thought. When they get the parking ticket they don't even flinch with the dread middle class does at having to take care of…
  36. 686.

    Victimless crimes should be decriminalized

    For

    • Thank you Con for the response. I will first address Con's case and provide rebuttals where needed, then move on to reaffirming my own case -Con's position- She starts off by stating that " Anything that harms our individuals is something that we should act against. I think the…
    • It is my position that promotes self-interest. The united states government should not have the authority to govern how one chooses to live their life. The only time the government should interfere with ones autonomy is when that individuals self-interests infringes on…

    Against

    • So a part of our arguments come down to a discussion on the value of freedom and whether the value I put forth are more worthy of consideration in this case. These are values of happiness and life - utilitarian values - as Kozu suggests. If my arguments or claims in favor of…
    • Thank you Kozu. My position is that human beings have a vested interest in our species to protect ourselves and each other from things that harm those within our species. Anything that harms our individuals is something that we should act against. I think the value of the…
  37. 687.

    Illegal drugs should be legalized

    For

    • Drugs cause nothing bad, in fact life is too shallow to actually live it without drugs. Live is very monotonous, you just work, eat and survive. By actually trying different states of consciousness can give you happiness.
    • I believe that drugs are good for the body because they allow you to have a good leisure time and enjoy your life. Life is short and we must enjoy it, the government has no say about how we chose to live our lives.

    Against

    • My opponent has forfeited.
    • People often begin to use drugs or drink a lot of alcohol to avoid the things that bother them most. Some examples of the things people may want to avoid are: pressure from friends, stress in the family, hassles, the feeling that adults are on their case, or the lousy feeling…
  38. 688.

    The Military Commissions Act of 2006 should be repealed

    For

    • The Military Commissions Act (http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov...) is unconstitutional, unethical, and unnecessary. Under this act, the government can declare any alien, including someone who has lived in the United States for years, an "unlawful enemy combatant." Furthermore,…
    • I agree with you that no law is perfect, and if this law really was necessary then maybe it would be better just to fix the wholes, but as I pointed out, not only are there many horrible problems with the Military Commissions Act but it also doesn't help anything. There is no…

    Against

    • I disagree for a very simple reason. We should be able to protect ourselves from any and all peoples we feel are a threat to us. Now I would submit that this power must be used with discretion but, as it does violate the constitution (no rights are extended to foreigners in the…
    • First let me apologize for not addressing your argument about International Law. The Geneva Convention excludes from the rights granted to common soldiers. So this Law does not violate International Law but rather make that law US law as well! Second I am sorry about not being…
  39. 689.

    Police should be abolished in free societies

    For

    • Fo shizzle ma dizzle niggerz
    • Yolo swag

    Against

    • #noblemanlyfestyle #530farmitpeasants
    • #24seven #alldayerrday
  40. 690.

    Possession of marijuana should be legal in the USA

    For

    • As mentioned in the rules I am not allowed to add anything significant in this round. I therefore will only wish the judges luck with judging this debate.
    • Again, there's not much to debate about.

    Against

    • ResolutionThe Possetion of Marijuana Ought to be Legal in the United States of AmericaRules 1. Pro will begin arguing in Round 1. He will post something similar to "no round as agreed" in Round 4.2. No new arguments in the last round. DefintionsI expect all terms in the…
  41. 691.

    Prostitution should be legalized in the US

    For

    • I will be basing my argument off one from a previous debate of mine (. http://www.debate.org...) . === PRO ARGUMENTS === ECONOMIC BENEFITS: If Prostitution was legalised, the government could regulate it and tax it. It would create more revenue for the government through this.…
    • I hope all is well with my opponent. However, my arguments stand unrefuted, and I await his response in the next round.

    Against

    • yeah true we would make more money from their taxes but just think people that could be doctors scientist or people that could find a cure or aids or breast cancer will say man that is too much hard work then they will say prostitution easy and I can make a lot of money you see…
  42. 692.

    Canada and the US should strengthen gun control laws

    For

    • My opponent would like to discuss the merits of the gun control debate as an issue worthy of discussion at all. Understanding that my opponent does not feel that gun control (and, by extension, gun-related violence) is a problem of a scope which requires redress at the…

    Against

    • No response - my arguments stand.
    • I thank my honourable opponent for his acceptance. From his issues bar I see that we have similar opinions, this, however, we disagree on. I do not think that gun control is an important issue in either Canada or the US. This is not a debate about whether I am for or against,…
  43. 693.

    All guns should be banned

    For

    • Since 1791, the United States has had the second amendment which is a law that allows US citizens to carry guns. As a result, within the past six years, there have been over 1600 shootings in the US resulting in thousands of lost lives. Because of this, I am for the resolution,…
    • Arguments will begin next round.

    Against

    • I accept. Good luck!
    • First, please cite all of your sources. I have a hard time believing that crime rates in Canada are 90% lower than the US. Even if they are the population in Canada is 36 million and the population in the US is 325 million so that might explain the percentage difference. You…
  44. 694.

    The Supreme Court had the right to legalize same-sex marriage nationwide

    For

    • Majority can rule against gay marriage all they want that doesn't mean they are right. The Supreme Court is made up of people who care about others and their happiness because they are the people who aren't sexist, racist, or stereotypical. The country was built on the basis of…
    • In America we have a Supreme Court, people who make the major decisions for our country that we as ordinary people can't decide. Gay marriage has been a question tossed in the Supreme Court's face so many times it might as well be boring, but it isn't. In America people have…

    Against

    • Now it dose not mean the Supreme Court was right either because this is an opinion between them and the public of the US and the Supreme Court dose not care about happiness by god if they did they would have taken in account of people who didn't like this at all. The Supreme…
    • Now you do have an excellent point but the Constitution dose in fact state that We the people of the United States not. We the nine people of the United States. Majority rules in the US so what ever a decision like this is worth needs to be decided by the citizens no matter how…
  45. 695.

    Torture should be permitted in some counterterrorism cases

    For

    • I can't argue against the scenario where the person is only a suspected terrorist. I believe giving the government the ability to torture people who they haven't proven to be enemies to be a bad idea, as they could use this to infringe upon the rights of Americans. So I'm sorry…
    • Thanks to my opponent for the arguments. Before I get into rebuttals integral to this debate, I'd like to rebuttal the use of the word 'innocent'. I feel the need to rebuttal this because it's the kind of descriptive language that can sway voters. My point here is that the man…

    Against

    • It seems, then, that we are in agreement over the issue of torture. It would be nice if people wouldn't vote on this debate, since it floppped just because of an honest misunderstanding... Thank you for your time, and, again, sorry for messing this up.
    • I'm sorry. I must have misunderstood the scenario... I thought we were dealing with a SUSPECTED terrorist here; not an already known terrorist... I'm actually in favor of using torture if we already know he is a terrorist... I suppose it is up to you what to do with this debate…
  46. 696.

    Everyone over 21 should have the right to own a firearm

    For

    • Remeber what i said that they have to pass a test and the government isn"t that dumb and would not let buy any gun. Once a person have internal problems they can scan it on the way he acts while testing. Many people now in days are very more wilder than back then most of the…
    • If you have your gun legalized and have special permission from the government which you will need to be trained by police officers, not only on firearms, but in self defense classes. Having permission to have a firearm requires a psychological and physical exams. If you have…

    Against

    • People can be trained and check many times by the government but always people can get guns some how , people can make things happen and they can cause a disaster like some years ago in the Batman movie , or in schools like the ounces we see recently . Yes crazy people make…
    • I think people above 21 does"t need a weapon in house , there are many cases in which a guy gets guns and kills everyone in schools or other public places . Also I think that people doesn't need to protect them self's , we have the police to protect people and also always in…
  47. 697.

    Marijuana should not be legalized

    For

    • I'm sorry for the unfortunate forfeit round; I've been busy and my immediate needs precede those of mine on this site. Anyhow, since you seem to agree with me that we're still arguing on whether this drug ought to be immediately legalized for recreational use, let us continue…
    • Yes, you're absolutely right that the reason not enough is known about it is mostly the fact that it's not legal and thus no conclusive, acceptable, long-term studies have been conducted yet. And speaking of risky behaviors, I ask you, which is more risky? Complete…

    Against

    • http://www.drugwarfacts.org... http://www.history.com... Banning the sales of marijuana creates a black market. Illegalizing marijuana will not eliminate the risks you have provided. Prohibition increases the rate of crime, not the opposite. My links provide this accurate…
    • pass
  48. 698.

    Prostitution should be legalized

    For

    • Thanks for your argument however I assume that this problems exist in the hiding world of prostitution. But after legalization these women can easily go to psychologists to talk about their emotional and mental problems and together they are more likely to solve this problems.…
    • According to the arguments of my opponent prostitution brings more crime to the streets, however after legalization percentage of criminals decreased significantly again in Amsterdam. It is one of the most law abiding cities in the World. Police will take under control areas of…

    Against

    • The biggest and the most important question put up while pre-concerting or taking into account any legislation is whether it really stops the harm done to sex workers and consequentially contributes to the betterment of the society. These days, legalisation aims at renaming…
    • I see your side that legalization of prostitution can help to solve amount of problem but 75% of women working as escorts had attempted suicide. Prostitution causes women irrevocable mental and physical damage along with heinous emotional abuse due to a derogatory social…
  49. 699.

    The federal government should legalize medical marijuana and hemp

    For

    • Well, my opponent has forfeited R3, but hopefully he will at least provide a conclusion to his arguments. For my conclusion, I will provide some background, and then reiterate my arguments. Marijuana is a plant grouped by the genus cannabis. It has three species: cannabis…
    • Because my opponent keeps jumping around the topics, and has ignored the case I have made, I will address his points one by one (or try to): "So realistically he must prove that both can be legalized, or else I win this round." -Indeed I have shown in both R1 and R2 arguments…

    Against

    • I sincerely apologize for dropping that last round, i was at a real debate tournament over the weekend and had no time. what you should look to in this debate round is still the argument of governmental legitimacy. this point stands in this debate round with complete relevance,…
    • Basically what the resolutional analysis comes down to in this round, is my opponent has to show to the judging pool how he is without a doubt proving the resolution in its entirety true. My opponent states that the DEA lumped both [marijuana and hemp] together under their…
  50. 700.

    The death penalty should be banned

    For

    • Well, that ends that! VOTE PRO ON THE BANNING OF THE DEATH SENTENCE!
    • My opponent has forefited the last round, so I can't post a rebuttal. It has been a nice debate, though.

    Against

    • Attack against Argument One: Life actually cost money too Many opponents present, as fact, that the cost of the death penalty is so expensive (at least $2 million per case?), that we must choose life without parole ('LWOP') at a cost of $1 million for 50 years. Predictably,…
    • Lol oh dear :)

How to use these debate topics

  • Vote, discuss, revote. Poll the room on the motion, give 5 minutes of discussion, then vote again and look at who changed their mind.
  • Four corners. Label corners strongly agree → strongly disagree; people move, then each corner makes its best case.
  • Switch sides. Halfway through, everyone argues the side they disagree with. It sharpens listening.

Run them live

Want every person to answer on their own phone, with a timer and a live leaderboard? Use these questions in an EngageSlide Vote · Discuss · Revote — free to start.

Tick questions on any page — your set is kept while you browse (or take the first 10 here) — and they become ready-to-play slides. What is EngageSlide?

More question collections

Questions adapted from args.me corpus (CC BY 4.0), edited for clarity. This collection may be reused under the same terms — see sources & licenses.