Discussly

Health Debate Topics for Students — page 11

716 debate topics, students. Debatable motions with arguments for and against. Open the arguments below, pick one at random, or present them full-screen.

StudentsDebatePage 11 of 15
  1. 501.

    Public smoking bans are unacceptable

    For

    • Smoking is a choice that the individual make, and therefore it should be up to the individual person if he or she wants to smoke or not. I earlier mentioned that it was a human right to smoke and failed to explain why. America is a land of freedom and liberty; we have the right…
    • Asphalt is just as dangerous as smoking. The fumes from asphalt can give headache, skin rash, sensitization, fatigue, reduced appetite, throat and eye irritation, cough, and skin cancer. So why should it only be smoking that should be banned. When we walk outside on a hot…

    Against

    • Pro states that: "Smoking is a choice that the individual make, and therefore it should be up to the individual person if he or she wants to smoke or not. "Which still fails to explain *why* smoking should not banned. Literally anything can be an individual choice, but that…
    • =Rebuttals=Pro claims that "asphalt is as dangerous as smoking", however, the resolution is exclusively about smoking and not anything else that could potentially be dangerous. The difference between asphalt and cigarette smoking is also significant. One of them is essentially…
  2. 502.

    Public health concerns justify compulsory vaccination

    For

    • I would like to offer the following definitions. According to Merriam Webster's Dictionary: to justify is to prove or show to be just, right or reasonable. Just is to be in conformity with what is morally upright and good. According to Random House Unabridged Dictionary…

    Against

    • Once again unfortunate... Please give me the win seeing as my opponent has forfeited.
    • This forfeit signifies two things: 1. The extensions of all my arguments, because the resolution/ debate is specifically LD style no new arguments may permitted. So I have one the round. 2. The lack of respect he has to me, numerous times I have seen my opponent online yet he…
  3. 503.

    Doctors should receive more training on sleep disorders

    For

    • R1: Sleep is Overlooked "We analyzed our records, and only 2% of our patients were referred by GP's." [1] We both agree time spent on sleep disorders is nearly nonexistent. The GP's are the first to see patients, but with the vast deficiency in knowledge based on sleep…
    • Thanks for accepting Bluesteel, you're a formidable opponent. I ask in R3 would you accept a cap of 2,000 characters?Sleep rejuvenates the body and mind.Arguments C1: Sleep is Overlooked Medical schools currently spend barely any time educating future doctors about sleep. The…

    Against

    • Thanks for the debate Contra. R1: Sleep is Overlooked Contra cites a quote from Dr. Clement saying that only 2% of patients were referred by GP's. However, Clement is a unique expert in sleep disorders and sees mostly patients with unique disorders, such as narcolepsy, wherein…
    • ==Character Limit== I don't know about 2,000. That's short. And because you only gave me 24 hours to respond, I have only 50 min right now and thus don't have much time to research many of your claims. R1: Sleep is Overlooked Contra's first source, the one which says that sleep…
  4. 504.

    Adolescents should have autonomous medical decision rights

    For

    • I stand in the firmest affirmation of the resolution "Adolescents ought to have the right to make autonomous medical decisions." First, I would like to define a few terms: Adolescents: 13-17 years of age Ought: Necessary (Cambridge) Autonomous: having the right or power to…

    Against

    • Forfeiture, dropped all arguments.
    • Extend.
  5. 505.

    Emotional suppression is better than venting

    For

    • So. Here we go. Another fully plagiarized piece of text from RationalMadman. This time you didn't even bother to clean it up to make it look like yours. Why would you? Last time you won the debate, even though you copied your post from an irrelevant source and then lied about…
    • My sister thinks that venting your bad emotions is a healthy thing. I think the opposite, but instead of telling her so in a calm and mature manner, I would like to debate the issue here.

    Against

    • In this day and age, what with the economy as it is, the strain on relationships is approaching monumental levels. It's interesting to note that back in the days of the Great Depression, people were making babies and sticking together, through thick and thin, creating all sorts…
    • :) Okay, let me lose the conduct vote for plagiarism. That is okay then. I accept losing 1 point.I shall now go on to attempt to gain the 3 point arguments' vote and to cancel out your sources vote.According to this site: http://www.selfgrowth.com..."There is nothing wrong with…
  6. 506.

    High schools should provide a designated smoking area

    For

    • From an outside point-of-view, I am also very pleased with the maturity and grace with which you spoke. Let me continue as your opponent. 1. Free Choice. I think you are right in saying that a school is an, "institution dedicated to enhancing the knowledge, health and…
    • Hello and good morning, afternoon or evening. This is my very first debate of this kind so, as many others on this site seem to plead, be gentle with me. My argument is about tobacco use, albeit tailored to a more specific issue. I wish to argue that a high school where…

    Against

    • Welcome to the site. Thanks for posting the debate. 1. Free Choice While all smokers have the right to choose whether or not to smoke, it does not seem logical to have an institution dedicated to enhancing the knowledge, health and well-being of its students to condone and…
    • Sorry to see Marvel couldn't make the last round. I'll conclude with a summary of the debate. The only advantages Pro claims from installing smoking sections are the containment of smoking and a controlled area for young smokers to fulfill their addictions. First, I…
  7. 507.

    Individuals should not be required to buy health insurance

    For

    • Yes, I miss wrote on Obamacare giving us free healthcare, It provides free healthcare benefits to anyone who signs up for the program. Everyone is forced to pay a tax for it, and use it, or pay a fee, so basically yes it is free healthcare benefits with hiked up taxes for…
    • Obama care is a service, like dental service or doctor service or lawn care for that matter. Obama "giving" us free health care is false we all have to pay more taxes for that weather we want it and or need it or not. It is unconstitutional to make you have to buy a service.…

    Against

    • Due to space I've had to ellipse some quotes. Brackets are edits to ensure sense. "Everyone is forced …" Again, a misunderstanding of what Obamacare does. I urge Pro to look up what the law is. The law mandates: "A shared responsibility requirement. .. requires. .. all…
    • Unfortunately, it is premised on several errors of fact. Obamacare does not "give" us free health care. A single-payer system would do that; that is not what is in place. What is presently called "Obamacare" is a series of regulations of the insurance industry that was already…
  8. 508.

    America should adopt universal health care

    For

    • Its obvious that my oppoenent just does not understand the concept of the Federal Government and Healthcare. If the Gov't denies anyone they can and will be punish under my proposal. Gov't can't always be in control. Secondly, my oppoenet has never spoken to a group of small…
    • The secod point is that businesses and individuals are having trouble affording health care. Businesses and indidviduals that keep their health plans have to pay a much higher amount. If a business must spend more on health care cost, the it has less money for raises,…

    Against

    • I'm going to touch on the deny claim you have. The goverment still can deny you! I have already said that the goverment will pick and choose what to pay for. At least our system now covers your lasik or you nose that was hurt in an accident. but politics shouldn't be even near…
    • "There are forty Million uninsured American citizens who need Health Care. Health Care premiums continue to go up and climb faster that the rate of inflation. Many businesses do not even offer health plan coverage, those that do will often pass the cost of it to the employee.…
  9. 509.

    Medical professionals rather than parents should decide children's health care

    For

    • The right to live to regret
    • Religious freedom does not allow for the right to harm others

    Against

    • The division between the personal and social spheres
    • Freedom of religious observance
  10. 510.

    Financial incentives should be used to increase organ donation

    For

    • Financial organisers are giving incentives that is increasing malpractice of organ smuggling in the world

    Against

    • 5 rounds...seriously?
    • Too bad, I was looking forward to debating this.
  11. 511.

    Smoking should not be considered a right

    For

    • Frequently, smokers will contend that non-smokers/anti-smoking proponents are infringing upon their "rights." To be certain, people have a basic "right" to choose unhealthily, and cigarettes are not prohibited. However, there is no law protecting their "right" to use such…
    • In the interests of public health, it is my opinion and my conviction that smokers ought to be able to sacrifice smoking while they are in public areas. Legislation restricting public tobacco use would: 1. preserve clean air for all persons (non-smokers and otherwise) 2.…

    Against

    • I fully respect and understand your opinion. And before I begin I would like to say that I am an ex-smoker and when I did smoke I was careful about not bothering people. I did this because I believed that just like a woman has the right to do as she wishes with her body and…
    • I know all powerful commands and laws come in groups of multiples of 5 but let's simplify what you're claiming. First, preserving clean air and pollution are shocking similar so let's just combine 5 and 1 to clean air and decrease littering. Next, 2 and 3 are very close so…
  12. 512.

    Bartenders should be allowed to refuse alcohol to pregnant women

    For

    • It seems my opponent has gone. .. Too bad, i was enjoying this debate.
    • Thank you for continuing this debate. Alcohol is harmful to any fetus. Just like children they are developing in many different ways and alcohol can hurt this. Would you serve alcohol to a 4 year old child? Then why would you sell it to a fetus? Whatever the woman has to eat or…

    Against

    • If a pregnant woman wishes to drink, it should be under her own discretion, not that of the bartender. Should we stop allowing them to drink coffee and dye their hair as well? http://www.nydailynews.com... With more studies being done, it seems that maybe a little bit of…
    • Regardless of if the women is hurting her baby in choosing to drink alcohol, it is her body and she should be able to make the decision herself. Also, who is the bartender to say that what she is drinking is actually harming her baby? There are people I know of whose doctors…
  13. 513.

    Natural pale skin is more beautiful than tanned skin

    For

    • Pale skin is precious since the middle ages,it looks arristocratic. Ladies with pale,porcealin skin can not be afraid of skin cancer. A very long time ago that in times of royalty The more pale you were and whiter you were the more royal you are. It may have been during marie…
    • Sorry,I can't agree with you because,skin cancer is the most common of all cancers. It accounts for nearly half of all cancers in the United States. Melanoma, the most serious type of skin cancer, will account for more than 76,600 cases of invasive skin cancer in 2013. It…

    Against

    • So dear fellow future voters that was my conclusion and hope and earn a vote in negation. thank you.
    • Oh okay so for the second to last round i will conclude that my opponent's argument is based upon an opinion. tanning is only mistaken as dangerous and is never really dangerous it is because of global warming from one of my first points in the first round. Natural pale,…
  14. 514.

    Smoking in public areas should be banned

    For

    • The opposition has forfeited last round, and has failed to come up with any arguments against this case. The proposition stands by its arguments that smoking in public areas should be banned. Non-smokers who are passing by actual smokers become just as much at risk when…
    • Thank you for your arguments. I will now begin by analyzing my opponent's points, and then build upon my own. My opponent stated that: "Many people smoke in those area's and which if banned, cause a protest." Protests are not guaranteed, especially for something so small and…

    Against

    • Smoking in public area's shouldn't be banned for that. 1) Many people smoke in those area's and which if banned, cause a protest. 2) It doesn't discourage smokers to quit. 3) Think of enforcing this ban. As will I get further into these points as well others while bringing down…
    • I forfeited due to not being in town, and I won't be able to type my case and attack yours, due to I will have to get up early, and I have sleeping disorder's so I have to go to bed early, so you win this debate, Sir. But i will be back.
  15. 515.

    Cigarettes should be taxed more heavily

    For

    • The tax is proper. 440,000 people due due to the inimical effects of smoking cigarettes annually in the United States! Also, studies by the Center for Disease control have shown that the air quality in New York is proven to be nine times higher than in New Jersey, where smoking…
    • I believe that there should be a tax on cigarettes because of the detrimental cause of it towards our environment, ourselves, and the future implications towards future generations. Also, it would allot more revenue towards the federal government, which is what we need because…

    Against

    • Your argument consists of 1) we should tax cigarettes, 2) because they are detrimental "towards our environment " 3) "because they are detrimental to ourselves", 4} "because they are detrimental through future implications towards future generations. " 5) "Also, it would allot…
    • Inasmuch as Pro has forfeited, Con posits that: 1. The tax on cigarettes shall not be increased 2, Current cigarette tax revenues shall be used to reduce the use of cigarettes 3 Activities to reduce cigarette use shall be limited to education and not further legislation Quid…
  16. 516.

    The United States should adopt universal healthcare modeled on France

    For

    • it's fine it's no big deal. but to start this debate about how my opponent has stated that we can make this cheaper by having a single payer system. well by adopting universal health care we would be insuring 47 million people with health care so they could get treat meant and…
    • To start of this debate we just want to say that we are going to prove on how the United States health care is worse then the French health care system. We will prove this by the different cost, and how our economy would benefit from this. My first contention is that by…

    Against

    • My opponent completely drops my framework argument which was 1. pro must prove french system is the best in the world 2. pro must prove that the french system can be adapted in the united states since my opponent does not provide a framework, and concedes mine, look to this as…
    • I Negate the resolved. sorry i missed last round. Framework: Okay lets get this straight, for the framework, the pro has to show two things 1. french is best in the world, 2. french can be adapted in the united states this is significant because logically, the united states…
  17. 517.

    Cancer is primarily caused by genetic factors

    For

    • So, in my days of debate.org and schooling, I have heard many arguments of cancer being caused by a bad diet or some other stuff. This is not the case, my first argument starts here. Cancer is caused by a gene being damaged and a cell not being able to fix it. This is mostly…

    Against

    • That's all folks
    • Extend.
  18. 518.

    Non-donors should be denied priority for organ transplants

    For

    • Organ donors are more deserving of organs
    • A Practical Solution

    Against

    • The right to access healthcare is absolute
    • People may have valid religious reasons not to donate organs
  19. 519.

    The NHS should treat self-inflicted illnesses

    For

    • I have many more arguments (physical harm caused by mental illness, drugs, depression, etc.), but for some reason this debate has a 750 character limit. My opponent's only point is that "people should know better" and I believe that I have successfully countered it in my…
    • It is important to consider that the world is not perfect, and that even though there are many cases of health problems one may consider "self-inflicted", the people in question may not have had a real choice in the matter. Allow me to digress momentarily. I went to a…

    Against

    • I agree that all are worthy of assistance, however if they knowingly caused the reason for which they require the assistance then should they really be given this assistance. Alot of people seem to go for the Pro argument but i am curious as to why? To me its like telling a…
    • Should the NHS use up valuable resources to treat self inflicted illness? by self inflicted i mean those that are obese or have lung cancer due to excessive smoking or may have liver cirrhosis due to alcholism. these people have been warned according to the government that…
  20. 520.

    Smoking should be further restricted

    For

    • Restrictions reach out to the general population
    • The state has to take measures to protect the health of its citizens

    Against

    • Smoking is a choice of lifestyle the government should not intervene with
    • Regulation harms safety and the poor population
  21. 521.

    Women should have the right to access contraceptives

    For

    • I thank you for your time, Con.
    • Thank you, Con. I. Addressing Counter-Arguments/Rebuttals "Everyone acknowledges that having sex has risks, such as protection breaking, but you should go into the action accepting that it may happen, and willing to accept the consequences. If you were worried about getting…

    Against

    • I just got on and realized that my argument was due. I will be getting surgery tomorrow and will likely be out of commission for a while. I don't want to run the clock down to a forfeit, but due to time constraints, I can't make a case with the time I have. Count this as a…
    • Thanks to my opponent for issuing this challenge, as I have often wondered why people supported this. To maintain the flow of the debate, I'll rebut my opponents arguments, and then make some of my own.RE: Hypothetical scenariosCut the rhetoric out and get to the facts. My…
  22. 522.

    Eating meat is healthy

    For

    • I have to extend my previous points as I have nothing further to refute here. I appreciate the debate.
    • Immorality of eating meat is incoherent to this debate, as we are arguing the health of eating meat. I will need to see sources for your census to believe its legitimacy. My opponent's fallacy that eating less meat will cure world hunger. This does not apply to the health of…

    Against

    • Neither of us has shown any source material. Also, I would like to point out your obvious use of search engines and the copy/paste tools. Nevertheless, I will show sourcing here. My primary source is The Moral Life, by Louis J. Pojman. He explains the immorality and…
    • Meat is unhealthy in most every way imaginable. Compare people who don't eat meat's physical and emotional health to people who do. People who consume meat regularly tend to weigh more than people who don't. Red and white meats have been proven to contribute to heart disease,…
  23. 523.

    E-cigarettes should be banned in public places like cigarettes

    For

    • Nicotine is derived from tobacco. I am not saying that people should not be allowed to use these devices, I am saying they should not be allowed to use them in public around other people potentially putting other's health at risk. They have not proven that these devices are not…
    • The FDA is actually proposing extending its authority to cover additional products that meet the definition of a tobacco product under the proposed rule: Tobacco Products Deemed To Be Subject to the Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act. Currently FDA regulates cigarettes, cigarette…

    Against

    • The initial reason for the electronic cigarette was for people to stop smoking. Personally, I have seen so many people that benefited from it. Although it has nicotine, it does not have tobacco, and it doesn't burn. Vaporizing is and should be allowed in smoke-free places. Also…
    • No, because it is not an actual tobacco product
  24. 524.

    The US federal government should substantially increase public health aid to Sub-Saharan Africa

    For

    • Plan: The United States federal government should establish a Global Health Service to expand the capacity of community health workers in the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief focus countries to sub-Saharan Africa.

    Against

    • Sweet. Well my opponent has not refuted any of my arguments so please flow them all through. I have the sneaking suspicion my opponent my decide to attempt to refute all my points in his last speech so I have no chance to answer. If this happens please discard all of his…
    • You're doing so good....... You are really convincing me that I am such a horrible debater and you can ownz me. Keep up the good work. For the judges and voters please extend all of my arguments. Notice that my opponent drops them all by not responding and therefor they all…
  25. 525.

    Teens should be able to get birth control without parental consent

    For

    • The debate is about, Teens should be able to get birth control without their parents consent. Not STDS! I know that STD's are spreading throughout the nation, but you did not include how many babies are born with STD's. everydayheath.com I never meant that your dad is a…
    • You make very good points, but I never said that birth control prevents STD's. Also it is logical that if not used correctly it would be harmful. Also I never said that ALL teen girls would actually go and get it, but the one's that are willing to go get it. Your father might…

    Against

    • I understand what the debate is about, what I am showing though is that if birth control were to be available to all teenagers then STD cases would go up. Teenagers would be having sex and pregnancy rates may go down but because STD rates would go up is the reason why I am…
    • Quick clarifications:1) I never claimed you said that birth control doesnt protect against STDs, Im just showing that the health benefit of unlimited access to birth control would be very outweighed by the spread of STD's through sexually active teenagers2) I also never claimed…
  26. 526.

    Drinking water poses greater risk than breathing air

    For

    • I'll use this last round to summarize another point: climate change. Particle pollution can result in changes in the atmosphere (otherwise known as the greenhouse effect/global warming). These changes can cause cooling in certain areas of the globe, which shifts weather…
    • I'll focus on the health risks of air pollution this round. There are a few types of air pollutants, but the most severe are ozone and particle pollution. Exposure to ozone can cause accelerated aging of the lungs and aggravated lung conditions, such as bronchitis.[1] Particle…

    Against

    • Definitely the water we drink is more dangerous than the air we breathe. Water pollution is documented as a contributor to a wide range of human disorders. it also destroys the lives of many aquatic animals. clean drinking can be a normal thing for us but it is like a gift from…
  27. 527.

    The United States should ban cigarettes

    For

    • My adversary has to show that God does not exist for his argument to be valid He is also making me want to ram my head in the wall be accepting all of my debates. I shall shed tears of sadness now
    • A government"s responsibility to their citizens is as follows. The / A government role is to ensure the wellbeing of its citizens, and make the best calls accordingly. They have an obligation to protect and take care of their citizens, even if that means making calls that are…

    Against

    • Accept
    • God is the truth and I don't have to prove it. I only accepted your debate once.
  28. 528.

    Fast food is partly to blame for American obesity

    For

    • Studies show that children are much more active than adults because they have recesses and after school activities and adults must eat more than children, therefore proving your statement wrong. Also, the adults have the money to buy things they eat, so they are able to make…
    • "This is the best part of the day, when I get to be fat, on the bed, with my quart of Coke," states Morgan Spurlock, a man who when on a fast food binge for one month. Now, most people wouldn"t think twice about wanting to go on an all McDonalds diet for 30 days, but their…

    Against

    • Fast food contains some of the most harmful ingredients to our health. McDonalds and many other places gets their meat from disgusting slaughterhouses that are not taken care of. Watch food inc. the movie to get a documentary on what's the truth behind these major conpanies.…
    • Fast food is more popular than healthy foods, not only because its known commercials everywhere but the fact that its cheaper. Families with low income who can't provide their children with organic foods, will have to go to the alternative, which is cheap fast food. In other…
  29. 529.

    Alcohol should be prohibited again

    For

    • Wow, you copy and pasted that article on here. Economics of Prohibition Most of these could have been foreseen, but the field of economics was relatively new. Keynes's book of "The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money" wasn't published until 1936. Though these…
    • CATO Institute As far as consumption goes "it took years after repeal before consumption rates reached those of pre-prohibition." [1] Crime did increase during prohibition, but crime was on the rise before prohibition. [2] "Probably one of the most popular ideas of the time was…

    Against

    • Economics of Prohibition Prohibition's supporters were initially surprised by what did not come to pass during the dry era. When the law went into effect, they expected sales of clothing and household goods to skyrocket. Real estate developers and landlords expected rents to…
    • The executive summary from the Cato Institute sums it up very well: "The National prohibition of alcohol (1920-33)—the "noble experiment"—was undertaken to reduce crime and corruption, solve social problems, reduce the tax burden created by prisons and poorhouses, and improve…
  30. 530.

    The Center for Science in the Public Interest prioritizes vegetarianism over food safety

    For

    • My opponent has not refuted any of my contentions.
    • I accept my opponent's definitions, therefore I will not post my defintions Contention 1) CSPI promotes unhealthy food diets: It is well known that CSPI denounces fatty foods, but at the same time promotes high-carbohydrate foods. Studies have shown that high-carbohydrate foods…

    Against

    • I am Con to the resolution, "CSPI is more interested in spreading vegetarianism rather than food safety." A few quick definitions: CSPI: http://www.cspinet.org... vegetarianism: the principle or practice of excluding all meat and fish, and sometimes, in the case of vegans, all…
  31. 531.

    Cigarette packs should carry graphic warning pictures

    For

    • No apology necessary my man, it was an innocent mistake and you haven't wasted my time. Thanks for posting the debate, and I hope we can have a debate in the future that doesn't end like this one. Cheers.
    • I'm afraid I can't accept my opponent's change in resolution, despite that he's new to the site and it was an innocent mistake. The reason I can't accept the change in resolution is because I agree with my opponent that the under-the-counter law is ridiculous, and in my opinion…

    Against

    • Well to that, im afraid, leaves me with no option but to conceed to my oponent as, even though it was a small mistake, it was a stupid one, and I appologise for wasting my oponents time! At least we both a agree that the under the counter law is stupid! Thanks to everyone who…
    • Firstly can I just apologise, as I have sort of shot myself in the foot by not properly explaining my debate parameters, while I do not agree with the pictures on the back of cigarette packets I would as my opponent pointed out not want them removed, unless they were were…
  32. 532.

    Diet pills should be banned

    For

    • Okay, you are sure that if person will take diet pills and do some exercises will lose a weight easily. .. .but why no one thinks that it cause different consequenses? First of all, Ingredients in a Diet Pill Taking a closer look at the ingredients used in the average diet…
    • Hello everyone! I am new to debate.org so I apologize for any mistakes. I would like to propose a debate on the idea of diet pills. Nowadays diet pills became more and more popular. The testimonial on a leading diet website is gushing: "I lost all the weight I wanted and then…

    Against

    • Hi ! I am also new here! ^^ I would like to propose a debate on the idea of diet pills. >>Diet pills are made for those people who want to lose weight easily, it means that it also needs an exercise and proper diet. It is not directly said that taking in diet pills will…
    • THANK YOU !! So as you ^^ I didn't say SOME, I said regular exercises. How stupid those people who take it that they don't even know that it must take time and I think everything, anything needs a time to be work or to see the result, you know there's nothing quick here on…
  33. 533.

    Smoking should be banned in public areas

    For

    • You are welcome, thank you for joining me for this debate. The thing is, nobody is segregating smokers. You choose by your own free will to smoke, but those who are enjoying the "mainstream" as my opponent states, should not be forced to breathe in the dangerous particles.…
    • First off, you are welcome for posting the debate. But to business, you bring up your home country and state that smoking is prohibited among open spaces, but if you had designated smoking areas you would be happy as a sand boy in a desert. So what is wrong with the idea of…

    Against

    • Many thanks to my opponent for his last argument, which was undeniably well thought out, reasonable in its tone and seemingly convincing. Mr. Hanson is clearly a most worthy adversary. Nevertheless, it behoves me to highlight some serious flaws in his arguments, to whit: 1 -…
    • Thanks for continuing this debate, I appreciate it. As you may have realised, it is a subject close to my (at risk of cancer) heart! The thing is, though, by segregating smokers, who represent a sizable minority of the population, in social contexts, you are dividing friends…
  34. 534.

    Tobacco smoking should be restricted by law

    For

    • I will be arguing on the side of more extensive bans as opposed to more moderate ones. A near-total ban: one which allows for situations in which significant harm is not being caused. To make things more convenient, I will make a proposal which would fit what my resolution asks…
    • I believe tobacco smoking should be banned to whatever extent is necessary. This would not include a person smoking in the privacy of their own home and not in the presence of children or anyone not wishing to be exposed to the smoke. Simply put, the ban I propose makes tobacco…

    Against

    • I will be arguing against the extensive ban put forward by Yvette in favor of a moderate ban, which still protects the rights of all parties involved. To make our proposals easily discernible, I'll put forward mine as well instead of ripping apart hers. I propose that smoking…
    • Since we were separated at birth and have many of the same opinions, I have the feeling that this will be a fun and productive debate. My resolution is simple and easy to understand. I believe that tobacco rights are justifiable and necessary. However, there should be public…
  35. 535.

    Governments should fund needle exchange programmes

    For

    • Needle exchanges can help social services to locate addicts who are in need of treatment
    • Needle exchanges prevent the transmission of disease

    Against

    • Needle exchanges will increase the incidence of drug use
    • Needle exchanges cause crime
  36. 536.

    Physical fitness matters more than mental fitness

    For

    • Fit people are happy people
    • Physically fit people have better mental health and do better at academia

    Against

    • Depends on your goals in life.
    • Mental health can impact on physical health
  37. 537.

    Tobacco and alcohol should be banned

    For

    • Tobacco/Alcohol should be illegal because tobacco can cause extreme damage to your body and could cause lung cancer. And alcohol could not only harm the drunk person's mind, but it could also physically hurt anyone near them. All harmful drugs shouldn't even exist!
    • I have to admit, my opponent has brains. But I still believe that if cancer or other deaths happen the population could decrease and that's no good. So, the government should totally care about what people do to themselves. And what's more, children who actually watch their…

    Against

    • Will also forfeit this round.I urge voters to reject the notion.
    • I will also forfeit this round, to keep things even.
  38. 538.

    Smoking should be banned in all public places

    For

    • Smoking should be banned in public places. Smoking causes a major health concern not only for the smoker, but for the people around, too. About 53,800 people die from 'secondhand smoke.' Secondhand smoke is smoke from a cigarette, cigar, or pipe that is involuntarily inhaled,…

    Against

    • Multi_Pyrocytophage DID NOT forfeit this round.
    • What my opponent says is true - for a standard cigarette. With an e-cigarette, the problem can be averted.Smoking an e-cigarette is technically smoking. It contains fewer chemicals than the normal cigarette does, and it releases a tiny amount of smoke. This greatly reduces the…
  39. 539.

    Medical personnel should be prohibited from emigrating to developed countries

    For

    • In terms of practicality and safety sake of the aforementioned medical personnel, the resolution before the house must stand. However, before I get into some constructive I'd first like to refute what the Opposition as presented. The main point that the Opposition was trying to…

    Against

    • If my opponent could post a random comment briefly so we could move this debate into voting procedure, it would be much appreciated
    • I believe Side Government has argued the wrong case. He is arguing for prohibition, not against it, making all of their arguments moot and the need for refutation is not needed. How would you like to proceed?
  40. 540.

    Medicare should be provided free of charge

    For

    • yes there should is is extremely expensive here unlike Canada.

    Against

    • Like I said before Medicare is free.
    • I am not going to post any arguments until Con does because I dont want to waste my time.
  41. 541.

    The US should adopt improved Medicare for All

    For

    • -----Rebuttals----- Superior Insurance R1: Better Health Care Quality Neither the American College of Physicians or the Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care recommend mammograms for all women 40-50 (as your source implies). They have not been empirically shown to cut…
    • Thanks for your starting arguments JamesMadison. As per say the rules, in this round we will both attempt to rebut our opponent's starting arguments. R1: Improving Health Care Results I agree, we do not have a *general* market in healthcare. We have a market composed of bloated…

    Against

    • IntroductionAs I have agreed to not respond to Pro's R4 arguments here, I will simply finish responding to R2 and R3 and make concluding remarks.The Cost of SPA core argument in this debate is the cost of single payer. Pro has made cost a centerpiece of his argument in this…
    • I also pointed out that both of these systems are lacking in medical technology compared to the USA (MRIs and CT scanners specifically). In this round, I plan on going into more detail on the failings of both these systems. First, a 2007 study from the NBER compared Canadian…
  42. 542.

    Carbohydrates are a major cause of disease

    For

    • 1. It appears that you don't understand the basic principles of debate. You are supposed to address my statements, point by point. Giving your reasons for disagreeing with each point and offering alternatives to these ideas. You have done none of these things, thus far. The…
    • Just because a website is called 'Quack Watch', doesn't necessarily follow that they are there to stop fraudulent medical practises. We have to consider that the possible purpose of 'Quack Watch' may be to protect an already corrupt medical system from cheap and effective…

    Against

    • Thank you again for accepting the challenge. Let's go through the evidence and see what is stated. "A diet high in carbohydrates may increase the risk of pancreatic cancer in sedentary and overweight women," BMJ 2002;325:566 That could be any carbohydrate. Soft drinks comes to…
    • Akhenaten in another debate has cited that a mercola article that claims carbohydrates cause disease. "Carbohydrates cause nearly all age-related diseases." Kent Rieske I Con will argue that the hypothesis that Carbohydrates cause disease is false. Akhenaten Pro will reinforce…
  43. 543.

    Smoking and alcohol should be illegal

    For

    • i think it should be outlawed because i have personal things but still the law should stop people from killing theirself's

    Against

    • Thanks for the debate (or not). Please extend my arguments.
    • Just as I suspected. Extend my arguments por favor.
  44. 544.

    The use of palm oil is unhealthy and not beneficial

    For

    • I'm am truly sorry, I'm going to a AIMS sports tordament this week and I'm getting ready for a cherrleadign competition now the after that leaving for AIMS of I will have to forfeit this round and maybe the next two, deeply sorry. Perhaps I can do this debate again with you :)
    • The moot for this debate is that the use of Palm oil is unhealthy and isn't benifical. I, being pro agree with this statment. I define this moot to be that the use, to use or consume, of Palm oil, oil from several plants, usually palms, especially the West African oil palm.…

    Against

    • I will forgo this round as promised. Thanks.
    • Thanks for informing me, Jess. Real life is always more important. I will not take advantage of you by posting more arguments during this round.
  45. 545.

    Cooked food is less healthy than raw food

    For

    • Con's argument seems to be based upon two concepts. 1. Extermination of all bacteria How many bacteria do you think are on your keyboard right now? Ten, one hundred, five hundred? "Researchers have discovered that computer keyboards contained 7,500 bacteria per swab - much more…
    • Claim: Proteins when heated above a certain temperature become denatured. Warrant: "(2) Of, or pertaining to, a molecule (such as a protein or a nucleic acid) wherein its chemical structure is altered through chemical or physical means so that some of its original properties…

    Against

    • Thank you for your arguments. I will go onto my arguments, and rebuttals. FrameworkBOP is on both of us, Pro says nothing about framework. The debate is about the poison of cooked food, not bad things about cooked food. RebuttalsI will go onto the round two rebuttals.1. Fats…
    • Thank you for your argumentsFrameworkOkay, this debate is about if cooked food is toxic meaning if cooked food is poisonous. I will be taking Con that cooked food is not toxic or poison. If I fill the BOP which is shared, I win the debate. If my opponent has filled the BOP, he…
  46. 546.

    Diabetes and cancer research should receive more funding

    For

    • i have diabetes and this is a topic i happen to have a VERY strong opinion on this. i think that diabetics and people with cancer should be able to live their life happy and healthy. people should invest more money for finding a cure for both diseases

    Against

    • In light of numerous forfeitures, I hope this isn't too hard a debate to take sides on! Thanks in advance to all voters for their time. Cheers!
    • The sources I forgot to actually list at the end of my last argument: [1] https://www.diabeteshealth.com... [2] http://www.cancer.gov... [3] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov... On a different note, I would propose 5 rounds is simply too many rounds for a silent debate.
  47. 547.

    Everyone should be automatically enrolled in organ donation

    For

    • Under the current system, the final decision over whether an organ is donated is made by the family
    • There is a serious shortage of organs for transplant in the UK.

    Against

    • It will be difficult to opt-out
    • Some people will be distressed by the removal of their loved-ones' organs
  48. 548.

    A fat tax should be introduced

    For

    • "If a fat tax was ever introduced then the end result is likely to be that people will still buy junk food first but will pay more and thus will not be able to afford any healthier foods which could lead to an increase in obesity!' You hit the nail on the head here. Poor people…
    • I agree with you there. Healthcare is disproportinately disseminated to people with little to no sense of personal responsibility under this line of thinking. In your first set of arguements though you didn't mention trying to use that "fat tax" to offset the costs of their…

    Against

    • Personally I think people should not have to be told by their government what they can and cannot eat. Too much of any food will make you fat. The government should not be in the business of deciding which foods cross the fat tax line and which don't. Companies will try to buy…
    • Despite the staggering increase in numbers of people who are obese, there is an increasing tendency on the part of health professionals to take a "non-judgmental" approach to such problems. The Labour government"s Foresight report blamed the rise in obesity on an "obesogenic…
  49. 549.

    Congress should not pass a national health care system

    For

    • It was probably just my sheer intimidating masculine figure that scared her off. (If you knew me, you'd know I was kidding. )
    • I will leave my opponent to counter my arguments if she chooses to so later. There's still more rounds- the debate can go on!

    Against

    • Resolved : A National Health Care System should not be passed through Congress As Pro failed to properly state sources or define all parts of the definition, I would like to now do so, with all definitions from the Merriam-Webster Dictionary. national – although this is not the…
  50. 550.

    Childhood obesity should be considered a form of child abuse

    For

    • http://www.youtube.com... Here's another video. It isn't necessarily about childhood obesity, but it is a good video on obesity in America (and is somewhat entertaining). Child abuse is the physical, sexual, or emotional maltreatment or neglect of a child(ren). By neglecting to…
    • http://www.youtube.com... Childhood obesity has doubled in children and tripled in adolescents in the past 30 years. In 2010, more than 1/3 of children and adolescents were overweight or obese. We even have obese infants. Children and adolescents generally don't pick the…

    Against

    • To compare childhood obesity to child abuse is preposterous. In contradiction to my opponent's views, it is unfair to dictate how a child lives his or her life. Rather than hounding children about what they eat and how much they weigh, we should be encouraging them to feel…
    • "Society's opinion is the right opinion." To understand this phrase my opponent stated, we must first understand who "society" is. Defined by the dictionary, a society is a community with shared customs. By that standard, a high school can be a society. Here's a quick example…

How to use these debate topics

  • Vote, discuss, revote. Poll the room on the motion, give 5 minutes of discussion, then vote again and look at who changed their mind.
  • Four corners. Label corners strongly agree → strongly disagree; people move, then each corner makes its best case.
  • Switch sides. Halfway through, everyone argues the side they disagree with. It sharpens listening.

Run them live

Want every person to answer on their own phone, with a timer and a live leaderboard? Use these questions in an EngageSlide Vote · Discuss · Revote — free to start.

Tick questions on any page — your set is kept while you browse (or take the first 10 here) — and they become ready-to-play slides. What is EngageSlide?

More question collections

Questions adapted from args.me corpus (CC BY 4.0), edited for clarity. This collection may be reused under the same terms — see sources & licenses.